Episode 135: The Unsolved Disappearance of Evelyn Hartley

#truecrimeunsolved #evelyn #unsolvedmystery
On the evening of October 24, 1953, 15-year-old Evelyn Hartley vanished while babysitting in La Crosse, Wisconsin. Her disappearance sparked one of the largest manhunts in state history, involving thousands of volunteers, extensive searches, and even polygraph tests. Despite the discovery of chilling clues—including blood evidence, a mysterious shoe print, and a potential getaway car—Evelyn’s case remains a haunting unsolved mystery.

In this video, we delve into the details of that fateful night, the evidence left behind, and the theories surrounding her disappearance. Could her abductors have escaped unnoticed, or is there more to the story? Join us as we piece together the events and explore why this case continues to baffle investigators decades later.

Like, comment and subscribe for more unsolved and mysterious content with Fireside Unsolved.

Join Fireside Unsolved to get access to exclusive perks:

#firesideunsolved #unsolvedmystries #coldcase #disappearance #mystery #truecrimecommunity #crimedocumentary #unsolvedcases #vanishedwithoutatrace #missingpersonsmysteries #unexplained #unexplainedmystery #crimestory #mysteryunsolved #mysterylover #historicalmysteries #truecrimeaddicts #truecrimeaddict #historicalmystery #coldcasefiles #wisconsin #babysitter #1950s #crimestorytelling #unsolveddisappearances

[kayleenkrolikowski]

I WILL check this out. Thank you. In the 80s, in college, we did an exercise for crime scene investigation with a similar case....before moving on to the more gruesome. It's so frustrating to dive back in on an unsolved case, yet so adrenaline pumping when you think just maybe you have a question or see a connection that we're never brought up.