2021 VW Golf GTI Clubsport vs Honda Civic Type R | PistonHeads

The first time we pitched the latest Civic Type R against the Mk8 Golf GTI, the decision went in Honda's favour. But this isn't just any Golf GTI - it's the new Clubsport. With more power than standard and Nurburgring-honed suspension as well, VW reckons this is the most focused Golf you can buy. So, is it better to drive than the hot hatch king? Over to Dan to find out.

[apolloandratti]

The FK8 is like a good vintage wine, it has gotten better and "more recognition" with age. At first many were too focused on the polarizing aesthetics of the Type R, but then it began to slowly capture the hearts and minds of many. This FK8 is reminiscent of the game changing impact the NA1 NSX had (to only a degree of course, as the original NSX was groundbreaking in so many ways). It's been 5 years since the FK8 came into the market and it has not been dethroned yet as the best overall hot hatch.

[kudzimanyau]

Love how you're showing more of your emotion/excitement in these new videos, helps the reviews especially for our sake. Keep going at it Dan love your progression, since the good old Evo days👍

[chunbaouk]

Dan Prosser is the best in the business for these types of comparisons in my opinion. Real nails the subtle distinctions between the two. Keep it up Dan!

[timmietz]

Honda by a mile for me. Recently bought the LE version of the Type R. Paid over sticker but still very happy with it. Unique car for sure. Best FWD For sale in the US.

[chrissansom]

never heard a bloke say he wants a rotating knob but... now I think about it, not a bad idea

[Xboxracer]

The FK8 remains on top, what a machine. I can only imagine a version of that engine in a new S2000...

[johnnyr]

Sounds like the Type R and the GR Yaris are still the Goku and Vegeta of this arena.

[legaltechinnovations]

He sounds much happier driving the type R.

[Ntuthuko]

I own I type R same color. The car has a presence. After test driving the car, I know I had to have it.

[robinmarples]

My léon cupra 5 f has the same engine, same power, bigger brakes, Adaptative dumpers, 19' rims and Michelin ps4s form standard, and the possibility to have it manual (what I have)
All of it for nearly 10 grand less.

[jryalls]

The Clubsport should come with DCC, the bigger DSG paddles from the new R and the 19’s as standard (because the 18” Richmonds are hideous).

[turdzilla]

I'd take the GTI Club Sport for a daily over the Type R. If it was going to be my second car, id take the Type R...or the new BRZ when it comes out because its RWD.

[miamigt]

Great content, Dan. I have a 2021 Type R and love it. Very practical and a proper track day toy too.

[RicHSAD]

The Type R is one of those cars I want to drive, but don't want to own. It just has this childish look to it, even the Veloster N looks more mature. That GTI Clubsport though looks amazing in my opinion, especially in that color.

[kimiroihanz]

Golf GTI Clubsport S is the Ultimate that can compare with Type R

[flxpl]

Except front headlights I like the look of that GTI. I can't imagine myself in a car looking like TypeR no matter how good it drives.

[andrewmontague]

Really thorough review, excellent! The biggest issue with Civic Type R is it’s looks, which must’ve had a severe effect on sales. For all of the people who can’t live with that, there’s now the Golf 8 Clubsport.
It’s brilliant that manufacturers are still developing this type of car, let’s enjoy them while we can, this could be the last generation of ICE hot hatches..

[stfie]

I'm on to my 2nd Golf Mk7. i never use the radio button, i use the button on the steering wheel.

[jpngion]

The FK8 Civic Type R is just immense. Wonderful, wonderful to drive.

[chrisjones]

Love both cars but the Clubsport takes it all for me. Incredible car