Ranking aespa as all rounders #kpop #aespa #karina #giselle #winter #ningning

[Minhooneiv]

Giselle is a check on dance, she’s actually really good.

[lia]

Sooo mature, I'm in love with this comeback ❤

[sus_kiddo]

Giselle dancing in their debut era was something special after the hate she got idk what happened.

[muhammadinshaahsni]

Vocal
1Ningning ✔️
2 Winter ✔️
3 Karina ✔️
4 Giselle ✔️
Rap
1Giselle ✔️
2 Karina ✔️
3 Winter ✔️
4 Ningning ✔️

Dance
1karina✔️
2 Winter ✔️
3 Ningning ✔️
4 Giselle ❎
All rouder
1 Karina
2 Ningning.
3Winter
4 Giselle

[Annnnniiiiii]

Karina is my bias💞
Winter is pretty 🤧
I love Giselle's rap🌺
And ningning is so cool🥶

[jIlmoxx_zw]

Vocal:
Ning Ning(B) ✅
Winter(^C+) ✅
Giselle(^D+/C-) ✅
Karina(^D+) ✅
Rap:
Giselle✅
Karina✅
Winter✅
Ning ning✅❌
Dance
Karina✅
Winter✅
Ning Ning✅❌
Giselle❌✅
Stage present
Ning Ning✅
Karina✅
Giselle✅
Winter✅❌

[beatrizbisctrizam]

at ningning solo we saw she was actually a great rapper and also I think her dance abilities are in the same level as winter. besides, she has the best stage presence
for me, she's definitely the all rounder

[Jwa]

i have no idea why people keep saying winter have no stage presence. Are you guys still living at 2021? Now her stage presence have improved a lot and her honestly her stage presence is so good. Please stop saying she doesn't have stage presence please

[itachiuchiha]

All are allrounder. Karina is allrounder cause she excels all. Winter is exceptional hexagonal idol. Ningning is good enough. And Giselle is also good but her dance need improvement. And for stage presence, they are kind weak than other group but they will improve soon whereas ning ning only has quite good stage presence.

[ayo]

i feel like ningning and gigi are the only all rounders

[sushi]

winter is the most well rounded member imo. people need to let go of this narrative that her stage presence is weak because she’s improved a ton. not just in that, but every aspect. the other three are very talented as well!

[hilal]

i think karina is the real all rounder in aespa, ningning needs to improve herself in rap, winter in stage presence and rap (I'm not a fan of her rap actually), giselle in dance meanwhile karina has perfect vocal, rap dance and avarage stage presence

[yukyu]

I'm glad that you didn't put visual in there💗

[wony_]

A lot of people were saying that Karina should be the main vocalist but no-ur forgetting nini 🙈💅

[tikeyrv]

Por dios santo claramente se ve que ning ning es mejor bailarina 😮😮

[mypearlb]

Ningning is slightly better in rap than Winter. Although they need more material (because they still can't be considered rappers), Ningning has better diction so far, Winter kinda sounds a bit cringey (or might be the parts given to her lol).

Also for all-rounder, you have to include stage presence.

Vocal
Ningning ✅
Winter ✅
Karina ✅
Giselle ✅

Rap
Giselle ✅
Karina ✅
Ningning ❌
Winter ❌

Dance
Karina ✅
Winter ✅
Ningning ✅
Giselle ❌

Stage presence
Ningning ✅
Karina ✅
Giselle/Winter (they're both inconsistent tbh so) ❌

All-rounder ranking
Karina 4/4
Ningning 3/4
Giselle & Winter 2/4

[minhazuddintarek]

Karina is better in vocals than Giselle.

[jIlmoxx_zw]

All rounder:
Karina(5/5) ✅
Giselle(4/5) ✅❌
Winter(4/5) ✅❌
Ning Ning(3/5) ❌

[wilvdu]

Vocal:
Karina✅
Winter✅
Ningning ✅
Giselle✅
Rap:
Karina✅
Winter❌
Giselle✅
Ningning❌
Dance:
Karina✅
Giselle❌
Winter✅
Ningning ❌
Sp:
Ningning ✅
Giselle❌
Karina✅
Winter❌
Overall:
Karina: 4/4
Ningning:2/4
Giselle:2/4
Winter:2/4

[aastar]

Giselle literally ruined æspa chances of being all rounders