The Comfort Book Club / Marple - Twelve New Mysteries

Welcome to October's Comfort Book Club discussion! My Mum, Donna, and I are chatting about this month's book club choice, 'Marple: Twelve New Mysteries' written by contemporary authors in honour of Agatha Christie's beloved elderly sleuth, Miss Marple. There are spoilers in this chat, as we're assuming you have read the book if you watch. Special thanks to the readers who sent voice messages for this video, which were included in our discussion: Myriam, Gina, Antoniette, Laura, Sherri and Victoria.
—

SUPPORT: No pressure at all, but if you would like to support my work by making a donation to my channel, you can do so by clicking the 'Thanks' heart sign, just under the title of this video (in the same bar where you find the 'like' button)
—
LINKS:
(affiliate links used for Blackwells)

BLACKWELLS: If you order a book from Blackwells using one of my affiliate links, I may make a small commission from your purchase, at no additional cost to yourself. I like to support Blackwells by linking to their website, as I’m a big fan of their flagship Oxford bookshop, and they offer reasonable overseas shipping. You in turn support my work by shopping through my affiliate link. Thank you!

[PokhrajRoy.]

I don’t think people will ever understand that Miss Marple was THE Cottagecore legend.

[wuMcK]

I loved this book of short stories, so happy to have Miss Marple back again.. and so many really captured her so well. I agree about the final one not quite 'getting it right'... I loved the one set at Christmas time, I wish we had more Christmases with Miss Marple! (I feel like reading A Christmas Tragedy from The Thirteen Problems)

Thank you so much for suggestion this book! I enjoyed it immensely.

I read one of the 'new' Poirots and thought she captured the character pretty well, I had a difficult time finishing because of the overly long 'reveal'. But it was well written and I look forward to the Christmas one w/Poirot.

And will look into finding some new Sherlock Holmes, one of my favorites next to Miss Marple ...who is my absolute favorite sleuth!

I love the Comfort Book Club so much. I live rural and difficult to find a bookclub especially with the kinds of 'cozy' books I love. So difficult to find my 'tribe of book lovers' but here I feel I have. Thank you Miranda and Donna. I hope you enjoyed your cheese and caraway scones and tea 🙂 🍵

[MaroufMOM]

So nice to visit with you and Donna. This will be a lovely evening

[MJ-in-Canada]

Donna goes off-piste with a cup of coffee!☕🤣

[sandyokey]

I adore Agatha Christie, and was so pleased at how well the contemporary authors portrayed Miss Marple. She is also my favorite sleuth. I think my favorite story was written by Ruth Ware, and her tip of the hat given to Dorothy L. Sayers, who is another favorite of mine. Donna, love your new hairstyle, and thanks to you both for a delightful visit.

[T-M]

Absolutely delightful to see a mother daughter reading team!🐾👏🏼🐾📚

[susanfisher]

I agree with Miriam about Blackwell’s. Their shipping fee to the USA is so reasonable and their book selection is wonderful!

[christinalinklater]

Thank you for a cozy and convivial visit, Donna and Miranda! I so appreciate everyone's wonderful comments -- it was great fun to read these stories with all of you.

[atinylyfemakesteam]

When I read this book earlier this year I loved it! I'm a huge Miss Marple fan since I was young! I too used to dream of living in St. Marys Meade. Then one day I thought to myself "knowing my luck I'd end up being the random victim found in the weirdest place."

[glendaslanina]

Hello Miranda and Donna. I, too, enjoyed this collection. Being October and reading Victorian literature, it was a nice break to pick up short stories especially involving Miss Marple. My favorite was Miss Marple’s Christmas. I love house party stories where the carefully planned festivities go awry. And what a large bunch of mistletoe it had to be to hide pearls! Thank you for this fun read and a good discussion.🎄

[JillK-regv]

Oh that was delightful! Miranda, I have only just discovered you, as I’m new to the world of Booktube. How wonderful to hear your thoughts and those of your lovely mum. You’re so in tune with each other. I have listened to some of these stories on Audible and Val McDermid’s one was my favourite. I know some die hard Christie fans are sniffy about new stories but I think it is a testament to her enduring appeal as a writer. After all, Shakespeare’s plays are also reinterpreted and adapted for the present day. I’m SO much looking forward to catching up with your lovely channel x

[Crystal-tg]

I have never read any of Agatha Christie books, so this was a first very enjoyable read not finished yet. Thanks so much massive soft hugs to you and your gorgeous mother who l adore. We managed to visit the David Hockey exhibition in Yorkshire, thanks to your recommendation. Gratitude & appreciation for all your hard work. 🩷🧡💛☕️🧁🇬🇧

[toddbelanger]

Oh my goodness just yet again a beautiful fun video ...thank you ladies for making my rainy Sunday perfect...love love love your channel.

[naomihickman]

Loved hearing your and Donna’s thoughts on this. I enjoyed spending time with Miss Marple again while reading it. My favourite stories were the ones set in classic, cosy Miss Marple settings and where other familiar characters turned up. My least favourite one, was the same story as you and Donna, for exactly the same reason. Although a fun read, for me it really highlighted how incomparable Agatha Christie’s superbly ingenious books are!

[joanyoung]

So enjoyable. Miranda and Donna you bring the sunshine. Thank you. 🤗

[jilldavis]

You ladies are the best. Always so much fun. Thank you!!!

[inlaterdays]

I really enjoyed this book! It was such fun to see so many different authors' takes on Miss Marple. I'd be hard pressed to pick a favorite story, but the ending of one made me smile - where Miss Marple reflects on how nice it was to solve a mystery without anyone having to die for a change. Of course I do love the murdery stories as well! Also thank you to both of you for suggesting more writers - I haven't read much beyond Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, and Josephine Tey.

[sue]

I loved this collection of stories and wasn't sure if I would as I am a huge Miss Marple fan and I was worried they wouldn't live up to my expectations! Thank you for sharing the voice messages and for your great discussion and other recommendations. Also what lovely flowers you have on your table there - such a joy to look at. x

[juliasherwin]

I have just started this on audible and I have been so looking forward to it. Sadly due to pain in my neck and arms, I am unable to enjoy traditional books as I used to, but I wanted to let you know how much comfort you and your mum bring me with your videos. Whenever I am feeling really down and can't get out to enjoy nature and beautiful outdoor spaces myself, I put on your videos and take in the joy you both get from your books, days out and tasteful purchases. I just wanted to let you know how much of a positive influence you have on people ❤

[MJ-in-Canada]

I love the synchronized "so cosy" around 3:44.