Muslim CHALLENGES Sam Shamoun With A TRICKY Trinity Question? [Debate] | John 20:17

#Islam #Muslim #Quran

[IndependentArmz]

I'm thankful MY GOD isn't easy to understand. I'm thankful MY GOD is not like me. I'm thankful MY GOD's thoughts are not like mine. Praise Jesus Christ!! Praise The Father!! Praise be The Holy Spirit!! We stand in awe of your magnificence!! We stand in awe of your glory!! Thank you LORD for knowing what needed to be done to redeem us from ourselves. Praise you for thine is the kingdom, the power, and the glory forever!!

[SacredReason]

GLORY BE TO THE FATHER, TO THE SON, AND TO THE HOLY SPIRIT, ONE GOD ALMIGHTHY. HALLELUJAH. AMEN.

[RockyGuerrero]

Sam is cooking these stone kissers 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣☮♥✝

[jacobfavret]

I had a Muslim try to argue with John 20:22-23 that the disciples can forgive sins like Jesus therefore He is not God, and He ended up proving the Trinity right there 😂 the tap dance after was epic, he ran before I could nail him down.

[bricemakes]

Sam obliterated the clown 🤡 . He didn't come humble and thought he did something. People always try to distort the Bible and it shows they are under demonic oppression (influence) to go against the true word of God.

[GODHimself_]

guy- that's ridiculous..
sam- yes muhammad is ridiculous 😂

[Creasey_F]

sam and avery are two of my favorite people on youtube rn.

[joelvillarta]

Tnx u bro Sam @ bro God logic continueos preaching d word of almighty God 4 Christianity God bless u always

[brock]

I'm stealing that stone kisser thing. That's gold.

[RashidYoosoof]

Many people criticize or ignore oral history when many elements of religious traditions, including Christianity, have relied heavily on oral transmission before being committed to writing.

The Gospels, for instance, were written decades after the events they describe, and much of what is known about early Christianity was passed down orally before being recorded.

While oral history has its limitations, it's a common and accepted method for preserving and transmitting religious teachings across various faiths.

Moreover, the reliance on eyewitness accounts isn't necessarily the only method to verify truth in religious traditions.

What about the term "earwitness"? If oral testimony is dismissed due to its nature, does that also imply we should dismiss testimonies that were heard and then relayed by others, even if those accounts have been preserved in written form?

Earwitness accounts, much like eyewitness testimonies, carry significant weight in understanding historical and religious narratives.

They involve direct experience of hearing a message or event, which can be just as powerful as seeing something firsthand.

In the context of the Quran, oral transmission has played a crucial role in its preservation. The entire Quran was memorized by the Prophet Muhammad and subsequently by his followers, ensuring that it was passed down through generations with precise accuracy.

Today, this tradition continues, with millions of Muslims memorizing the Quran in its entirety. Unlike other religious texts that may have multiple versions or interpretations, the Quran has maintained a single, consistent version since its revelation.

The concept of earwitness is further reinforced today through the recitation of the Quran, especially during Ramadan, when it is recited from cover to cover in mosques worldwide, including the Kaaba in Mecca.

In the digital era, these recitations are often telecast live, allowing people across the globe to listen and become earwitnesses to the same recitation.

This global phenomenon underscores the enduring power and reliability of oral transmission, particularly when it comes to the preservation of sacred texts.

The live broadcasting of these recitations in real-time provides a collective earwitness experience that transcends geographical boundaries, connecting millions of believers to the same message and reinforcing the unbroken chain of transmission that has safeguarded the Quran for over fourteen centuries.

[Olga____]

2Кор 13:13: "Благодать Господа нашего Иисуса Христа, и любовь Бога Отца, и общение Святого Духа со всеми вами. Аминь."

[peacemaker___]

Where can I find this website with the interlinear transliterations?

[RashidYoosoof]

The Kaaba, located in the holy city of Mecca, Saudi Arabia, is the most sacred site in Islam.

It is a cube-shaped structure that serves as the qibla, the direction towards which Muslims around the world face during their daily prayers.

The history of the Kaaba is deeply intertwined with Islamic tradition and the story of the Black Stone, a significant artifact set into one of its corners.

According to Islamic belief, the Kaaba was originally built by the Prophet Adam as a house of monotheistic worship.

It was later rebuilt by the Prophet Ibrahim (Abraham) and his son Ismail (Ishmael) under divine guidance.

The Black Stone, known as "al-Hajar al-Aswad" in Arabic, was placed in the Kaaba during this reconstruction.

Islamic tradition holds that the Black Stone was originally a white stone from paradise, which turned black due to the sins it absorbed from people touching it.

The Kaaba has undergone numerous renovations throughout history, reflecting different periods and rulers in Mecca.

The Quraysh tribe, including the Prophet Muhammad's family, maintained the Kaaba before Islam.

When Muhammad began preaching Islam, the Kaaba was a center of polytheistic worship with numerous idols. In 630 CE, following the conquest of Mecca, Muhammad cleansed the Kaaba of these idols, rededicating it as a monotheistic sanctuary.

The discovery of the Zamzam well, a significant element of the Kaaba's history, is rooted in the story of Hagar (Hājar in Arabic) and her son Ismail.

According to Islamic tradition, after being left in the barren desert by Prophet Ibrahim as a test of faith, Hagar ran between the hills of Safa and Marwah in search of water.

In her desperation, the angel Jibril (Gabriel) appeared and struck the ground, causing water to gush forth from the spot, which became known as the Zamzam well.

This miraculous well provided sustenance and is considered a symbol of divine mercy. The water of Zamzam is revered and sought after by pilgrims to this day for its spiritual and physical benefits.

The Kaaba is now the focal point of the Hajj pilgrimage, one of the Five Pillars of Islam, requiring all Muslims who are physically and financially able to undertake a pilgrimage to Mecca at least once in their lifetime.

During Hajj, pilgrims perform the Tawaf, a ritual involving the circumambulation of the Kaaba. The Black Stone plays a key role in this ritual; pilgrims strive to kiss or touch the stone, emulating the actions of the Prophet Muhammad.

The significance of the Kaaba and the Black Stone extends beyond the physical structure and object.

They symbolize the unity of the Muslim community and the continuity of monotheistic worship from the time of Adam and Ibrahim to the present day.

Despite the lack of explicit mention of the Black Stone in the Quran, its veneration is based on the Hadith and the practices of the Prophet Muhammad, making it a deeply revered element of Islamic tradition.

One of the central practices tied to the Kaaba is the five daily prayers, known as Salat, which are spread throughout the world from this sacred site.

Muslims around the globe face the Kaaba during these prayers, underscoring its importance in daily worship.

These prayers are observed at specific times of the day: Fajr (pre-dawn), Dhuhr (midday), Asr (afternoon), Maghrib (sunset), and Isha (night).

The synchronization of these prayers, all oriented towards the Kaaba, emphasizes the unity and discipline within the Muslim Ummah (community).

In addition to the daily prayers, there is a special congregational prayer every Friday called Jumu'ah.

This prayer replaces the regular Dhuhr prayer and includes a sermon (khutbah) delivered by the imam.

It is a significant weekly event where Muslims gather in mosques to perform the prayer in congregation, reinforcing the communal aspects of worship and the importance of the Kaaba as the spiritual focal point.

The Kaaba serves as the spiritual focal point for Muslims worldwide.

For those in locations where they cannot see the sun during the day or the sunset at night, it is advised to follow the prayer times of neighboring countries or the prayer times at the Kaaba.

Astronauts and submariners, who may be unable to determine the Qibla and prayer times based on their unique circumstances, can also rely on the prayer times at the Kaaba as a reference.

In regions where non-standard pronunciations of the Quran are practiced, individuals are encouraged to quietly follow the more standard practices if they are aware of them.

This approach helps maintain unity and consistency in recitation. There is a trend towards using the Hafs An Aasim recitation style universally, as it is the standard method used at the Kaaba.

This style ensures consistent meanings in the Quranic text across the Muslim world.

Hafs An Aasim is the most widely used recitation style globally, particularly in the Arab world, Southeast Asia, and parts of Africa.

In contrast, Warsh An Nafi' is more common in North and West Africa, such as Morocco and parts of Algeria. At the Kaaba, the Hafs An Aasim method is used for recitation, and it is the standard for public recitations and recordings in Saudi Arabia and many other parts of the Muslim world.

The Kaaba holds a central place in the Islamic faith for several reasons. It is considered the most sacred site in Islam, and Muslims around the world face towards it during their prayers, an act known as Qibla.

The Kaaba is believed to have been built by the Prophet Ibrahim (Abraham) and his son Ismail (Ishmael) as a house of monotheistic worship.

The structure is also the focal point of the Hajj pilgrimage, which is one of the Five Pillars of Islam and a mandatory religious duty for Muslims who are physically and financially able to undertake it.

The Kaaba symbolizes the unity of the Muslim Ummah (community) as all Muslims, regardless of their geographical location, face the same direction in prayer.

Its significance is not just religious but also cultural, as it represents the historical and spiritual heritage of Islam.

The Quran is recited from memory and broadcast globally, proving the preservation of its contents.

The Black Stone at the corner of the Kaaba serves as the starting and ending point of circumambulations.

If there were no mark or indication of the Kaaba's location, it could potentially be misappropriated or lose its unique status.

This could lead to it being "hijacked" or used for purposes that do not align with Islamic teachings, similar to how the Vatican City serves as a religious and political center for the Catholic Church.

The preservation of the Kaaba's identity and sanctity is crucial to maintaining its role as the central symbol of Islamic faith and unity.

[markimarrk]

some people just don't want the truth 🤦

[BornAgain]

lol every verse in the bible buries islam.

[RashidYoosoof]

9. The doctrine of the Trinity is indeed a central tenet in Christianity. It describes God as one being in three distinct persons: the Father, the Son (Jesus Christ), and the Holy Spirit.

This concept is foundational to mainstream Christian theology and is often expressed through the Nicene Creed, a statement of faith that articulates the belief in the Trinity.

In Christianity, The Father is seen as the creator and sustainer of the universe.

The Son, Jesus Christ, is believed to be both fully divine and fully human. Christians hold that Jesus is the incarnate Word of God who came into the world to offer salvation through his death and resurrection.

The Holy Spirit is considered the presence of God active in the world and in the lives of believers, guiding, comforting, and empowering them.

The Trinity is considered a mystery in Christian theology because it is a concept that transcends human understanding.

It asserts that while there is only one God, He exists in three co-equal and co-eternal persons, each of whom is fully God. This means that the Father is not the Son, the Son is not the Holy Spirit, and the Holy Spirit is not the Father, yet they are all one God.


Islam, on the other hand, strongly emphasizes Tawhid, the concept of the absolute oneness and indivisibility of God (Allah). Muslims believe that God is singular and unique, with no partners, equals, or divisions.

The Quran explicitly rejects the idea of the Trinity or any form of plurality in God's nature. This rejection is based on the principle that God is utterly transcendent and cannot be compared to His creation.

Key points in Islamic theology regarding are as per the following.

Muslims follows strict monotheism (Tawhid) that is, God is One and has no partners or equals. Any division or association of partners with God is considered shirk, the gravest sin in Islam.

Jesus in Islam or Isa in Arabic is highly revered as a prophet and the Messiah, he is not considered divine.

Muslims believe Jesus was a messenger of God, born of the Virgin Mary, performed miracles, but was not crucified as Christians believe. Instead, it is believed that he was taken up to heaven and will return at the end of times.

Rejection of the Trinity The Quran explicitly denies the concept of the Trinity and the divinity of Jesus. Verses such as Surah Al-Ikhlas (112:1-4) emphasize God's oneness and unique nature, while others, like Surah An-Nisa (4:171), admonish Christians against saying "three" in reference to God.

The theological divergence between Christianity and Islam on this issue is profound. For Christians, the Trinity is an essential and non-negotiable doctrine, while for Muslims, the oneness of God is equally non-negotiable and fundamental to their faith.

These differing views reflect deeper differences in the understanding of God's nature and the role of Jesus.

[razem]

1. in JOHN 20.17 JC clearly states that the Father is God and in JOHN 20.31 John defines who JC is

2. Thomas did NOT say "my Lord and God" but "MY Lord and MY God" i.e. Thomas first addressed Jesus and then the Father whom he saw through Jesus, in the sense of "whoever sees me sees the Father"
JOHN 12.45, JOHN 14.9

3. even if Thomas called JC God, then in the sense of JOHN 10.34

4. why doesn't Peter say that JC is God?
MT 16.15-17, MK 8.24, LK 9.20, ACTS 2.22-24

5. what did Thomas believe according to JC in JOHN?
• that JC is God
or
• that JC was resurrected or raised by God

[atato]

Hope is restored when you see there’s sam and avery for years to come for Cristian apologetics.

[RashidYoosoof]

The question of who wrote the Quran is intricately linked with the foundational beliefs and traditions of Islam.

According to Islamic doctrine, the Quran is considered the literal word of God (Allah) as revealed to the Prophet Muhammad over a period of approximately 23 years, starting in 610 CE.

The revelations were delivered to Muhammad through the angel Jibril (Gabriel). This process is fundamental to understanding the oral and written traditions surrounding the Quran.

The Quran was initially transmitted orally. Muhammad, who was known to be illiterate (ummi), received the revelations in Arabic and memorized them.

He recited these revelations to his companions, who also memorized them. This oral transmission was crucial in an era where literacy was not widespread, and it ensured that the message could be disseminated widely and preserved accurately.

The memorization and oral recitation of the Quran continue to be a significant practice in Islam, known as "Tajweed, " which refers to the correct pronunciation and articulation of the Quranic text.

While the oral transmission of the Quran was predominant, the revelations were also documented in written form during Muhammad's lifetime.

His scribes, including notable companions such as Zayd ibn Thabit, would write down the verses on various materials available at the time, such as parchment, bones, and palm leaves.

This dual approach of oral and written preservation was vital for ensuring the accuracy and consistency of the Quranic text.

After Muhammad's death in 632 CE, the need for a unified written version of the Quran became more pressing.

This need arose due to the rapid expansion of the Muslim community, the diversity of dialects, and the concern for preserving the exact words of the Quran.

The first caliph, Abu Bakr, initiated the compilation of the Quran into a single written manuscript, led by Zayd ibn Thabit. This compilation gathered all available written materials and cross-referenced them with the memories of those who had memorized the Quran (Hafiz).

The final version was kept with Hafsa, the daughter of the second caliph, Umar, and one of Muhammad's widows.

Under the third caliph, Uthman ibn Affan, the written Quran was standardized. Uthman commissioned a committee, again led by Zayd ibn Thabit, to produce several copies of the Quran based on the original manuscript.

These copies were sent to various regions within the growing Islamic empire to ensure uniformity in the recitation and written text. This effort was particularly important to avoid discrepancies and maintain the integrity of the Quranic message.

The history of the Quran’s transmission highlights the interplay between oral and written traditions in Islam.

The oral recitation of the Quran is highly valued, with millions of Muslims worldwide memorizing it in its entirety.

This tradition underscores the importance of preserving the precise pronunciation and recitation style, as variations can lead to different interpretations.

The written Quran serves as the definitive reference, ensuring that the oral recitations remain accurate.

This meticulous preservation is further reflected in the cultural and religious practices associated with the Kaaba, the most sacred site in Islam.

Located in Mecca, Saudi Arabia, the Kaaba is not only the direction (Qibla) towards which Muslims pray but also a symbol of the unity of the Muslim community.

The Kaaba houses the Black Stone, believed to have been placed there by the Prophet Ibrahim (Abraham) and his son Ismail (Ishmael).

The Kaaba’s role in Islamic tradition is closely tied to the Quran, as the rituals performed during Hajj, such as the Tawaf (circumambulation), are guided by the teachings in the Quran and Hadith (sayings of the Prophet).

The Quran’s compilation and the Kaaba’s centrality in Islamic worship are intertwined with the concept of a single, unchanging divine revelation.

This belief in the Quran's divine origin and perfect preservation is foundational to Islamic theology. It distinguishes the Quran from other religious texts, which may have undergone various edits and translations over time.

The Quran's consistency across centuries, regions, and cultures is seen as a testament to its divine protection and the meticulous care taken by early Muslims to preserve it.

The Quran, as per Islamic belief, was revealed by Allah to the Prophet Muhammad and was preserved both orally and in written form.

The process involved a collaborative effort by Muhammad's companions and early Muslim scholars to ensure the Quran’s accuracy and uniformity.

The Kaaba's role, along with the practice of memorizing and reciting the Quran, underscores the deep reverence Muslims have for the text and its teachings.

This careful preservation of the Quran has ensured its consistency and integrity, making it a cornerstone of Islamic faith and practice.

[Belief_Before_Glory]

The Trinity is True:
"The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, God’s love, and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be with you all. Amen."—2 Corinthians 13:14
"And God saith, 👉‘Let Us [PLURAL] make man in Our image, according to Our likeness...’ And God prepareth the man in His image; in the image of God 👉He [SINGULAR] prepared him, a male and a female He prepared them. — Genesis 1:26-27
"Go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of 👉the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit" —Matthew 28:19

✳️"because three are who are testifying in the heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Spirit, and these -- the three -- are one" — 1 John 5:7
👇
✳️Even if 1 John 5:7 is removed from every Bible, the same teaching is still found in the Bible:

👉1. Here we have the Holy Spirit testifying about Jesus:
“When the Counselor has come, whom I will send to you from the Father, the Spirit of truth, who proceeds from the Father, he will testify about me." —John 15:26 📌Notice the Spirit proceeds from the Father for they are One.

👉2. The Father testifies of Jesus:
"The Father himself, who sent me, has testified about me..." —John 5:37

👉3. Jesus testifies of Himself:
"I am one who testifies about myself, and the Father who sent me testifies about me." —John 8:18

Jesus & the Father are One:
"I and the Father are one."
—John 10:30
👉There are Three who testify & they are One! It's staying in my bible.
"Without controversy, the mystery of godliness is great..." —1 Timothy 3:16
All the best! 💜