Why Carl doesn't talk in Up 😨 #movie #shorts

Have you noticed this before? They have made a special effort, there must be a special reason for this situation, but I looked so much that I could not find a proper explanation 🤷🏻‍♂️ #up #moviereview #viral

[CrystalEze]

He never got a chance to talk because when he was old he talked 😊

[LucyMartinez-kd]

I watched this movie today and sadly Ellie died and didn’t make it to go to paradise falls I love this movie ever since it came out and sad that Carl and Ellie didn’t get to have children 😢

[helloiwanttootakeoverthewo]

I think it was just cause they couldn’t find a good younger voice actor

[amypauze]

Maybe it is because he was actually so surprised that he couldn’t talk any day

[nick_wilde.]

At least he got to say two words Like No and Wow

[ElijahNawwarandMSNAgain]

Actually he does. He never spoke when he was a kid

[RobertMaszota]

I never knew that he couldn't talk.

[Billybean]

I think that he can talk but he choose to not talk

[crippling]

He speaks at the end, and no one speaks when they were married because its a montage

[Bambi-]

Maybe it’s because he doesn’t feel like talking or he does friendly self with like action

[chrisdale]

We can't write
In the box >:(

[matildaphiri]

He never ever talk. I think he had a speech problem. Tell me in the box.

[alexaviersworld]

In up after Carl and Ellie look in Ellie’s My adventure book when Ellie leaves Carl puts his arm on the balloon and puts his head on his arm and says Wow

[Aiden-ejo]

I think he couldn’t talk because she was talking so much because when he was a old man, which is the main person, we see he is talking

[CandyBarreto-qj]

No bc I saw him do Sign language or hand language

[CoreyWebster-trpk]

I think Carl was shy as a kid and didn’t get a chance to talk as an adult

[AngelinaGilot-sn]

Oh yeah I know why because he didn't get to talk

[alijonmirzaev]

Do you see the hand motions? I think a mouth problem.

[barrylong]

Because he didn't want her to speak