ranking ALL I-LAND 2 Contestants (with reasons!)

ranking all 24 i-land 2 contestants, plus reasoning!
edited + decided by @euaiox
vids from @Mnet

~ not intended as any hate at all ~

this is an overall skill/debut-worthy related ranking and took a long while to make...thank you so much for watching!
drop video suggestions in the comments
hearts, euaio

[euaiox]

Kim Sujung's placement at #2 – she is an ace and all-rounder. She is highly charismatic, with fantastic stage presence, and dances excellently. She is shockingly stable as well, her higher notes are shocking. With time, her middle-range will develop and she will be an incredible idol. She delivered an outstanding performance, lacking in no category.
Yui's placement at #4 – she is an incredible all-rounder and deserves more recognition. With time, her singing will be excellent (right now you can hear that she is sort of fighting to support) ; she is already a great rapper and good dancer with great stage presence.
Nam Yuju's placement at #5 – I believe that Yuju should make her debut. She is incredibly stable whilst singing live (especially in the dance break), rapping live, and dances excellently with great sp. I don't know why she lip-synced her line, which I found disappointing, but she seems vocally adept judging by all other performances (from her earlier years, etc). She would have been higher if not for the lip-syncing.
Bang Jeemin's placement at #6 – she is very gifted, but Jeemin's vocal performance in Drama was lacking, which is why she placed low-ish (fans please don't hurt me). She is very stable, but she did not properly hit notes. Her stage presence is excellent though and she dances well, hence her higher rank (I reviewed RUNEXT as well).
Jeong Saebi's placement at #7 – honestly, she deserved higher. It shows just how skilled these trainees are that she placed here.
Koko's placement at #8 – this was difficult to decide. She is so skilled.
Mai's placement at #10 – overall, she is a weak vocalist and lacks strength when she sings and when she raps. She has a lot of potential, and that is why I placed her so high; alongside her charm and good stage presence, and beauty.
Ryu Sarang's placement at #11 – she is a good all-rounder, but her Unforgiven performance did not thoroughly show this. I felt that whilst she stayed very stable, her vocal tone was weak.
Yoon Jiyoon's placement at #13 – her voice is incredible, but her stage presence is weaker than the others.
Lingling's placement at #14 – she has a lot of swag and is a good dancer. Her stability and vocals need more training, you can hear her straining to force out strength in her tone, but she has a lot of potential.
Oh Yuna's placement at #15 – I believe the judges were very harsh. True, she had voice cracks and she lacks strength in her upper range, but she performed well with the parts she was given. Her stage presence, dance and visuals were fairly on point as well.
Yuiko and Choi Soul at #17 and #18 – these two are interchangeable.
Park Yeeun's placement at #19 – she has very good stage presence and is charming. She is weak vocally/with dance.
Kim Eunchae's placement at #20 – her stage presence fluctuates between decent and indecent. Her singing was strained and she is undertrained.
Um Jiwon's placement at #21 – considering the dance she had to do in her pre-chorus (Unforgiven, Yunjin's part), she was very stable. Lower placement because the others were better.
Kang Jiwon's placement at #22 – she is unstable with weak stage presence.
Kim Chaeeun's placement at #23 – she is very charming and cute, but she is highly unstable.

[hjsj]

Juwon lower than yuna doesn't make sense