What if Yoda Went to Mustafar and Fought Anakin? - Star Wars Theory Fan-Fic

or text Star Wars Theory to 500-500 now.

With an Audible membership, you can download titles and listen offline, anytime, anywhere. The Audible app is free and can be installed on all smartphones and tablets. You can listen across devices without losing your spot. Audible members don’t have to worry about using their credits
right away. You can keep your credits for up to a year—and use them to binge on a whole series if you’d like!
And if you’re not loving your selection, you can simply swap it for another.

_______________________________________________________________________

In revenge of the Sith, we had obi wan fight Anakin, and Yoda fight palatine. Against obi-wan’s wishes, who requested to fight Sidious because he could not kill Anakin, was denied by Yoda and flat out was told that Palpatine would kill him.
This led to the outcome we had, where Yoda lost to Sidious, and obi-wan mutilated Anakin.
What if Yoda went to Mustafar? Now this fan fiction will be incorporating tons of fantasy battle type explanations as we need to understand the actual fight and who would win and then we can discuss what would happen in the galaxy as a result of this fight. In the past I’ve done a similar fan fiction, but this one will be more in depth on their fighting styles.

As obi-wan tells Yoda he can’t fight Anakin. Yoda agrees, and tells him to stay put in the temple and to not engage the emperor at all costs until he returns. This would keep obi-wan alive, and we can focus on Yoda’s journey.I feel Yoda knew where Anakin was, he just didn’t tell obi-wan for whatever reason. He told him to trust his feelings and that led him to speak to padme, resulting in him hiding in her ship as she travelled to mustafar.

Yoda would either travel to Mustafar, since I feel he already knew, or he would just sneak onto padme’s ship without even saying anything to her. It’s Yoda, he’s that stealthy.
Anakin and Padme run their dialogue. Padme doesn’t know about Anakin killing younglings, since obi-wan didn’t tell her. We could say Yoda told her, but let’s just go with the option of him sneaking onto her ship.
Anakin sees Yoda in the doorway of padme’s ship.
He is taken aback. The grandmaster is here. He isn’t nearly as angry as he was when Kenobi showed up. Anakin knows he’s in trouble. And he is about to pay for what he’s done.

Master Yoda…

No! Padme says. I didn’t bring him here.

Anakin looks enraged at her. He chokes her and Yoda uses the force to push Anakin back, tumbling to the ground.

A disgrace, you are, young Skywalker. Betray your friends, you have.

As Anakin gets up, he takes his robe off.

It is you who betrayed me. The Jedi never gave me the respect I deserved.

Entitled, you are. Pay you will, for all you have done.

If it wasn’t for your lack of empathy, the Jedi would still be alive. You are responsible for this.

Yoda shook his head.

Much to learn, you still have. Mistake it was, trusting you.

Anakin: Don’t make me kill you.

Try you will. Succeed, you will not.

Anakin ignites his saber but before he can leap at Yoda, the Jedi grand master was already at his feet, lightsaber slashing at his ankles. Anakin blocks it and realizes how fast the grand master is. He had never duelled him, and yet, here he thought he was a better fighter than him.

The two would fight an incredible duel. As molten lava surrounded them. Anakin would be wary of Yoda’s speed, and his small stature which proved difficult to fight against.
Yoda would need to be cautious of the youthful energy that Skywalker possessed. His stamina was natural, and didn’t require the force to enhance. Whereas Yoda pulled from the force to enhance his speed and agility due to his old age. He couldn’t fight like this forever, regardless how powerful he was in the force.

Anakin used form V djem So. This was a more aggressive fighting style that focused on offence rather than more defence like Kenobi’s form 3 soresu.
Yoda used form 4 ataru, this was also a very aggressive form. So with these two fighting, it would probably be a more intense fight than any other, since they both would be trying to kill one another with each hit, whereas with Kenobi, he was always defending, and blocking looking for an opening, super patient. This battle would just undulate between one being the agressor and the other being less aggressive, until they falter and get the upper hand, switching roles, tumultuously.

[yamahakidf]

Anakin: " I HATE YOU"!!!!

Yoda: "Give a fuck, I do not."

[KeysofIDproductions]

Yoda *after cutting Anakin's feet off*: Almost the same height, we are *chuckles*.

[yeeticus]

Just a small point, padme wouldn’t have travelled to mustafar if obi wan hadn’t told her about anakin so Yoda couldn’t sneak onto her ship

[darthjar]

Here’s an idea. What if Obi-Wan and Yoda double teamed Palpatine and then went after Anakin?

[jjfromthebigland]

Anakin: I HATE YOU!!
Yoda: de-feeted you are.

[hunterkiller]

Obi Wan just needs to stand in the Senate podium to have the high ground while Palpatine is sitting in office.

[tyyt]

“Try, you will” “Succeed, you will not” that sounds good until you realize yoda’s also said “Do or do not, there is no try”

[VeraTepes]

In nearly 2 seconds, Yoda had done 4 spins. 2 Horizonal at ground level, and two jumping vertical, at shoulder level.
Anakin had no idea what happened, before he was thrown into the Lava, all limbs completely severed.

[andrecoyote]

Yoda: “Cane I do not need…
Health Insurance Fraud i have committed…”

[MrRelic]

Obi-Wan: Only a Sith deals in absolutes.
Anakin: That's also an absolute statement.
Obi-Wan: Precisely
shoots force lightning

[davidalan]

I don’t think Yoda’s faking it with the cane. I think he’s not just using the Force to speed himself up, he’s using it to breathe flexibility into his limbs. He’s Yoda - a totally empty vessel to be filled by the Force, but only when he needs.

[joshuawilford]

She didn’t die from “loss of will”, Sidious transferred her life force into Anakin to keep him alive. Sidious is the one who planted the dreams in Anakins head.

[christinajade]

"until Palpatine would rise from Exegol - just kidding"
You almost had me for a second. 😂😂

[joestorywrestler]

I’m so happy Theory is still doing fan fiction, I love sitting down and relaxing after work or college classes while listening to these and could do it all day.

[wolftal]

I think the reason Obi-Wan didn’t stop Anakin from choking Padmé, was because he wanted Anakin to do it himself in hopes of bringing him back to the light side. Yoda on the other hand wouldn’t have been so certain on this point and would have taken more instant action as you described.

However you really ought to do a sequel to this, where Vader escapes and Obi-Wan and Luke have to track him down.

[Axi_osity]

I always wondered why Yoda and Kenobi didnt team up on Vader, like I can see them going to Mustfar, then heading over the Coruscant to wack Palpatine

[sunflow]

If Yoda worked in a retail store and met a Karen:

*"Entitled, you are. Pay for those products you broke, you must."*

[SpaceMonkeyBoi]

Yoda on mustafar: "what about his legs? He don't need legs."
Anakin: "👁👄👁"

[MT-UK]

Your voice acting is on POINT!
Your creativity is amazing and the passion for Star Wars is palpable.

What you could come up with if you were hired by Disney is just mind blowing- you and Jon Favreau would bring a whole new meaning to the ‘Rule of Two’

[mynameisbub]

I love your What If's! Your lore knowledge shines and you tell a wonderful story. Please keep it up.