Can you guess the costume in 4 pictures? (YIAY #628)

aka the VERY late Halloween special oops

[frijjfan]

my greatest achievement is having sent Jack down the homestuck sharpie bath rabbit hole

[crowzur]

Jack not knowing which one is Rhett or Link is hilarious especially because he has been on the show a few times

[CaptainJ]

“In just 4 pics” should absolutely become a new YIAY sub-series.

[ejaybugboyyt]

Normally a joke this run into the ground would suck, but that stretch of like 5 Jack to The Future outfits and Jack absolutely dying fucking broke me. That was so insanely good. Holy shit.

[MajiggerRose]

Fun fact about the "baby" gravestone. There was actually a time when gravestones would just be small headstones basically just saying "baby" because with the high infant mortality rate, babies often weren't given names at birth.

...I guess that wasn't a very fun fact, was it? :(

[summer]

I love how Jack got the Ace Attorney joke almost instantly, but the Homestuck reference took a while

[kristym]

The editors putting Ian and Anthony over that bit about Jack not knowing Rhett vs Link was a highlight for me

[BonseyJonsey]

Of course Jack is the kinda guy who saves all his old phones in one drawer

[danner]

Thank you for that 'Isn't America basically the planet' reference, hands down the funniest joke she ever made

[izzysauls]

Calling the troll horns “cat ears” made me cringe and then laugh for a good 5 minutes. Lov you Jack you old fart

[holliwawa]

The sharpie bath incident also vandalized the hotel room the cosplayer was sharing with a group if I remember correctly. Lmao

[tweer]

8:12 Fun fact: the creator of Undertale and Deltarune wrote music for Homestuck. The creator of Slender: The Eight Pages also wrote music for Homestuck.

[Topazzzzzz]

confronting people with homestuck in the year of the lord 2023 should be a criminal offense

[prageruwu]

him finding out about the homestuck sharpie bath story was hilarious

[marxssweetass]

Seeing Jack talk about Homestuck was something I would've never expected to happen.

Yet here we are

[sylphofheart]

every time jack mentions homestuck i grow stronger

[aykrivwassup]

the "worst halloween costumes" tradition is broken 😢 this episode looks fun too tho!

[elle]

little else has been as thrilling today as watching jack learn of the homestuck sharpie alcohol bath in real time

[OstroGothic]

Love seeing the Izzzyzzz cameo for the Homestuck cosplayer video - great channel

[clulessidiotowo]

The fact that I recognized the bathtub and sharpie immediately scares me