Czy Motul 10W50 4T jest lepszy niż Castrol 10W50 4T? Sprawdźmy...

@PiotrTester

Test czystości oleju silnikowego Motul 7100 4T 10W50 i Castrol Power 1 Racing 4T 10W50

Jak przebiega test?
Identyczna ilość oleju została 3x krotnie podgrzana do temperatury 250°C strumieniem gorącego powietrza o temperaturze 550°C.
Próbka z olejem znajduje się zawsze w takiej samej odległości od podgrzewarki. Temperatura oleju mierzona jest profesjonalnym wzorcowym termometrem laboratoryjnym.
#motul7100 #motul10W50 #castrol10W50

Dlaczego podgrzewam olej do tak wysokiej temperatury?
Chcę pokazać graniczne możliwości oleju, gdzie olej traci swoje właściwości, a z oleju zaczynają wytrącać się zanieczyszczenia i osiadać na ściankach silnika. Jest to podobna temperatura do tej panującej w silniku np. w górnej części tłoka. To że czujnik temperatury w silniku pokazuje 90°C wcale nie oznacza, że w całym silniku olej ma identyczną temperaturę.

Sposób oceny stanu oleju po teście?
10 - bardzo dobrze
1 - słabo
Będę podawał tylko jedną wartość. Biorę pod uwagę stopień zaczernienia oleju jak i ilość zanieczyszczeń na ściankach probówki. Im czarniejszy olej tym mocniej wyczuwalny jest zapach spalenizny.

Wyniki:
Motul 10W50: 6,5/10
Castrol 10W50: 9/10

Piotr Tester zestawienie:

[UzielCabreraChavez]

El Castrol es mucho mejor que el Motul, Motul lo que tiene es una gran campaña de marketing y publicidad para llegar a la mayor cantidad de población posible, pero los que saben de aceites, saben que el Castrol es mucho mejor que Motul.

[allalbavincero]

Piotr, It is somewhat confusing to watch your video and read your description. In video 5:33, Castrol floating and clearness are both better. The color scale (middle of the screen) is marked 10 on the left (most clear) and 1 is on the right (darkest). The Castrol is the higher number and your " 9/10" description matches. However, in your "Q and A" (6:03), you indicated that the lower result is better lubricating. That Q&A claim might lead people to think Motul were better since Motul is darker so matched the scale's lower number side. That is confusing.

[AS-upcw]

Porque este MOTUL 7100 es mas cafe obscuro que rosado como lo he visto?

[gabrielsanhueza]

ya me cambie de motul a castrol sin haber visto este video, hay una enorme diferencia en el ruido del motor y lubricacion de taquees hidraulicos , con motul sonaban mucho ahora nada con temperaturas de cero grados ambientales

[sijithcheruvallil]

Please test castrol power 1 cruise 15w50 .

[atny]

Already done a test with the putoline N tech pro+ 10w40?

[gosth]

Motul is good but theres way too much clone motul sellers so go for castrol

[jonaskahl]

Der test ist Quatsch! Wenn schon, muss man den Gewichtsverlust messen, nicht die Farbe. Jedes Öl kann schon im "Neuzustand" farblich dunkler bzw gefärbt sein.

[NMad-kpbu]

From the datasheet, both were comparable in terms of viscosity index. Can't go wrong with either of both oils. I used Motul 7100, my bike feels the same 🤷 feels normal, nothing wrong, the engine's healthy. The oil does its job. Use the correct viscosity, change at regular intervals, that's all

[shibin_siyad]

Hey...what is this? I can clearly see that the castrol oil colour and its not easily getting heated like motul.... And those Q&A are similar in your other videos...is all this a research or just

[jannisya]

Trotzdem würde ich das Motul immer vorziehen gegenüber dem Castrol....der NOAK wert ist besser ....in der Praxis geringere Verdampfung . Und was sehr wichtig ist für Motorrad Öle ist die Scherbelastung auch fürs Getriebe und da ist das Motul besser ...

[zanathzanath]

Flawed test. Being red in colour, it darkens by comparison to Castrol, which is goldish yellow. And, oil darkens not because of heat alone😑

[naufalazrie]

can you do a friction test for this catrol power 1 racing again?and why type of metal you had been used in the friction test?and i suggest you to try make a test on fuchs silkolene semi-synthetic for bike.tq

[josemiguelpradavonborries]

¡Hello piotr!...excuseme but i speaks a very little of english...in your opinion: ¿is ipone katana 10w40 a good motor oil, comparing with motul 7100 or castrol power 1 racing?...👍

[moravald]

These tests are very good! Could you do a test on Aero Shell 100w oil and Aero Shell 15w-50 oil? Thank

[PACFICDR]

Castrol fornece produtos aos exércitos e a NASA ✅👍

[brunocarvalho]

Não achei o teste valido por conta do motul 7100 ser um óleo já de coloração diferente, implogando a ser mais escuro, o fator que deveria ser levado em conta seria quando a resistividade em não perder suas propriedades multiviscosas ao longo do teste

[HienPham-hkyj]

Empirical these numbers are. Tests that qualify which oil is better should be scientific and follow under set guidelines e.g Four-ball Wear Test, FLZ Gear Failure Protection Test, Foam Test, etc. Read your oil SDS and deliver judgment from there people. If no SDS are around for that oil or if it's too short and lack for details, skip the oil

[marioarmando]

Busque videos más antiguo y encontré uno que este mismo Castrol a 100 grado con un peso de un kilo durante solos 2 minutos tiene un pésimo desempeño un elevados desgaste mientra que el motul con 5 minutos apena una pequeña marca en el metal creí que el Castrol era mejor

[jairandrade]

Pelo oq entedi motul ele absorver mais a temperatura 🌡 do motor na troca de Calor com a carcaça de alumínio do motor q por sua vez é refrigerado a ar isso gera troca de calor, o óleo ideal ele tem q absorver calor lubrificar e manter a característica viscosidade em temperatura altas a cor não diz nada .Se o óleo do motor está escuro sinal q está fazendo seu dever de limpeza no motor com as trocas corretas a cada km rodado