Why It's So Hard for Meta, PayPal and X to Build a Super App Like WeChat | WSJ

Meta. PayPal. X. All of these tech companies have made attempts at a “super app” in the U.S., following the success of WeChat in China, but have yet to get one off the ground. Tech leaders have struggled to combine elements like social media, messaging, payment and more into one place. So what’s holding the U.S. back from having a super app available?

WSJ explains why, despite challenges, companies still see it as their holy grail product.

0:00 App efficiency
0:37 The appeal
2:18 U.S. issues
4:03 Regulation
4:48 What’s next?

News Explainers
Some days the high-speed news cycle can bring more questions than answers. WSJ’s news explainers break down the day's biggest stories into bite-size pieces to help you make sense of the news.

#Superapp #WeChat #WSJ

[ven]

The US/EU shouldn't want a single app with access to literally all of their identity, finance, and other security information. It creates a single point of failure that poses a major security threat to customers when that app is infiltrated

[johnl.]

Americans and Europeans (and others) already think big technology companies have too much power and lack of privacy so a Super App is a no go.

[Breaking]

While it is true that China has made significant strides in the development and adoption of super apps like WeChat, it is important to consider the unique factors that contribute to their success. China's digital landscape, regulatory environment, and consumer behavior differ significantly from those in the United States.

[ankurghosh]

Meta is trying to do the same thing in India with WhatsApp. Introduced payments, communities, channels, avatars and what not. It's downright scary what most people don't realize with an attitude of "I have nothing to hide"

[DawnPatrol]

We have this in the usa and it’s called iOS. Imessage, Apple health, Apple Pay, etc... Apple is the tech giant collecting all of our data the same as WeChat (if not more), but it’s just packaged a little differently.

[mrrmn]

"Can you grab me a coffee?"

"Grab your own coffee."

No super-app required.

[AgentX-dhlf]

Whatsapp in India has Chats, Calls, Video Calls, peoples' statuses, UPI Payments and Shopping all in one app.

[rollbin]

The thing is every app in China is becoming super app not just WeChat, there are shopping app or gym app becoming social platform, and music app becoming livestream platform

[ceateio]

The thing is, iOS/Android are our Superapps. We have one screen with multiple buttons for different features. iMessage, FaceTime, Apple Pay, … there‘s no difference between having them as multiple tabs or multiple apps.

[VarunDaniel]

Giving one organization control over everything is not always a good idea.

Remember how when Google has an issue with one of the products you use they block your entire Google account preventing you access from every Google products you use.

[TomNook.]

There is a way to offer the convenience of a "super" app AND limit the power of tech giants. Anyone can create an app and through APIs, integrate services from the major platforms into one. It can be as separated (an app that then links to the 5 different websites - essentially a browser) or integrated as required.

This does however require the big tech companies to open up their features through developer APIs.

[mikecairnduff]

When you are jumping between the different screens and mini programs within WeChat, it doesn't feel seemless at all. It's no different to having separate apps. However, the great thing about it is everyone has it, so you can easily pay for things, transfer money etc. I can't see a similar app taking off in the West though.

[rhruozo]

Why aren't things as efficient and all encompassing as in an authoritarian state?

[fetB]

wow, opening 4 apps within a span of hours. truely a massive task. Are we really that low already?

[siddharthsriram]

It’s really not that complicated to get your boss a coffee. You don’t need a super app lol.

[Hellojsm]

They missed the technically different insights. WeChat offers coders a frontend layer and lightweight scripting language functions and interfaces to develop their own services, known as WeChat Mini Programs. It is essentially a mimic of Google Play for Android OS services, but with a smaller, simpler, and lighter language and development procedure.

[LaxmikantKachhap]

Amazon is already on the way to do this in India. It already provided a range of services from banking to booking movie tickets and more.

[danmarius]

The super-app is a super bad idea. Because of security and because competition works.

[MKsaircall]

There is already a company that manages finance, messaging any other commodities you can think off. It's Apple, they already are a Super Company and the App Store it's a super app manages everything. US and European citizens don't see an issue with using multiple apps to fulfill their needs. Plus competition makes for a better costumer experience even if we sacrifice the commodity of having everything in one app.

[Padawan]

People used to go to atms not too long ago. We have come a long way. So don’t forget to sit down for a bit and relax. Just say good job and move on.