Elphaba show down: Rachel Tucker vs Jennifer DiNoia Wicked showdown

Video comparing Rachel Tucker and Jennifer DiNoia singing parts of The Wizard & I, Defying Gravity & No Good Deed. For full versions of each of this videos:

I didn't record nor do I own any of these clips.

[mikeym.]

Back in 2009, I was incredibly fortunate to see jennifer play elphaba in her first run on Broadway back when she was stand by. Dee rascoli was playing the role full time and it was her first night back after a week long sick leave. When she went to hit the big note at the end of wizard and I, her voice completely gave out!! The entire audience was so supportive giving her a standing ovation... needless to say though, as soon as she left the stage, jennifer came out to finish the performance and KILLED I've since seen Dee in the role as well, and she is fucking incredible as well. But when jennifer came on that night, it was just like nothing had happened! One of my favorite nights at the theatre.

[ethan]

The Wizard and I - Jenny
Defying Gravity (Its me - sky) Jenny
Defying Gravity (as someone - meee) Rachel
No Good Deed - IDK they both are amazing but i do have to go with jenny

[justyourvoice]

OH MY GOSH! This is so funny.Rachel was Elphaba on Broadway and then Jenny is Elphaba on broadway right now!

[maymeteorite]

OKAY SO I WAS EXPECTING TO BE LIKE "OH YEAH RACHEL" EVEN THOUGH I LOVE THEM BOTH BUT I WAS DEAD WRONG I CAN'T DECIDE I'M AMAZED

[alisonkennedy]

Jennifer. Hands down. She has such a powerful & pure voice, her pronunciation is better, too.

[jordanr]

Seeing Jenny in 2 weeks then Rachel in her first week back in London! 🎉

[Roxyrox]

I think both are amazing at Elphaba but Rachel does something extra for me personally. But again they are both amazing performers xx

[ber]

I have a new found appreciation for Jennifer, but its still the Tucker for me.

[michrp]

Jenny is totally the winner!! She's amazing ❤

[hhcsoftball]

Jenny was so amazing live in a huge fan💕

[jonathanchung]

I saw Jenny in Wicked! But I would love 2 see Rachel! But I think Jenny wins! I still love Rachel!

[mariadagostino]

The wizard and I Rachel.

Defying Gravity tie

No Good Deed Rachel. I felt like Jenny was copying her



Over all the winner is Rachel. Not hating on Jenny she is very good and very talented and I would love to see her but Rachel has so much more power.