Sorry Remiel I'm with Xelzaz on this one.

[noirhelios]

Ah, good old moral grey. Personally always felt bad for Sinding, but it could go either way depending on whether Sinding got lycanthropy willingly or not. If not, he makes it clear he'll stay on his own from then on which can be pretty torturous on its own, but if so, putting him down would be considered karma. If only cause the afterlife is confirmed to exist in the Elder Scrolls, so we actually know where he'd end up when he dies lol

[yRaven.]

Me too... WAIT IS THAT A COOL RING? Sry Xelzaz, Hircine won that one.

[aloysius]

Redcap will have the same point if you also bring him

[thedivinenamekian]

Did you choose to spare sinding, or kill him?