Marillion - Jigsaw (Montreal 2011)

Recorded on the second night of Marillion Weekend in Montreal Canada, on April 9th, 2011.

[StringBazz]

That was a great moment... can't understand why h doesn't want to to do the old tunes, though :/ Its part of the band's heritage.

[nachois]

I kinda get emotional when they do this, letting the crowd sing Fish songs instead of H, it's almost a mythical vibe

[NothingIncarnate]

Guys, a lot of the old stuff is simply not H's STYLE to sing. Far too wordy, theatrical, too much falsetto. There are certain Fish-era songs that suit his voice (i.e. "Sugar Mice", "Slainte Mhath", "Kayleigh", "Lavender"), however this is not one of them. The style is so much Fish's own that if H attempted it he would almost be forced to do a Fish imitation. He's also said in interviews that he has to feel what he's singing in order to put the proper emotion and conviction behind it.

[nepabum]

i love h but its bullshit that he wont sing some of the old stuff

[JeppeJoy]

Hand over the mic!
Looks like the best band in the world need a singer.

[ralfhansw]

i don´t want to hear always the same Songs from the Fish Time.Just sometimes a Surprise like He knows or Punch and Judy.Always the same is boring.

[Lukin]

H needs to get a grip and realise that the band were around almost 10 years before he appeared on the scene and that these songs are all part of the bands illustrious History. What, does he think he's too good for the older Tosser.

[evh]

It's making a fool on the crowd and the worldwide fans. Fish is still at his best.
If you read Fish considerations for leaving the band, he was right.
They were busting their butt offs in touring and the record company, producers and managers took their profits and after a long European Tour for Clutching at Straws
they were asked to loan money and take a U.S tour. That's where the straw broke the camel's back. H ruined the band. Period!