Fitbit Surge Review - How smart is it? - Smartwatch Reviews 2015

preview_player
Показать описание
The Fitbit Surge is definitely a fitness super watch but how is it any good as a smartwatch?

The Surge is Fitbit’s most expensive wearable but also does the most as it provides heart rate monitoring, sleep tracking, GPS and as well as basic call and text notifications. It’s a fairly comfortable device to wear and has a great battery life. In our opinion, the Surge is a highly evolved fitness device first with smart watch features that feels a little slow.

Based on our time with the Surge, we gave it a score of 4 Eh’s out of 5. We feel that this is a better smart watch then the Pebble classic and does much better than Fitbit’s own Charge HR and Flex.

In terms of design, the Surge is a fairly bulky device though we didn’t find it getting into the way as much as the Pebble did. We didn’t have any issues with the wear and tear of the Surge despite looking like it is going to be uncomfortable to wear, we were surprised at how well at sat on our wrists.

Fitbit recommends that you wear the Surge approximately 1 finger distance from your wrist bone to ensure a good heart-rate monitoring connection. This placement feels really awkward to me and I found that it was almost impossible for me to keep it at the optimal placement if I was wearing a long shirt. For fitness, Fitbit recommends 2-3 fingers which means the Surge is sitting close to the middle of my arm and if you’re doing an activity that requires lots of hand movement, like lifting, it’s going to move around a lot which gets annoying.

For durability, Fitbit claims that the Surge has 7+ day battery life. Now I was a little apprehensive at first with this claim since my low battery power would come on after 5-ish days but the Surge would stay powered for another 1.5 -2 days after the warning.

In terms of protection, the Surge is water resistant up to 50 m but Fitbit suggests that up don’t wear it swimming or in the shower with the primary reason of letting your skin breathe a bit.

In terms of functionally, this is where the Fitbit stumbles in terms of being a smart watch but shines as a fitness device. As we said at the beginning of the video, the Surge is a fitness device first, smart watch second.

One of the biggest things that limits how useful the Fitbit surge is the lack of 3rd Party Support in terms of apps. In our minds, a big strength of the smart watch is being able to add additional functionality via apps. Going from a Pebble to this Surge was very noticeable because I couldn’t customize what I saw on my wrist.

In terms of handling, which we’ve defined as actually interacting with the device, the Fitbit Surge is a little quirky. This is a touch-enabled device but you still have to rely on the physical buttons to use the Surge.

In terms of viewability, you can easily see the watch face in direct sunlight and the is backlit for darker viewing though you can’t just shake your wrist to activate the backlit, you need to push a button. interesting enough, there is a light sensor somewhere as the backlit doesn’t activate in direct light.

Notifications are pretty basic as you only have call and text notifications which I felt was a bit limiting. You can’t really customize the watch faces much and we found that the Flare clock face was really the only one that would tell you how active you were during the day.

Heart rate monitoring is accomplished via Fitbits PurePulse Technology, which are these green blinking LED’s that measure stuff in your skin. That portion of the Fitbit Surge extends past the bottom of the watch so it will almost stay in contact with your skin which means you’ll get red sticky areas after a while.

There is a GPS receiver on this watch which is pretty crazy and it generally works. Like most other trackers, it will count your steps and flights climbed as well but is pretty boring.

Now to put all these sensors to use, Fitbit allows you to easily select a specific activity easily. This feature can easily be the number one reason to get the Surge over the Charge HR but once you get going on an activity, you get a summary display showing you relevant information to whatever activity that you’re doing.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subscribe to stay in the loop! We release 2-3 videos a week so there's going to be something new every week. We're all about helping you get the most out of iOS so click Subscribe!

Рекомендации по теме
Комментарии
Автор

You are the best reviewer out there!keep up the amazing reviews!

bubbagarcia
Автор

Very good, and fair, review. I've had my Surge about four months and consider it a good investment despite its quirks, as you have identified. I run (alright, 'jog') and the GPS sold me as I can leave the iPhone 6+ at home rather than wear it in an armband. I agree that lack of third party integration is the greatest weakness, and I suspect some innovative developers could fix up some of the idiosyncrasies of the device.

bf
Автор

Your wearing it way too loose. A device with a heart rate monitor needs to be tightened down so as it doesn't move when you shake your hand. It will leave imprints and be a bit uncomfortable but that's how it needs to be worn for accurate readings

jeremygr
Автор

I'm thinking about getting the charge hr now! Could you do a full review on it please?

CTRL-ALT-DEREK
Автор

Have you ever thought about reviewing the Incipio Bombproof for the iPhone 6. Looks like a solid rugged case and I loved it for the iPhone 4. Thanks Aaron!

Redstar
Автор

Thanks Aaron for the another good review.

selocanish
Автор

MobileReviewsEh amazing review...and so detailed...thanks a lot!!!

btw, can you please tell me what iphone 6 case your using at/around 1:57 on the vid?  thanks!

JRx
Автор

Good review!! Really made me want one!

missbeautytwins
Автор

my gf wants one of these as she is trying to lose weight and thinks it will help her keep track of how she's doing day to day. I don't want to waste money on tech that doesn't do what it claims so I watched your video review. Seems like its not a smart buy but maybe a later model would be after they fix a few issues. So in the end thanks for the info.

darkcatt
Автор

Garmin Forerunner 15? Could you do a video on this?

Amelia-libn
Автор

Does the charge hr's screen get scratched up easily?

Damnitmak
Автор

I don't understand how to make my Surge monitor sleep. You say it does it automatically, but my 1st night sleeping with it, I got NO data

joangilbert
Автор

What was the band you used in the beginning ?
And how is that compared to surge?

NorwegianElk
Автор

I mean it is hard to say it is a "Smart Watch" it is more of a fitness tracker or physical watch i mean yes i do wish it had some customization but it's not like an Apple Watch which is suppose to be like a phone on your wrist.

gameplayer
Автор

I've heard that this thing can bug out after getting even a little wet. I've heard that sweating can mess it up. Is this true?

DustinKFowler
Автор

what do u think the best smartwatch for ios>?

tembikai
Автор

What case are u using on the iphone 6 on this video?

paradicx
Автор

+MobileRevieshEh how did asd inc turn into this wonderful amazing channel

theaccentman
Автор

HI, COULD ANYONE PLEASE MESSAGE ME REGARDING WHEN IS FIT BIT, GOING TO UP- GRADE THE FIT BIT SURGE HR GPS SMART WATCH, I HAVE THE PRESENT MODEL, BUT I'M HOPING THAT THE UP - GRADED VERSION WILL BE MORE ADVANCED, WITH MORE LED LIGHTS, SIMILAR, OR EVEN BETTER THAN THE POLAR M 600, FOR BETTER ACCURACY FOR HEART RATE MONITORING. BEST REGARDS, DAVID.

davidmorgan
Автор

They should add a face that let's you see seconds.

GamerRusith