Railsaws: Makita SP6000 vs Festool TS55

Do you want to learn how to design and make fitted furniture? Here is my course:

You know Festool is good, but so is Makita and do you really need to pay more?

There are lots of railsaw choices on the market these days, but for many professional users or very serious DIYers it still often comes down to a close call between these two models as a balance of features and price - The Festool TS 55 vs the Makita SJ6000.

So what are the real differences between them? This video will answer your questions with plenty of up-close shots side by side, as well as clear explanations from an experienced user, and showing the saws in use, ensuring you come away with a detailed knowledge of the pros and cons of both machines.

Not an unboxing video, this video is valuable as a comparison of how these saws have faired after years of heavy usage in a professional workshop and site environment.

[TFfan]

Festool is better, but for the prize, you get what you need in a Makita.

[AncoraImparoPiper]

This has been the best comparison so far and I've been watching at least a dozen comparisons to allow me to decide which saw will suit my needs. Not anyone was as detailed as you. I am now definitely leaning towards the Makita. Since I am merely a hobbyist, it will take many years before I wear out my Makita. I will also buy the corded version since they have dropped in price markedly probably because the battery powered saws are now so much more popular. Good time to buy! Thanks for your efforts in making this review. I've subscribed too.

[thetallcarpenter]

Hi Alastair. Thanks for taking the time to do this video. I find these kind of tool reviews far more honest than your usual, 'tool guy', ones. Showing tools in their intended environments being used by proper tradesmen after many hours of service gives the kind of real information that guys like me who work in carpentry need when considering new tool purchases. Its interesting that I bought the Makita based on an almost identical comparison of the two from a good friend of mine who noted all the same things as you including the worn guide cams on the Makita and how easy they are to replace. I'm not an every day track saw user, so felt that the cheaper Makita would serve my needs perfectly. Cheers.

[robzilla]

I work at a custom furniture manufacturer and have used both the Festool and Makita. I've found the TS 75 takes 2 or 3 passes to get thru 2" material where as the Makita will power thru it on 1 pass with a relatively smooth glue ready cut. I've also noticed the splinter guard as more of hindrance then a help. The Festool feels underpowered in comparison but I do like the extra depth of cut with the TS 75. Great video and comparison, thanks for posting.

[harry]

I've used both, I ended up buying the Festool, had it about 5 years and it's an absolute joy to use. The Makita can do the job but the Festool just feels so much nicer and thats just getting it out of the sustainer !!!

[renegutierrez]

I have had the makita saw for abut 4 years now, and had been hesitating about getting the festool, until a couple of months ago when a finally got it, in my opinion makita has nothing to envy from festool, actually to me it felt like the festool bogged while cutting 1 3/4 solid doors, which's never happen with my makita, also the blade got dull really fast on the festool. And to be honest the festool seems to be more precise, anyway both of them are great saws, not much different from one another in my opinion, except for the price of course.

[jonmars]

I have both saws and have some experiences not mentioned here. Now the Festool that I have is probably the first edition they made. It's a little under powered but works well with a sharp blade. Festool may have made improvements since I purchased my saw. I have recently bought the Makita and am not at all disappointed with its performance. Very similar to the Festool at a much more affordable price. The one issue I had with Festool that I'd like to mention is with brush replacement. Festool uses a special brush cartridge that is positioned by a slot in the saw's cheap plastic housing. It's not easy to get at the brushes. The plastic, unfortunately melts at low temperatures and the brush on my saw heated up enough to fuse itself into the plastic housing. I was ultimately successful in extracting the cartridge but there was damage that could have rendered the saw unrepairable. If it happens again, the saw will be made useless for simple want of brush replacement. Makita uses standard brushes making brush replacement painless and easy.

[lb]

Thank you for this well formatted, informational comparison! We were deciding between festool, Maffel, and Makita and we decided to go w/ makita thanks to your comparison. We won’t be putting nearly as many hours on our tool so I don’t think wear and tear is as much of an issue

[johngibson]

You mention that these are both good saws and I agree. First thing I did was sand off the container latches On the Makita and they work fine now (poor Engineering effort on Makita’s part, I agree). I would agree that the Festool may be a better saw in some respects, for professional use, but many would say the price point on the Makita would make it the winner. I have both (just gave my son the Makita) and would be just as happy with either saw. I do like having the riving knife for ripping a straight edge on hardwood. A very decent review though. Cheers!

[freedomfighter]

Great review - fair, honest and unbiased. Also very "down to earth" and factual, no "smartness" here. Really appreciate your style and content, thanks!

[SME_Ste]

Makita for me too. I’m actually an electrician, but for some reason have been involved in fitting kitchens now for 5 years or so. The makita has always done everything i’ve needed it to perfectly. Looked at bosch and festool at the start but couldn’t see the extra cost justifying itself for what i needed it for. My only grip is the depth stop, must remember to add 6mm when used in the rail

[brenttaylor]

I found adding a third grip strip beside the splinter strip aided my work, also the DeWalt's rail clamps are a great help. Great vid, thanks

[tapsulinka]

Good video.

I do cut aluminum profile mats every day. I would say it's hard work for every saw. I have had Festool several years and the quality is the same as the day I bought. It was twice the price of Makita but I think I made best choice. For home usage Makita might be okay.

Please remember that it's very important which cutting blade you are using. Choose the right blade for the work. If you cut any kind of materials having glue or plastic, notice that because of the heat, this plastic or glue will easily stick to the blade and make cutting results worse. Buying all the time new blade can cost a lot. You can try cleaning the blade or bring it to special company for sharpening it

[djvasforever]

19:00 quick tip. If you have a Makita track saw, try Festool tracks, they are 0.1mm wider at that point, so the saw grips better.

[Greg-fsnp]

Thank you for the excellent, detailed review! Interestingly, I have the Makita and just yesterday I did a 90 degree, end grain cut through 7/8" white oak with no difficulty. I did take care to tighten the cam clamps, clamp the rail at both ends, clean dust from the saw base and rail, and steadily guide the saw through the cut. There were no problems with the saw jamming on the rail or burning the cut edge. I will say that my saw is relatively new with not a lot of use so that might be a factor accounting for my relatively trouble free end grain cut as compared to what you experienced. The take away I got from your review is that the Festool may do better with heavy use but the Makita is just fine for the more occasional hobbyist.

[MinuteWorkshop]

Very good Alastair, enjoyed that! I think the anti-tipping lip on the Makita is only there to stop the saw tipping over at the end of the cut, not to keep it on track during a bevel cut - my understanding, anyway. 👍

[SharpEdgeWoodworking-UK]

Hey Alistair.... I've recently upgraded my plunge saw and I was between exactly these 2 contenders. With fortune circumstances of a promotion price AND access to somebody's staff discount I was able to get the Festool for £280 brand new.... so that was the winner.... and I love it.

[jameshite]

I’m a Festool fan. I’ve had both sizes of the Festool track saw and ended up liking cordless Makita best.

[pauljohn]

Hi, I have had the makita for 5 or 6 years now, I use a lubricant wax on the track and base plate of the saw, it does help a lot. The adjustable cams are cheap and easy to replace.

[johnmackay]

A very fair review. I recently replaced those blue cam inserts as I was having similar issues with my makita. It did improve it a lot more IMO. I also use a PTFE spray lubricant on the rail now and then, this also can help. The Makita certainly hasn't been perfect but after 8 years of kitchen fitting abuse it has fared pretty well. Seriously looking at the cordless version now. All the best.👍