Ipsy Glam Bag Vs. Macy's Beauty Box March 2025 | A CLOSE BATTLE

Macy's Facts: Macy's will send you beauty samples every month for $15 (+sales tax) and free shipping. You will receive 1 free bonus product each month, but the type of product will vary. No customization options.

Ipsy Facts: The ipsy glam bag is $14 a month + $2 handling fee + free shipping. This bag will contain 5 sample sized beauty products and 1 beauty bag each month. You are able to choose 1 of your 5 items each month.

#subscriptionsisters #ipsy #ipsyglambag #trending #macysbeautybox #macys

Want to mail me something? Have a box and want it featured? Send it to the address below!
Subscription Sisters
c/o Sydney
1704 N Bell # 154
Fremont, NE 68025 USA

Disclaimer: Unless stated, nothing in the video is sponsored or a paid advertisement. Many times a company will gift a box and/or product. This however, does not mean I have to review a box/product favorable. Gifted boxes/items do not come with any conditions. I am free to speak about them however I feel. I will on occasion include affiliate links in a video or video's description. These may or may not allow me to make a small commission. Your support is very much appreciated.

[SussexSandra]

This is a clear Ipsy win for me. The Macy box is like a Mother’s day gift

[SussexSandra]

I’ve always thought if Elizabeth Arden as middle aged and old lady beauty products.
And then i remembered that i’m now in that middle aged to old lady age bracket at 56😮
This brand has been around for years!!

[lauraneely]

Your icy eye makeup is 🤌🏽 *chef's kiss*! 😍

[ashleymyers]

Macy's won for me! Elizabeth Arden might be seen as an old lady brand but the skincare is really good quality 👌

[Jewels_]

I love the Macy's vs Ipsy bag "battle" videos! I think you're right that the win went to Ipsy. Really liked the bag but wish it was a bit redder to be a strawberry! Thx for the video, always love your energy! 😊😊

[kim_]

Ipsy!🍓 I love that cute bag and anything Glow Recipe. The powder compact is very nice, too.🥰

[kelliekelley]

I got the Macys box, really enjoyed the products!

[nikkiperry]

You ipsy has more items that I would use. I kind of liked seeing yours, cause I just started Ipsy back up after being off for years, but they have my profile better already for me. Seeing we only had one product the same helped me see they are actually looking at my profile perhaps! Hehe

[Jennifer-purplepixieJJ]

Hey Sidney! Great unboxings! I have gotten those same samples from Elizabeth Arden before and I loved them! I didn’t need more to see if I liked what it did for my skin…. It was fabulous! Unfortunately those aren’t very budget friendly products so I love them when I can get my hands on the samples from time to time.
Oh and I’ve gotta tell you, your eye makeup looks amazing! I love how you always match it to your shirt you’re wearing. You look so polished and professional! TFS. Have a great weekend! ❤

[jodislama]

As Always a great unboxing. I’ve really been noticing your skin it looks great your face is glowing .You look beautiful. 😊

[KristiFlesher]

I love❤ that foundation. Got it a while ago and haven’t been able to buy it in the US since then ☹️

[debrabrown]

I loved both boxes and am enjoying the great products. ❤

[hillaryfayle]

Macy's ! I'm enjoying trying all of these products.

[lourdescolon]

Hi my friend! We received the same products from Ipsy Glam bag!

[nightenbelle]

I think Ipsy won hands down. It feels like Macy’s charged you for what would normally be free samples.

[hagertj]

Its Macys for me. I discovered I love those Retinol capsules. They leave my skin so soft and smooth. I love the feel. I’ve learned over time I definitely would rather have quality over quantity.

[melissamccall]

Ipsy for the win for sure! Rafia. The bag does read watermelon. I'm really over Macy's take over boxes. Not excited by these products except for the capsules. These are definitely more free samples...ugh. I miss the fragrances.

[debrawalker]

It's OK o figured you always have to be surprised lol...I ordered what I liked on Amazon

[kirahogan]

Ipsy wins, hands down. I would much rather have more product to try and reasonably repurchase if I like it than to have expensive products I probably wouldn’t repurchase because as good as they may be, there are probably other products out there that give the same results

[maureen]

Ipsy is the winner for me. I didn’t think anyone under 50 used Elizabeth Arden but regardless the Macy’s bag had 3 moisturisers & 2 serums & I’d rather see a bigger variety of products like in the Ipsy bag.