Jeremy Jordan ('Supergirl') performs 'She Used to Be Mine' from WAITRESS

MCC Theater's annual MisCast gala is one of the most exciting and unique theater events in town. Broadway’s hottest stars perform songs from roles in which they would never be cast.

[willhoffman]

How the hell is it possible that Jeremy Jordan just convinced me he was a pregnant lady with an abusive husband in less than 4 minutes....

[kevinchrissese]

I want a Jeremy Jordan version of every song in the world.

[naziatislam]

The pain in his voice is unimaginable and he's not even a pregnant woman

[jordanhersh]

Let’s be honest, this isn’t the first time you’ve been here

[danivigna]

HE MADE HIMSELF CRY. If that’s not talent then I don’t know what is.

[lilmarvel]

I didn’t sign a permission slip to go on this feels trip

[anniewilliams]

Who would buy an album of only Jeremy Jordan covers 😂

[Shyguy]

I can understand why they hired him to voice Lucifer in hazbin hotel, Lucifer is said to have a wonderful and attractive voice when he sings.

[kelleycrowley]

What a wonderful performance. A man comfortable in his own skin who can channel a pregnant woman’s pain and struggle. This is a beautiful pie.

[amberlionnet]

It has become a quarantine routine that i watch this at 4 am every night

[MarcThomas-cncr]

This man single handedly put this song into my top five songs of the year, I just wish his version was on there

[melflow]

4 years later and I always come back to this performance!

[panchish]

he lowkey disappeared from musical theatre and then suddenly DROPPED THIS out of NOWHERE it's the equivalent of aaron tveit dropping take me or leave me in 2016

[KHobbies_cina]

I believe his eye brows deserves a Tony Award nomination

[garyalfjose]

It's 2024 and still watching this over and over.

[quirkycatcrafts]

Ok this seriously needs some kind of a warning in the title or something. I am a truck driver and this popped up in my random recommended and I had to find somewhere to pull over because I couldn't see to drive through the tears. And that was just from listening to it. Watching it brought a whole new level of feels. Am I the only one that had full body shivers?

[gracieliz]

Jeremy Jordan performances:
60% voice
39% eyebrows
1% everything else

[nemarianaart]

Vivziepop saw this and was like “this. This is the parental angst that I NEED”

[annajams]

So glad they had him sing in the Supergirl finale. His voice is out of this world, and needs to be heard

[grahmtapp]

As a trans guy (ftm), I interpret this song in a completely different way then most but it is just as powerful if not more. Seeing one of my idols up on that stage pouring his heart out gets my feels every time. To that little girl inside of me, I never hated you.