Pixel-Peeping - Adobe Lightroom's AI DeNoise Vs DxO PureRAW, Topaz DeNoise and Luminar Noiseless AI

preview_player
Показать описание
I've been crunching the numbers - a direct comparison of Adobe Lightroom's amazing new AI denoise tool versus DxO PureRAW 2023, Topaz DeNoise AI and Luminar Neo's Noiseless AI. Four very different images used for testing.
Рекомендации по теме
Комментарии
Автор

Very enlightening video, Andy! As a DxO PureRAW 3 owner, I was fascinated at how the setting change from Prime XD to Prime could sometimes make for a better image. I will try both ways on complex images from now on.

the-pixel-whisperer
Автор

Cheers Andy, Certainly saved me a lot of work on comparisons. I have some low light images I took in March that where a mess when I edited them. Just retried them in lightroom with the noise reduction and wow so much better. I had been contemplating getting Topaz AI, but in light of what I have seen here, I think I will hold on that. Thanks for your work on this, much appreciated

👍

paulcooper
Автор

Did you open as a smart object in photoshop when you tried raw files through topaz. ?

markrigg
Автор

Have to say kudos to Adobe. Very nice.
A couple of questions if I may, Andy.
Firstly, does it look to you like Adobe have finally catered for the unique Fuji sensor (i.e., no worms) and secondly, is it possible to reduce the sharpening on the DxO XD algorithm to help reduce the over processed look?

dungbeetle.
Автор

Been a topaz user for over a year and when I tried dxo I was left wondering if it's even the same photo. The ability to not only remove noise but enhance/bring back details takes a giant shit on the face of topaz. This Adobe thingy does great job removing noise. But I miss the detail boost. If dxo pureraw is too aggressive, one can use photolab and move the sliders around to ultimate satisfaction. I assume Adobe will in the future bring more features. It just takes time. Which is ultimately good, then they don't produce garbage like some of the other companies.

_systemd
Автор

Every photo can take a variety of tweaks to get right, and Topaz DeNoise absolutely rules.

jonasweiss