Dr. Ali Gomaa WINS a DEBATE Against al-Albani

Brief Biography: Muhammad Umar Mustafa is a highly trained and qualified instructor of the Arabic sciences. He has studied at multiple institutions of Islamic learning, such as Darul Uloom al-Madania, Darussalam Seminary, and the Institute of Islamic Education in Elgin. He was at the very top of his class during each of his years there. In 2022, Ust. Muhammad received an ijazah from Sh. Abdul-Hayy Habbal to teach the Arabic sciences. He also possesses a shahada in the 10 Qira’at of the Quran by Dr. Fawqi Jawadah al-Azhari and is currently working on his ijazah in them with him and is also further pursuing his studies in other related fields.

[ibnawesome]

Learn two years of university-level Arabic in six months by joining the 6-Month Arabic Intensive starting July 2024.

Visit to learn more.

[dawahussalafiyyah]

It's not even a debate. Fear Allah old man. If Shaykh al-Mujadid Muhammad Nassiruddin al-Albaani was still alive then it won't take even 1 min for him to make u lose the debate

[skenderramadani]

comparing Sheikh Al Albani with this Dr.Ali Gomaa is like comparing the sword with a stick!!!

[heyhey]

Debate? That was a monologue 😂 Then I won in debates against Fakhruddeen al-Razi, al-Ghazali and Suyuti😂

[judgeyourself]

Any pure sunni scholor can win a debate with a salafi. The sunni creed goes back to the salaf and eventually the prophet.

The wahhabi creed goes back to najdi and it is only 250 years old.

[one_deen_edits]

Adab al Mufrad is a famous book. Even the newest students of knowledge know about it. To claim that Al-Albani didn't know about its content (being Sahih or Da'eef) is hard to believe and digest. And furthermore, where is the evidence for this "debate"?

[dardandema]

Any proof of the debate? Or are we expected to take your word for it.?

[UsaidKarbelkar]

May Allah guide these misguided people(Salafis).

[hasancasperlabuschagne]

Your translation skills are exemplary, mā shā Allah. May Allah increase you in good.

[faizahmed]

Alhamdulillah... Sheikh Albani rahimahullah is quoted all over the world... Iam from India.

[Huzaifa_salafi]

May Allah grant Imam Albani one of the highest positions in Jannah

[AbdulWadud]

Is your purpose to educate people regarding the usage of weak ahadith or to show that a certain scholar lost a debate? Are you truly giving Naseehah or are you pleasing your Nafs in the process?
Is there no other way to spread good than to discredit others and look down upon them?
ادع إلى سبيل ربك بالحكمة والموعظة الحسنة وجادلهم بالتي هي أحسن
If one is commanded to do so with the kuffar then what stops you from doing so with your fellow brothers?
This isn't the only video where you've done this. While the point you are defending may be correct, the way you present it will turn away many sincere brothers. Whats the point of translating all these videos if they are only geared toward a group which already agrees with your point?

[issaal-andaloussi]

I think it wasn't even a debate ,
و الله أعلم .

الله يهدينا .

[alinormohamed]

ما أسهل الفوز عندما تناقش ميتا أو غائبا!.

[classicalmuslim]

This wasn't a debate. This was an alim schooling a layman. Al-Albani wasn't an alim in anything except repairing watches. People who think he was an alim or muhaddith, simply don't know the technical definition of these terms, or were misguided by the heretical Salafi sect or influenced by Sheikh ibn-ternet who told them 🤖: "If his youtube views are high and google or wiki says he's a scholar, then he must be!"

[anamuslim]

LA ILAHA ILLALLAH
MUHAMMADUR RASULULLAH
ALLAH k siwa koi mabud nhi or muhammad (s.w) ALLAH k rasul he

[gibrillmlbadjie]

There's problem with the description of the video. Sheikh Albani cannot debate while he is with the Muslim who passed away

[ImranKhan-kxoi]

Oh! You who believe fear God and speak truth.
Shyakh Albani( rahamtullah) was a great Hadith scholar who dedicated his life to the service of Sunnah. He is rightly known as Reviver of sunnah. Wallah! The research which is going on now in whole arab & ajam was stared by shyalk albani.. He was a great researcher of Hadith & it's allied sciences but he is not Infamible. He has his mistakes but his goods are like Himaliya mountain in comparison to his mistake just just a few. One who don't know his level in Hadith science should go through his original book like Irwa al galeel Or silsila sahiya and see how beautiful he was. May Allah give him jannatul firdous

[kolkavalli]

Gomaa-r in albanian language means donkey

[sup]

This guy debated a dead person!! Dammmmnnn!