Preferred Pronouns or Prison | 5 Minute Video

“He.” “She.” “They.” Have you ever given a moment’s thought to your everyday use of these pronouns? It has probably never occurred to you that those words could be misused. Or that doing so could cost you your business or your job – or even your freedom. Journalist Abigail Shrier explains how this happened and why it's become a major free speech issue.

FOLLOW us!
PragerU is on Snapchat!

SHOP!

JOIN PragerFORCE!

Script:

If you want to control people’s thoughts, begin by controlling their words. That’s totalitarian thinking. It was once completely foreign to America. Not anymore.

Increasingly, Americans are forced to use language against their will or even their conscience or be prepared to suffer the consequences. And those consequences can be dire.

Take, for example, the issue of transgenderism, the newest “civil rights battle” of our time. A decade ago, few people could even tell you what the word “transgender” meant. Today, expressing the “wrong opinion” on the issue can cost you your business or job—or both.

Consider recent state and local actions punishing those who decline to use an individual’s pronouns of choice. In 2017, California Governor Jerry Brown signed legislation threatening jail time for health-care professionals who “willfully and repeatedly” refuse to use a patient’s preferred pronouns.

Under guidelines issued in 2015 by New York City’s Commission on Human Rights, employers, landlords and business owners who intentionally use the wrong pronoun with transgender workers and tenants face potential fines of as much as $250,000. That’s a steep price for saying “he” instead of “she” or “she” instead of “he,” or even “he” or “she” instead of “they.”

What about the vast majority of citizens who hold the biology-based view that chromosomes determine your sex—male or female? Or those who have a deep-seated religious conviction that sex is both biological and binary—God’s purposeful creation?

In December of 2018, Peter Vlaming was fired from his job as a French-language teacher in a Virginia school district because he refused to refer to a transgender student by the student’s preferred pronouns. Vlaming’s Christian belief prevented him from bowing before the notion that the student, who had been a “she” in his class the year before, was now suddenly a “he.” Vlaming was willing to use the student’s chosen new name, but he avoided using any pronouns when referring to this student. That wasn’t good enough for the school district; they needed to hear him say the words.

You don’t have to be religious to believe that one person can never be a “they.” The Supreme Court has clearly decided that compelled speech is not free speech.

In West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette (1943), the Supreme Court upheld the students’ right to refuse to salute an American flag. Justice Robert Jackson wrote, “If there is any fixed star in our constitutional constellation, it is that no official, high or petty, can prescribe what shall be orthodox in politics, religion or other matters of opinion.” And, Jackson went on to say, the state can’t force people to say things they don’t believe.

[Niloc]

Who else hates how the comments aren’t shown by default now on mobile?

[SmoothJK]

My preferred pronoun is "Master." Finally, I can force the world to call me that. :*)

[thzzzt]

I just simplify it. I now refer to everyone as "carbon-based life form". It's accurate (although generic), gender-neutral, specie-neutral, genus-neutral, family-neutral, order-neutral, class-neutral, phylum-neutral, kingdom-neutral and domain-neutral. I stop there though: If we ever find silicon-based life in the galaxy I'm not changing.

[hf.]

Considering the like to dislike ratio, I imagined the comments to be much worse than they actually are.

[primthos]

I don't care. I'm gonna say it.




I don't care you broke your elbow.

[Justin_Joy]

I wish all of these "activists" moved to Canada when Trump was elected.

[Elastigirl-Official]

"Civil rights battle of our time"
If you don't use my preferred pronouns i
1:wont cry
2:wont curse at you
3:wont get angry in any way
Ill probably just not talk to you i don't really give af

[niklasnrskovgehlert]

As a wise man once said: Facts don't care about your feelings.

[parihav]

Canada has implemented this as law several years ago.

It’s what gave Jordan Peterson attention, as he testified against this form of compelled speech.

[DANLAROCA-dxgk]

Michael Eric Dyson is a master at googling a bunch of adjectives and synonyms to make a word salad, all the while using the thesaurus.

For Example:
The cat jumped over the dog;

“The felis catus domesticus orbited in a leaping bombastic movement through the oxygen enriched atmosphere over the cranium of the stationary and motionless canis lupus familiaris”.

[fannin]

Also I love how all the modern comments come from the exact same video thank you Jamie

[greenishbean]

Trans people: We just want to be respected-
PragerU: Y’all hear summin?

[charles-yzc]

No wonder you tube and google hate this channel.

Thank you, MA’AM

[xniiieq]

“Today, expressing the wrong opinion on the issue can cost you your business, job, or even both.” Just like how in many places we can lose jobs, businesses, or even our lives.

[ArtoriasB]

If you replace every “transgender” or “pronoun” with “race” or “ethnicity” y’all would be singing a different tune.

[zachz]

IT'S A VIOLATION OF THE 1ST AMENDMENT!! WHY IS THIS EVEN AN ISSUE!!!!

[hotshotsunnyz]

These kind of rules are going to breed the hatred they are to trying to prevent for the privileged group.

[fannin]

Summary of this video: “oh I got in trouble by discriminating against somebody because discriminating against somebody is going to cause you to pay fines like it always has or the only real instance where a fine will be necessary is if it starts endangering the lives of somebody which was already the case before the bill passed. so if I intentionally misgender and somebody to put them in a dangerous position or causing a hostile work environment I shouldn’t be charged with a discrimination lawsuit and:or face any consequences”

[mrmakrin]

If you want to control people’s thoughts...

Begin by controlling their *thoughts*

[pogfee]

Having dozens of pronouns completely defeats the purpose of pronouns in the first place. It isn't practical linguistically.