Which Elden Ring Remembrance Options Are Best?

ranking all 15 remembrances worst to best. Which one should you duplicate? Patch 1.10 PVE list

HOW THE RANKING WORKS 0:00
MORGOTT 0:54
FIRE GIANT 2:02
FORTISSAX 4:10
REGAL ANCESTOR 5:42
PLACIDUSAX 7:12
RENALLA 8:50
RYKARD 10:42
GODRICK 12:02
ASTEL 13:50
MOHG 15:22
GODFREY 16:34
RADAHN 18:19
MALENIA 19:53
MALIKETH 21:36
ELDEN BEAST 23:28
NEXT RANKING VIDEO 25:28

[chef]

The best remembrance for several of these is... runes!

[klekman]

“Both of these weapons are kinda mediocre” **casually does 2K+ damage with grafted dragon**

[Rosu_yt]

Best rememberance is the friends we made along the way

[starblissed]

> "Giant's red braid is bad!"
> Casually does 2.8k to malenia and stuns her in place

[paulhinterberger]

The Ancestral Spirit's Horn is actually really nice for casual exploration as a mage since you'll be using Glintstone Pebble/ SGS to kill normal enemies, which are low cost. Makes flasks and fp go a lot further

[TheWroms]

Give this man his DLC already, he is stuck in endless ranking list loop.

[evanwhite]

the winged greathorn is a 15% damage debuff that lasts 60 seconds and since it makes a 10 second AOE to apply the debuff, you can use it before you're even near an enemy and then switch to a different weapon. i literally always pick it up just for that on any build, that debuff is crazy good for 12 FP.

[bjhale]

With Redahn's Remembrance, I would go for Lion Greatbow solely for the reason that it made fighting the Elden Beast somewhat fun because I was no longer chasing after it.

[pockystyx]

They better have a small roaming pack of walking mausoleums in the DLC.

[Panurome]

Ancestral spirit horn is amazing for clearing levels if you use fp more sporadically to do things like cast bestial vitality or an ash of war every now and then because it allows you to carry more red flasks, but is understandable that you think its very bad because judging from the background footage of your videos you seem to treat L2 as your main attack button

[Jay_Tsunami_]

Realistically Youwy. Could you do a series where you rank the Visual fidelity and coolness of spells and skills.
-Spells
-Incantations
-Weapon Skills
-AoW’s

Neglect how effective or efficient the abilities are, just judge solely on how cool and saucy they look.
I don’t think I’ve seen anyone else do this.

[Slowex]

For some reason Burn O Flame is much more reliable than ADLS to me. I don't have much trouble hitting enemies with it, including small ones, but I have the hardest time aligning the direction of ADLS and a lot of times it only hits once, dealing almost no damage, and it has completely whiffed more times than I would like to admit, while even one pillar of Burn O Flame deals more damage than one hit from a lightning strike and it feels less like I wasted a spell. It only becomes reliable when the enemy is big, and the damage surely is better, but also on the other side Burn O Flame is faster to cast and the ducking your character does when casting it amusingly has you dodging more attacks than it seems it would.

[kora]

Rykard's rancor is the single most underrated spell in the game; it's your fault to try to use it only as a projectile because it's not, it's true purpose is to be a highly versatile setup spell, you can cover your approach with it and start your offense, you can combo it into another spells, you can stay behind their explosions to cover as a defensive tool and make an opportunity to heal and when you start looking at it like that you'll notice that it's two slots cost despite it's low damage is perfectly balanced

[zacharypearce]

I'd honestly like the Ancestral Spirit's Horn talisman a lot more if it could be acquired much earlier. I like using the sacrificial axe in the off hand for pure caster and the fp regen per kill is very nice in the early game. Shame talisman is locked behind Radhan and by then you probably aren't having FP problems. Even the Blue Dagger Talisman can just serve you better. Sadge.

[VileLasagna]

Placidusax's Ruin has also the weirdness of not having any spell category, no matter how much it looks like all the dragon communion spells.

And yeah, the Ancestral Horn really deserves a buff

Also a hint for a lot of these, since we're talking about duplication:
If you want two copies of a weapon, you can make sure you grab one early by duplicating the remembrance before initiating NG+. That way you can trade in, say, a second Hand of Malenia or whatever, as soon as you reach the roundtable hold in the next playthrough.

Normally, even if you duplicate a remembrance, you can only get one copy of each reward

[Sargatas]

In fact this list is pretty accurate...even though I'm a little bias'd about Maliketh's rememberance, because, well...his sword is my favorite weapon in the game. And I wish that Marika's hammer had that holy caboom effect with it's charged heavy attack similar to what ruin's greatsword has.

[davidizenman]

I can’t believe you dissed whips like that. Dual Hoslows whip is goated

[davidlee]

finally! I was looking weeks ago and couldn’t find a video like this, so glad you made it 🙏

[Crying-Lightning]

Im being honest.. i was looking for this exact video yesterday but couldnt find one and seeing it now gives me joy.. specially after subbing you few days ago lol worth the sub! thanks a lot

[AccuracyBeast]

Blasphemous Blade - By far the most powerful weapon in Elden Ring. Especially out of all the rememberances.