Trying *Almost* Every Kind of Vegan Butter (+ Baking Test) // Plant-Based Butter Review & Taste Test

We try *almost* every kind of vegan butter on the market in the States. What's the best tasting when used as a spread? How does each perform in baked goods?

✹Products Mentioned✹
Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread
Simple Truth Organic Plant-Based Buttery Spread
Country Crock Plant Butter - Avocado Oil
Miyoko's Creamery Cultured Vegan Butter
Miyoko's Creamery Cultured Vegan Butter made w/ Oatmilk
Melt Organic Butter Spread
Pureblends Avocado Oil Plant-Based Butter
Milkadamia Buttery Spread
Califia Farms Plant Butter w/ Avocado Oil
Forager Project Organic Dairy-Free Butter

✹ More Videos ✹

✹ Find Me! ✹

Instagram | @sarahsvegkitchen
TikTok | @sarahsvegkitchen

✹ Contact Me! ✹

✹ Fave Things ✹

0:00 what is the best brand of vegan butter?
0:55 Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread
2:45 Simple Truth Organic Plant-Based Buttery Spread
4:51 Country Crock Plant Butter w/ Avocado Oil
7:55 Miyoko's Creamery European Style Cultured Vegan Butter
11:30 Miyoko’s Creamery Cultured Vegan Butter (made w/ oat milk)
12:50 Melt Organic Butter Made with Plants
14:24 Pure Blends Avocado Oil Plant-Based Butter
15:45 Milkadamia Buttery Spread - Salted
18:55 Califia Farms Plant Butter w/ Pressed Avocado Oil
20:37 Forager Organic Dairy-free Buttery Spread
23:03 what are our favorite vegan butters?
25:42 how to bake with vegan butter
31:23 which vegan butter makes the best cookies? (taste test)
40:19 our favorite cookies
41:40 outro

✹ Affiliate Disclosure ✹

When you make a purchase through my affiliate/referral links, you occasionally allow me to earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting this channel!

[milkadamia]

We came across your non-dairy butter review today. (We are always on the lookout for anything that references any of our milkadamia products and are excited to learn how they stack up). We are happy you enjoyed our butta taste as much as we do. We laughed when you said you consumed the rest of the Baggett using our Butta; we are always doing that! For us, bread is just an excuse to eat more butta.

Thank you for such an honest appraisal of the vegan butter world - we are okay with bougie. We know our choice to avoid using Palm Oil adds to the manufacturing complexity and thus price. While milkadamia Butta Bing Butta Bloom may feel like it cost an arm and a leg, using Palm Oil is costing us the Earth.

Keep up the impartial objectivity and authenticity!

[ericamarie]

I appreciate the level of detail... can you do: cream cheese? Sausages? Cheese shreds? Mac and cheese

[marystestkitchen]

thank you for your service omg so many butters! I thought we were doing pretty good in Canada but the selection you're getting is amazing!

[JaeC]

y'all are amazing lol. i cant believe i watched yall eat butter for 45 minutes and was PURELY entertained the whole time

[margarett_b]

Also, let's appreciate how much time Sarah spent baking all these cookies. Guys, she puts her heart into making these videos!

[gonewiththekale]

Miyoko’s is the best. I use it on all my parents’ meat-eating friends and NOBODY can tell the difference. The only thing that happens is their eyeballs get big and almost fall out of their head when I tell them it’s vegan, lol. It’s awesome because then they are enthusiastic to try OTHER vegan delights right after💚

[alainadacosta]

Y'all are both looking really cute with the colored hair, love the red on you Sarah :)! I was using earth balance but I recently got really inexpensive dairy free butter at aldi! It's called countryside creamery ~ haven't used it much/for baking yet though

[emilyrosejacobsen]

Can you post the recipe for the single-serving cookies?? I would love to just be able to make two cookies!

[MichaelMcNeeley]

For those concerned about buying organic and/or ethical palm oil, I’d recommend getting Earth Balance’s organic buttery spread. Last I read, the organic palm fruit is sourced from a region where orangutans don’t live. It doesn’t come in sticks but bakes just fine. The flavor is still classic Earth Balance imo.

[ChrisMichel]

The country crock almond oil one is my fav of the three country crock butters!! Tastes the most like butter to me!

[msprairierd]

Oh my gosh .. I almost fell out of my chair when Sarah said “it tastes like the bird aisle smells in the pet store”.. I bought the Forager Project buttery spread and didn’t like it and wasn’t sure what it reminded me of... I am a fan of the organic Earth Balance ..thanks for sharing .. love your videos

[kates]

I was JUST trying to figure out if it was the butter that was messing with my cookies thank you so much 😭❤️

[MKristine]

Did anyone else have to pause half way through to make buttered toast? 😂

[tiinah]

I live in Finland, so I'm not going to find any of these products in the stores nearby - yet here I am, watching a 40-minute long video describing different types of butter just bc I love you guys

[pintobean]

Myokos is my personal fav!
Comes in a box rather than plastic container and minimal clean ingredients! Plus tastes amazing. ♥️♥️😍

[meltorganic]

WOW! Hi Sarah & Eric. I can't believe I haven't come across this video before now. I love this comparison, including a nice variety of vegan butters, and I also enjoyed how some of these tastes brought back memories from your childhood. I hope you can try your cookie recipe again with our Baking Sticks. The sticks formulation is made without Canola, and Flaxseed Oil. This reduction in liquid oils makes the % of solid oils (Organic Coconut and Organic Palm Fruit Shortening) greater, allowing for it to remain a bit more solid, and your cookies might bake a little bit taller? Thanks for posting a fun and informative video to watch. I Subscribed now, so I won't be missing out for so long any more. :)

[amberpatschureck]

Eric's salt rant speaks to me soul. Love this taste test. So comprehensive. I'm an og earth balance girl myself. Partial to the red container, soy free...I just like the flavor a bit better than the yellow. Also I want to by Forager butter just to see what PetCo tastes like. Bravo guys!

[michellebeckham]

Miyoko’s garlic parm spread is incredible! I was literally eating it with a spoon! Love her plain butter as well, and I always have Earth Balance on hand, love to bake with it.

[judithrussell]

Wow, that's a big choice. I live in country Australia and have very limited options but I can get Naturli, which is a Danish brand and really good. It has shea butter, almond butter and carrot juice amongst others. It tastes like dairy butter to me, but it has been a long time.

[alyssawood]

"This tastes like something.." "Garbage?" Lmao I'm glad I'm not the only one who doesn't care for Califia farms. Only thing I like is their one black cold Nothing else from them does it for me lol