Crappie Shad vs Gulp Minnow - Which Fishing Lure Will Catch More Fish?

Today we are comparing Crappie Shad vs Gulp Minnow. Which fishing lure will catch more fish? One of these lures catches bass, bluegill, and even a shiner! The other doesn't catch a thing. The winner of this one on one comparison is clear, the Gulp Minnow. While these two crappie lures look very similar, and are nearly the same size, only one of them produces fish today. I have caught fish in the past on the crappie shad style lure, but today it didn't have a chance. Even though the water cooled off after a cold weekend, I was still able to catch a variety of fish. #fishing

Send mail to the show here:
Realistic Fishing
PO Box 2005
Lebanon TN 37088

Awesome Patrons: A Guy From Denmark - Scott Hettel - Chue Lee - Scott Kidder - Clinodev - John David - Daniel Lightsey - Joshua Johnston - Gail Hayes - Jay B - Brooks Meyers - Eric Payne - Jason Compton - Thaxton Mauzy - Aleksandr Sorokin - AD Robles - Marlo C. - Nathaniel Reynolds - Dan Fox - Michael and Susan Ziegler

Follow me on social media:

[RealisticFishing]

Congratulations to Jacob and Megan who were recently married. ❤

[vegetablejoe]

The Gulp Minnow is always my go-to no matter what when nothing else works.

[rowlandjohnnie]

The gulp definitely kicked ass... Let me know if you want to send me some lures..lol.. awesome vid bro

[BamaChad-WCHD]

Our crazy weather down south. I live in north Alabama and it was 80 all week and then 20 with 5 inches of snow Friday night. Back to 70 and above yesterday and today.

[phillipriley]

Those Gulp minnows are magic for you! Tight Lines!

[charlesdulude]

Went out this morning on errands stopped by the marina for the fun of it. Parking is clear of snow but the river still solid and snow banks are still a good four feet tall, some time to go yet for us I’m afraid. Thanks for this one love the sound track in the background spring birds are calling out

[fishingwithvance]

The Gulp Minnow catches everything it seems. Never tried the Crappie Shad before. Those big gill are a blast. Amazing that tiny difference made all the difference so to speak. The purple in those gills always reminds me why purple anything works. 51 degree QPer. Enjoyed it. Fish on!

[sjs]

I think I’ve said this before, but the supportive cameo appearances of people from other channels, is brilliant.

[TJWilson]

Turned that day around with the gulp minnow. Congrats!

[duanetaylor]

Thanks for the video. The Blue Gills looked nice and healthy minus the bird scratches. KiR!!!

[knhoriuchi]

I am a complete believer in gulp minnows. They never fail me. Thanks for the content!

[miguelg]

That golden shiner was a big ol' boy!

[atoadigi]

Gulp minnow saves the day! I always keep them in my bag. Great video!!!

[Psychoti]

I have pretty good luck with the Bobby Garland baby shad baits when I'm fishing for crappie & panfish. They're on sale at Bass Pro now (not sponsored, obviously, just sharin' the good news) and it's a rare day that I bring them out and don't catch anything. The MoGlo are my go-to right now because the water where I fish is really stained. Enjoyed the video, keep'm comin'.

[marlojohnston]

Another great video Alex and some awesome fish!! And it's definitely nice to see the gulp minnows for the win!!! They're a great product that definitely catches fish. Thank you for sharing and always keeping it realistic!

[bayrat]

Nice. I have some GM from last summer good to know

[randallpinkfloyd]

"I'll get you for this HeMan" - Skeletor

[tonymcbroom]

That was a pretty good size Golden Shiner, I have caught small ones, but nothing that large. Gulp minnows for the win! Great video Alex, cannot wait for the water to warm up about 8 to 10 degrees.

[coreybrock]

Never seen anything like the Shiners your pulling out of the water. Learned allot watching your down to earth videos! Just like real life!!!

[CasualGirlAdventures]

Wow! looks so cold still. your awesome for still getting out and fishing. well that’s a no brainer the gulp minnow definitely did a lot better. great video. Have a great day Alex!