Comparing Ryobi Compact Series PSBID01 and P238 Brushless Impact Driver ONE+ HP 18V

Ryobi Impact Driver:

RYOBI introduces the ONE+ HP 18V Compact Brushless 2-Tool Combo Kit with 1/2 in. Drill/Driver, 1/4 in. Impact Driver, (2) 18V Lithium-Ion 1.5 Ah Compact Batteries, 18V Charger, and Tool Bag. The 1/2 in. drill/driver is compact at only 6.4 in. in length, giving better access to the tightest workspaces and overhead applications. It’s also equipped with a brushless motor that delivers up to 400 in./lbs. of torque for maximum power when drilling and driving through tough materials. Other features include a 2-speed gearbox (0-450 and 0-1,700 RPM) and a 24-position clutch for maximum control while drilling and driving. And for quick bit changes, the 1/2 in. single sleeve ratcheting chuck with unique knurling pattern gives you that all important grip. At just 5.3 in., the impact driver is 26% more compact and over 23% lighter than our brushed impact driver. The brushless motor provides up to 1,700 in./lbs. of torque and up to 3,800 IPM to quickly drive a variety of fasteners. The impact driver features a variable speed trigger for precise control of up to 2,900 RPM and a knurled 1/4 in. hex collet with one-handed bit release. Best of all, it is part of the RYOBI ONE+ System of over 175 cordless tools that all work on the same battery platform. Backed by the RYOBI 3-Year Manufacturer's Warranty, this ONE+ HP 18V Compact Brushless 2-Tool Kit includes a 1/2 in. Drill/Driver, 1/4 in. Impact Driver, (2) 1.5 Ah batteries, charger, tool bag, and operator's manuals.

RYOBI introduces the 18-Volt ONE+ Cordless Brushless 3-Speed 1/4 in. Hex Impact Driver (Tool Only) with Belt Clip. The brushless motor provides more runtime, power, and longer motor life. The powerful design produces up to 2,000 in./lbs. torque to easily drive or tighten large fasteners. The MAGTRAY magnetic holder allows for the convenient placement of screws and bits. Best of all, it's a part of the RYOBI ONE+ System of over 175 Cordless Tools that all work on the same battery platform. Backed by the RYOBI 3-Year Manufacturer's Warranty, this 18-Volt ONE+ Brushless 3-Speed 1/4 in. Hex Impact Driver includes a belt clip, a Phillips bit, and an operator's manual. Battery and charger sold separately.

Compatible with LITHIUM+ HP batteries for even better performance
3-Speed Switch conveniently located on rear of tool for easy access: High Speed - 0-3,100 RPM, Medium Speed - 0-2,150 RPM, Low Speed - 0-1,100 RPM
Powerful design produces up to 2,000 in./lbs. of torque to easily drive or tighten large fasteners
Up to 4,350 IPM (impacts per minute) for fast driving applications
Tri-LED lights minimize shadows
1/4 in. auto-load chuck for fast and easy one-handed bit changes
Improved GRIPZONE overmold with microtexture for user comfort and control
Belt clip mounts to either side of tool for convenience
MAGTRAY magnetic holder for convenient placement of screws and bits
Part of the RYOBI ONE+ System of over 175 Cordless Tools
3-year manufacturer's warranty
Includes: (1) P238 18-Volt ONE+ Brushless 3-speed 1/4 in. Hex Impact Driver, (1) Phillips bit, (1) belt clip, and operator's manual

[izziereal]

I have the P238 impact driver and it's a great tool to have. I bought it earlier this year and have no interest in getting the new one as the P238 may be bigger, but gets the job done at ease. Great comparison video.

[ang]

Is it me or does the 238 have a lot more wobble

[weldonpinder]

This compact impact is not designed for the hp batteries cause the two extra contacts are not there that's the first flaw. The second is the mag trey isn't there and I can honestly say that's one thing I always boasted about Ryobi drills that other drills didn't have. The only good thing is it maybe lighter and a little more compact. If you ask me Ryobi really messed up. If your gonna upgrade you don't throw away the good features from the last upgrade

[jjsiegal]

WHICH would be best for Automotive work.. loosening bolts and screws in tight places ???

[pancakeninja]

Perfect for home DIY stuff that doesn't get overly abused!

[roysonparsons]

One feature you did not discuss. I believe the larger Ryobi impact driver has a three speed selector on the rear of the tool, is that correct? If so, does the speed selector provide an advantage in function?

[nicoleancell]

Are the batteries interchangeable? More specifically will the lithium+ battery work in the compact hp tool?

[TacticalThib]

Why did you compare a compact weak impact against ryobis top dog until the pblid02 came out you need to compare the p238 to the pblid02 this is stupid

[livingadreamlife]

In a new Subscriber and enjoy your info!

On another note, could you please tell me the title name of the acoustic guitar song in your videos? I play guitar and have been looking for the name of the song for ages. Thanks, in advance.

[descent]

imagine that small guy with the smaller barrel style battery.

[XellosMetallium]

Ooof the spec says this has 400 ft-lbs of torque.

[Admajors]

Just be aware, other reviewers have noted a *significant* difference using different capacity and types (lithium, lithium+, high performance) batteries.

If your goal is to compare the tools themselves, use the exact same battery when doing so.

[JoseSanchez-wbrz]

The p238 is the superior tool because it is an intelligent tool that uses the intelligent batteries better were the compact tool is brushless but not intelligent lacking the third point battery connection plus the p238 has three separate speed settings.