NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs ProForm Pro 2000 Treadmill Comparison

With a similar price point ($1,000 to $1,500) and many common features, it can be tough for the discerning consumer to choose between the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 and the ProForm Pro 2000 treadmills.

We’ve determined that the NordicTrack 1750 is a better buy, however, because of its slightly larger motor, more durable belt and greater versatility—features that may explain why this treadmill is the highest-selling on the market.

It’s hard to go wrong with either of these powerful and sturdy machines, though. And while prices fluctuate, the Pro 2000 tends to run about $200 less than the NordicTrack 1750. With this in mind, a thorough point-by-point comparison is in order.

Both models have a 300-pound weight capacity, 12 mph maximum speed, a 22” wide by 60” long running surface, and an incline range of -3% to 15%. This last attribute is great for people who live in flat areas looking to train in running hills. Both machines also carry identical warranty plans: lifetime frame, deck and motor; 5 years for parts; and 2 years for labor.

The NordicTrack 1750 and the Pro 2000 both offer pulse grip. They also have chest strap heart rate monitoring, a method we find more reliable than handle heart rate monitors. You can get the accurate readings you need with the NordicTrack 1750’s iFit chest strap and the Pro 2000’s Polar chest strap.

These two machines differ in some noticeable ways, however.

The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 has a 2-ply belt while the ProForm Pro 2000 has a 1-ply belt. A 1-ply belt is liable to wear out more quickly than a 2-ply, so the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 can better withstand the wear and tear of multiple regular users.

There’s another important difference between these two treadmills. To paraphrase an old saying, what a difference a point makes. The NordicTrack 1750 has a 3.5 CHP motor while the Pro 2000 has a 3.5 CHP motor. The NordicTrack 1750’s slightly larger motor size can tip the scales in its favor if you’re using it for regular training and need a strong motor to keep up with you.

Another difference is a matter of comfort, which is important when you’re putting your body through challenging paces. The ProForm Pro 2000 has two fans while the NordicTrack 1750 has three fans. Along with being greater in number, the NordicTrack 1750’s fans are more powerful. It’s an undeniably “cool” feature.

Both treadmills aim to keep your workout varied rather than tedious by offering a large number of programs. The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 wins by a nose on this one, however, with 38 available programs as opposed to the ProForm Pro 2000’s 32 programs.

If you’ve succumbed to the “tiny house” craze, you may want to look beyond these two machines for something more compact, because both of them are relatively bulky.

The ProForm Pro 2000 is 70” tall, 77.2” long and 39.5” wide, while the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 is 61” tall, 72.25” long and 38” wide. Doing the math, however, the NordicTrack 1750 has a slightly smaller footprint, which can make all the difference when finding a place to squeeze in your work out. Both machines have hydraulic systems that make it easy for a single user to raise and lower the treadmill deck.

Our final assessment is that both the ProForm Pro 2000 and the NordicTrack 1750 are quality machines that can match the most serious trainer stride-for-stride. Overall, however, the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 gets our stamp of approval.

Read their independent reviews here:

Watch their individual review videos here:

[nsg]

Thank you for the succinct review/comparison covering the important points. You have helped me make my decision between the two treadmills; Nordic Track 1750.

[adamdelay]

Both Nordictrack and Proform are from the same company. They are just manufactured in difference areas.

[christopherbenson]

Hello, and thanks for the review! Right now, the Proform Pro 200 is on sale for $1149, whereas the best price I can find for the Nordictrack Commercial 1750 is $1549. I'm wondering if you feel the Nordictrack is $400 better or it it makes sense to get the Pro 2000 at that price difference? Also, I think the $1549 for the 1750 is just updated - would you expect to see any further discounts as we get closer to Black Friday? Thanks for your help!

[erinthomas]

After the free 1 yr iFit subscription for the Nordic track, can I cancel and have no issues using the treadmill or is it required for use?

[TheseusTitan]

When I clicked on the link in your description, the NordicTrack 1750 doesn’t look anything like the one in your video. I don’t see a higher low set of fans and I don’t see the tablet holder on the one on your web site. Are these things accessories?

[NNN-rgex]

Awesome review, especially since I'm trying to decide between these two machines.

Questions: 1) You mentioned that the 1750 has 3.8 CHP motor, but their website says the engine is 3.6 CHP. So were you testing a previous model that had a better motor?, and 2) Are you aware of NordicTrack/ProForm offering Black Friday deals in previous years? Because I don't want to buy now (late October) if there are potential savings in a couple of weeks.

[heckman]

Which is better between the Nordic 1750 and the bowflex T216?

[pookaloo]

Great review. Getting myself a treadmill as my Christmas give from me to me. Do treadmills come with the mat or is this something you have to buy separately?

[michaeltrent]

So after the ifit subscription is over the Nordic Trac is DOA? Where can i buy the Proform 2000 its sold out everywhere

[ovwudwi]

Perfect review! Just what I was looking for. Is the free ifit subscription only for the Nordic track website, or is it for all purchases of this treadmill? Thank you!

[iamric]

I would like to know if I have to lubricate the belt from time to time?

[thedoug]

how big a tablet will each of these units hold? Can iFit be used on a windows machine (Surface Pro) or is iOS or Android a requirement?

[ricardocalderon]

Quick Question because I as well am trying to decided between these two for my wife and I. First off when clicking on both links it takes us to what seems like slightly different versions. The 1750 in the link doesn't have a second bottom fan. And the ProForm on the link has an HD screen to use with iFit. Not sure if maybe the models in this review are old? But not sure why they would get rid of the second fan. So I have found the ProForm Pro 2000 w/o HD screen on the Academy Sports and Outdoors website for $899, and then the 1750 it jumps up to $1, 487. Now in your review the price difference is a couple hundred bucks and for that difference it seems like a no brainer to go with the 1750 but with this huge price difference what would you honestly do?

[brillowolf]

So you’re advertising the 1750 as best in the $1500 range. But that doesn’t include the mandatory 1 yr subscription to iFit at $39 a month. Almost $470 more. Might not exactly qualify as false advertisement, but it isn’t far off.

Also when you do a little research into iFit, it gets pretty frightening with all of the horror stories and NordicTrack’s poor customer service. There are plenty of stories out there of people that have dropped nearly 2 grand into this machine and merely end up with a non functioning piece of furniture for their investment. I would like to find out I’m wrong, but I haven’t seen hardly any truly independent sources with a positive perception of anything NordicTrack.

[chukwe]

Do any of these Treadmills have PAUSE Buttons?

[jrock-xsvp]

I hear Nordic Track has bad customer serv

[submissions]

Where are you finding the nordictrack under 1500?lol