Skippy vs Peter Pan - What is the Best Tasting Creamy Peanut Butter Brands, FoodFights Food Review

What is the best store bought creamy peanut butter to buy, Skippy or Peter Pan?

In this YouTube video Food Fights will help you find the answers.

Which peanut butter brand do you prefer? Let us know in the comments.

In our FoodFights food review YouTube videos, we test and review many different food and grocery products to taste and discover if there is a difference between name brand, store brand and generic.

We sure were have a lot of fun in the process. Let us know if you agree with our analysis.

FoodFights releases a NEW food fight challenge and review video every Saturday at 10:00 am EST. Just in time for grocery shopping day.

Let Us Try It Before You Buy It

For more information:

[spencersmith]

Great review. I really like your tone of voice and think you would do great on the radio. You have a new subscriber.

[joibenjamin]

The Peter Pan Honey Roast flavor is better than the regular creamy to me and it’s definitely sweeter. You should try it! It has a golden yellow label. Can you do another comparison with that flavor?

[reynaldoflores]

They're BOTH so good, lol. If you took the labels off and did a taste comparison, you wouldn't be able to tell which is which.

[RedStrikerBeetleborg]

both brands are good (skippy has more of the peanut flavor; love the superchunk while peter pan spreads the easiest) and it's hard to choose which one is the best

[djr]

I grew up on Jif. Not sure if that is salty or sweet. I actually haven't had it in years. I usually buy Peter Pan for the value. I like do like the salty with sweet jelly. Skippy is probably better alone in a sandwich without jelly.

[Lala-ugyc]

Peter pan peanut butter is the best peanut butter ever. The flavor is better than any peanut butter I’ve had and I’ve had a lot of peanut butter.

[makidiaz]

They changed Peter Pan. It has a pale color now and doesn’t taste like anything but peanut shell shavings and vitamin e oil lol.
I’ve tried them all, the best taste so far for me has been Jif’s Natural, I know it ain’t natural but to me has the best taste

[stephenyoung]

I used to like Jiff but after they took it off the market and came back smaller size with a higher price I changed brands but I’ve always like honey roasted Peter Pan

[frankfurlacker]

I like Jif the best but I occasionally buy Skippy and Peter Pan too.

[eleonoreconstant]

I love them both!! I do like Jif as well, maybe Peter Pan is my favorite but I like to change. What’s your all time favorite PB? Thanks a lot for the video!

[andyjones]

Best hands down is Skippy Super Chunk. Used to be a JIF guy until I discovered Skippy 😃

[lizlee]

Doesn’t ultra smooth mean more added oil?

[patrickmcmullin]

Thank you Foodfights you helped me pick Skippy over Peter Pan!

[silasteacher]

Skippy has less fat and more sodium. Peter Pan has more calories and more protein. But these figures aren't much different.

[TheNicodemus]

I like Skippy but I will always be a Peter Pan guy over the other brands I've tried (JIF, SKIPPY, Smuckers etc)

[fansandvintage]

I haven’t tried Skippy or Peter Pan but I have had Jif and Smuckers

[Travybear]

They are so similar it's hard to tell a difference but peter Pan has a honey roasted flavor that is basically the best peanut butter on planet earth.

[paulrivera]

I think the texture and color comes from the soil they grow from

[spaceviking]

Jif is the best out of the big brands. No cottonseed oil.

[Buttermilkjug]

I miss JFG Peanut Butter~ It was my favorite growing up~