Understanding Private Inheritance in C++: Does It Create Base-Class Objects?

Explore the concept of `private inheritance` in C++ and learn whether it truly creates base-class objects in derived classes. Get clarity on this essential OOP principle.
---

Visit these links for original content and any more details, such as alternate solutions, latest updates/developments on topic, comments, revision history etc. For example, the original title of the Question was: Does private inheritance actually create a base-class object in the derived class?

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---
Understanding Private Inheritance in C++: Does It Create Base-Class Objects?

In the world of C++ programming, object-oriented programming (OOP) introduces various concepts like inheritance that can sometimes lead to confusion. One such topic is private inheritance and its role in creating base-class objects within derived classes. A recent inquiry raised a pertinent question: "Does private inheritance actually create a base-class object in the derived class?" Let’s delve into this question and clarify the related concepts.

The Basics of Inheritance

Before diving into private inheritance, it’s important to understand basic inheritance principles in C++. Inheritance allows one class to inherit characteristics (properties and behaviors) from another.

Key Concepts of Inheritance:

Base Class: The class whose features are inherited.

Derived Class: The class that inherits from the base class.

Subobject: An instance of a class that is treated as part of another class instance.

In C++, there are different types of inheritance, including public, protected, and private inheritance. Each of these types governs how the members of the base class are accessible in the derived class.

What is Private Inheritance?

Private inheritance indicates that the derived class will inherit from the base class but won't expose its interface publicly. Instead, only the derived class has access to the members of the base class. Here's how it works:

Access: Members of the base class become private members of the derived class.

Usage: You can use base class functions in the derived class, but not outside of it.

This is fundamentally different from containment, where an object is added explicitly as a member - in private inheritance, the inherited base-class object is instantiated automatically within every instance of the derived class.

Does Private Inheritance Create Base-Class Objects?

The crux of the question lies in whether inheritance translates to base-class objects being created in derived classes. So, does it? Yes, but with some nuances.

Clarifications:

Object Level: It's crucial to realize that it’s not the class itself that contains member objects but rather each object of the class type.

Subobjects: Each object from the derived class has a base class subobject as part of its structure. Hence, you can think of it as creating a base-class object as a part of the derived class's object.

Terminology: The terminology may vary. The phrase "add an object to a class" usually means adding either members or base classes, but it’s critical to remember it applies to objects at runtime rather than just the structure defined at compile time.

Why Private Might Be Confusing

You might wonder why the term private is relevant here. In this context, it primarily helps illustrate differences in how components can be accessed. However, in the case of creating a base-class object within derived classes, the 'private' status similarly does not change the fact that the derived class includes the subobjects from its base classes.

Conclusion

In summary, private inheritance does indeed lead to the creation of base-class objects within derived classes. This concept reinforces the OOP principle of encapsulating behavior and ensuring control over which components are accessible from outside the class hierarchy. By understanding these essential distinctions, C++ programmers can effectively utilize inheritance to design robust and structured applications.

Armed with this knowledge, you can effectively navigate the intricacies of C++ inheritance and apply these concepts in your programming endeavors!