Man's Got the Blue Spruce Blues! | Part 2

preview_player
Показать описание
William claims tree trimmer Anthony accidentally cut down his blue spruce!

The Original! There’s only ONE Judge Judy. Visit our website for where to watch, weekdays.

#JudgeJudy
Рекомендации по теме
Комментарии
Автор

As soon as the plaintiff produced the receipt for the locust tree stump, I saw red flags. Plaintiff's getting greedy.

skg
Автор

Plaintiff showed invoice for stump removal for "Locust tree". Said he got the wrong invoice. The question I have is, If I call someone to remove two stumps from my yard, why would the contractor give me two separate invoices instead of listing the two stump removals on one invoice?

lat
Автор

I'm sorry, I am not buying plaintiff's "Oh I brought the wrong receipt" Yeah, right. Not bloody likely.

brocktoon
Автор

I actually believe the defendant. I think the husband was playing both sides. I think he told the defendant one thing and his wife another because he knew she wouldnt be okay with it lol regardless, the defendant did make a pretty big mistake.

katherineduke
Автор

The defendant made a mistake and admitted it. And tried to put it right. The plaintiff's got greedy and wanted 3 times more than they were entitled to. So a Fair judgement 👍🏻

elizabethgalligan
Автор

I definitely believe the defendant, his story is way to detailed.

beautifulleo
Автор

Yeah, plaintiff was getting greedy with wanting three trees. That's why they are here.

jeffreyclinard
Автор

I believe the defendant about him saying his wife wouldn't let him. He's just denying now because he doesn't want to get into trouble with his wife. He wouldn't make that comment up if he was lying.

jenniferweed
Автор

Defendant prob made a mistake but then the plaintiff wanted like 10k worth of work for nothing as an apology

whismerify
Автор

He knew he brought the wrong receipt. I believe the defendant. He was to detailed about his conversation with the plaintiff.

cdelane
Автор

I think the plaintiff tried to make a mistake a lifetime of debt to the defendant.

NOTHEOTHERGUY
Автор

Byrd was earning his pay today with all of that going back and forth lol.

kylinjohnson
Автор

I believe the Defendant. He was trying to make it right and I'm sure they had agreed. The wife probably made him suing the Defendant.

monicavillarreal
Автор

I believe the defendant, but at the end of the day, I don't think that $2500 was that unfair of a judgement. But then again, I AM NOT A BLUE SPRUCE EXPERT!! Just clarifying...

jefft
Автор

Someone was trying to hoodwink Judge Judy! Scandalous😂

Elizabeth_lowkeyluxuries
Автор

Yeah, nice try by bringing the wrong repceipt, but couldn't fool judge Judy!

joey-qc
Автор

The plaintiff was padding the amount of his claim, provided incorrect pictures, and provided incorrect invoices. So basically he is a liar. The defendant seemed honest and reliable. Too bad his team got the wrong address. I would have given the plaintiff $500. I don't like liars.

BiterAvid
Автор

I believe the defendant on this one. This is the 2nd case Ive seen where the husband knew about the landscaping. The wife becomes furious, and then the husband prentends not to know a thing, and sues to save his own behind.

kevinalleyne
Автор

The defendant made an mistake and owned it and tried to make it right. The plaintiff’s were excessive in the amount they were requesting and I believe the defendant did the work he claimed..

damnnerves
Автор

I bet he thought he will force the defendant to redo his entire yard, plant a forest of 32 Ft trees AND landscape it for the rest of his life

gabs