The Fermi Paradox: Fine Tuned Universe

Our universe is a strange place, with underlying rules we’re only just beginning to understand, but could the strangest thing of all about our Universe be that we are able to live here to observe it in the first place?

Join this channel to get access to perks:

Credits:
The Fermi Paradox: Fine-Tuned Universe
Episode 456; July 18, 2024
Produced, Narrated & Written: Isaac Arthur
Graphics:
Jeremy Jozwik
Select imagery/video supplied by Getty Images
Music Courtesy of Epidemic Sound
Lombus, "Cosmic Soup"
Stellardrone,"Red Giant", "The Divine Cosmos", "Eternity", "In Time"

[Furyhound]

The fundamental law of probability... No matter how impossible it is statistically, if its true, you can pound sand

[Afterlife-Boy]

this has been my fav channel since 2017. Of the three or four actually optimistic physicists on YouTube, Isaac is the most fun BY FAR.

[Zetverse]

Isaac Arthur and JMG videos are what I keep looking forward to every week. May our simulation overlords bless both of you and your crew with long lives.

[Roguescienceguy]

Alright, I've got my drink and a snack. Let's go

[tycho_m]

Honestly, at this point Isaac's channel is an oasis of optimistic poetic naturalism in a desert of AI generated, ad-driven, derivative, bland content. It's hard to express how much support I feel in this day and age from this one guy's wide-eyed love for STEM. You inspire hope for the future in a time where isolationism, declinism, fearmongering and virality define the majority of interpersonal discourse.

Thank you thank you thank you from the Netherlands <3

[-Tholos-]

So generous of you to support Planet Wild. 👏🏻 I’ve been a member for over a year now and really like the work they do.

[xBINARYGODx]

That saying about the puddle thinking the pothole it's in must have been made for it because it's the same exact shape it is, comes to mind.

[projectarduino]

Some of my favorite questions are “we love asking questions, and we’re not afraid to admit we don’t know the answers” types.

[VisiblyPinkUnicorn]

"I felt myself on the edge of the world, peering over the rim into a fathomless chaos of eternal night"

[kennickel]

Appreciated the allusion to "The Last Question"

[frankfowlkes]

The Cosmological Constant is the one that really blows me away. Being balanced to 10 to the 122 is greater than the odds of picking out one atom out of all in the atoms in the Universe which is around 10 to the 82. We are fortunate indeed to even exist!

[wk]

Militant Agnostic Club, “I don’t know and neither do you!”

[seriousmaran]

A person walking in a forest with no idea of direction tends to circle. They could end up wearing a path that they then follow. Essentially thinking the forest is endless when in reality it isn't anywhere near that big.

[cannonfodder]

Gonna have to rewatch this one a few times to be able to absorb all this information.

Still an excellent and thought provoking episode as always, Isaac.

[seanhewitt]

The beauty of your logic and how you use it to observe our world and universe is... exquisite. Thank you for sharing your worldview with us.

[colinsmith]

Love this topic. Many years ago I heard about the 'fine tuned universe' idea and quickly concluded there are 4 possible explanations:
1.) Our universe is lone and unique, randomly generated, and just happened to come out just right. This is the only answer we can actually run statistics on. A Harvard professor did so years ago, and while I don't remember the exact value, it was MASSIVELY exponential in scientific notation and represented basically the largest jackpot in the universe.
2.) Our universe is just one of a vast multiverse, possibly infinite. Each universe is randomly created, but only those with 'right' values produce life capable of noticing. This requires faith in a vast, infinitely powerful universe-generating mechanism.
3.) Our universe isn't random and was specially created by some higher power to create life as we know it. This is the 'god' option, and requires faith in such a higher power with a plan.
4.) Our universe isn't random and there are some as-of-yet undiscovered principles that dictate that these forces MUST be what they are and couldn't be anything else. This requires faith in as-of-yet undiscovered science.

In short, three of the four require faith in SOMETHING. The only one that doesn't requires the single most improbable circumstances that we have ever conceived of, to my knowledge. All this to say that: Science can't prove or disprove God, but it can certainly leave Him on the table of possibilities.

[niveketihw]

Loved the energy in this one. Isaac sounds as excited as ever. :o)

[sigstackfault]

If we weren't in a universe in which intelligent life could form, we wouldn't be sitting here discussing it, now would we!

[Eldagusto]

Amazing episode! I’ve had so many questions you answered while I couldn’t even coherently put the questions to words! I rewound and relistened to to part so frequently to make sure I got it all. Great ep! I need to also listen to this week in space!

[englishcoach]

Thanks for frequently posting content. Although I don't get much objectivity from your channel, the way you delve is absolutely enthralling. I love your imagination and knowledge of science and science fiction to bring us top notch well narrated possibilities for the universe. Those snacks are really hitting my kuiper belt though.