PSA Reveal PART 2!!! Vintage Sportscards, Did PSA grade too tough?

PSA Reveal Part 2!!! Vintage Sportscards, Did PSA grade too tough?

Follow me on
Twitter/Instagram @huckscards
Facebook- Huck’s Cards

[mikethesportshistorycollec]

Great cards especially those beautiful 1971's with the bold black borders and the gloss.

[jamespinette]

U got some very nice cards there Huck. What I have found out over the years is if your card is in nice shape except for centering, u will get a 6 if it is off center either top to bottom or side to side. U will get a 5 if it is off center top to bottom as well as side to side. I hit the grade almost all the time using this method.

[ClementeCollector]

Huck, thanks for shouting out my channel, so kind of you! Huck love seeing some cards, that you don’t see often in returns! That Clemente card is 🔥

[bobodonemilking]

They are grading 1 grade lower on vintage that's why I'm done with PSA on vintage, sgc is my new go to for vintage

[sfisportscards]

Great follow up video Huck. It's hard to top 3 consecutive years 71-73 as far as card design. Beautiful cards and great names to submit!

[zachandporter]

Thanks for sharing. Great cards but tough grades!

[JC-pugi]

SGC much more reliable on grading and Slabs much nicer & turn around time is fantastic try SGC

[cardboardandplastic]

Whenever you see a 5 and have no idea why it got it, there is a very tiny surface wrinkle on the card that you typically have to search for. I think they take off way too much for a tiny wrinkle on the card, but it is what their grading rubric says. I have a bunch of 60's to 80's cards that are absolutely perfect except for a tiny wrinkle on the card. Unfortunately, that means they can't be graded. However, I will buy those PSA 5's all day long when people sell them for the price of grading!

[kennethsalter]

Love the Kaline 73 ....One of his best! Agee...should be a 7

[vintagesportscards]

130 some graders in the room as opposed to 15 or so in the past. Inconsistent is their new standard

[carlr]

Is it just me, or do a lot of the newly submitted PSA slabs are coming back crooked ?

[raykrouse]

I got back a 1961 Bob Gibson that was graded a PSA 4 that I thought was really misgraded so I cracked it out and resubmitted and it came back a PSA 6 so that shows you it is just someone's opinion and those opinions can be inconsistent. I do think vintage are being graded very hard.

[stevesousa]

Do you think with the new PSA grading standards that older graded 7 and 8 will be price comparable to newer graded 6’s? We ate know they are the same card?

[vintagesportscards]

When did you submit? Sorry if you mentioned it I missed it if so.

[jdcards]

I wonder why some of the same year cards seem to be in a different holder and loose.

[vintagesportscardfinds]

Great cards Huck. Big fan of your reveal videos. Love the Clemente in an 8. That might as well be a gem mint 8 because I'm pretty sure, a perfect pre 1980 card starts at 8, and they go down from there.