Best & Worst: Testing Eyeliner Pencils

Style, Beauty, Anti-Aging, & Health for Women in Their Hot-Flash Years!
EXPAND THIS BOX FOR MORE INFO!!
Thanks for watching! I'd love to hear from you, please rate, comment, subscribe.

Visit my Channel for more Videos:

Eyeliners Tested:
Make Up Forever Aqua Eyes
Sephora Contour 12Hr Wear
Revlon Colorstay
Maybelline Unstoppable
Laura Gellar I-Care
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On
Cover Girl Liquiline Blast
Smashbox Limitless

Related Videos:
***************************************
Best & Worst ~ Testing 5 High-End Liquid Foundations for Mature Skin
***************************************
Best & Worst ~ Testing 5 Drug Store Liquid Foundations for Mature Skin
***************************************
Best & Worst ~ Testing 5 Liquid Foundations for Mature Skin
****************************************
MakeUp For Hooded & Droopy Eyes:

Today's makeup:
Bourjois Healthy Mix in 53 "Light Beige"
Giorgio Armani Master Corrector #2
IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Concealer
NYX Blush in Peach
Physicians Formula OrganicWear Bronzer in Medium
NYX Eyelid Primer White
Tarte CC Mattenificent Limited Edition Palette
MUFE Aqua Eyes in "Dark Grey" 21L
Cover Girl Clump Crusher Mascara in Black
Tarte LipSurgence in "Believe" & "Generous"
Nail Polish: Urban Outfitters "Flip Flop"

[delacotta]

You do the best reviews! So well spoken and organized. You did a whole lot of work showing all the stages. Thank you ever so much! Great job. Now I gotta go check if you did a brow product video. That's what I'm on the hunt for. Hugs, Susan

[cherylblue]

Hi Angie.  I use Bare Minerals eyeliners and love them, but they are hard to remove at night, they have great stayon ability.  Thanks for all the reviews.

[tulipsurfer]

I have oily lids and I tried many, I can say my fav is Bobbie Brown gel liner is great but the best for pencil is Jordana 12HR liquid pencil liner. It is very creamy, gel like. It will not go anywhere. Cheap too. It gets dull quickly cause it is so creamy, so I collect the gel after I sharpen it and then put them in a small pot and use like gel liner. Fantastic.

[majordudette]

Clinique quickliner has been my go-to for a long time on my over-50 eyelids. Lasts all day for me, though I don't do waterlining due to contacts and sensitive eyes. I am always on the lookout for cheaper products that work, so your reviewing mixed products is very helpful, thanks!

[paulineanne]

I like to use Rimmel Scandal Eyes for waterline and liquid liner the felt pen type for over the lid still looking for best for for that.  But good review.

[solski]

Love your video! The natural and realistic result! unlike other tutorials, they are just reviewing the eyeliner but after putting the eyeliner the eye shadow, eye lash extension magically appears!!!

[champagne]

I've tried a few expensive $$$$ liners. They all ran. Just purchased a Wet n Wild felt tip eyeliner. Didn't smear the entire day. Love it! Only $3

[suescott]

Another great video Angie!  Love how you showed us the application and then how they performed.  Thank you for taking the time to road test all these eyeliners for us!

[yoursweetie]

For me with my older skin, (I'm 59) Urban Decay works wonderfully! Tightline, waterline, and above the lashes, it goes on easy, and stays on until I take it off. Urban Decay has also come out with 5 24/7 Velvet pencils that have no glitter and have a nice velvety soft look that I just love! I use either the Urban Decay eye primer or Too Faced Shadow Insurance. I also use the Smashbox under eye primer. 

[tonyahowell]

Have you ever tried Estee Lauder Doublewear eyeliner? I've been using it & it does pretty good in the waterline.

[sharp]

Thanks for taking the time to try these out for us.

[joannmcmahon]

I am 44 and have tried dozens of liners and hands down tarte smoldereyes are the creamiest and the wear is INCREDIBLE. I promise you they are the best.The colors are great and they have skinny pencils and chubby ones which are great for all over the lid.

[loveislife-sdfm]

I love your comparison videos!  Boy, you save me so much time trying to figure out what to use on my 50 plus skin.  Keep 'em coming

[youthdiscljm]

Thanks so much for the doing these product reviews, I love them and share them all the time!! I just bought the Sephora pencil yesterday and am really looking forward to using it. I put some on my hand and had to rub it really hard to make it move, that’s a good sign in my book! Thanks again Angie, you are fantastic!

[bethhelen]

Thanks Angie, I find I spend so much money just trying and then wasting what foes not seem to work. This helps tons! MUFE is definitely my next eyeliner.

[ElleIsForLiving]

As always, great video Angie.  I know how much work it is for you to insert shots of how it wore on each products so "thank you!".  I hope you have a fantastic weekend.  ♥ Elle

[suesheehan]

I've tried about every high end and drugstore brand eye liner pencils, and the only one that won't smudge or fade is from Bobbi Brown. I have oily skin, and I think that's the main issue, but her brand applied smoothly and lasted several hours. I have the "Noir" and will splurge again on a blue shade. Thank you for all of your reviews, Angie. They've helped me make good choices in makeup.

[junecollison]

Hi Angie, thankyou for testing the eyeliner pencils. I have yet to find one that stays on, and you have been extremely helpful. I now know which ones to try! .xx

[deniseferraccioli]

I favor pencils most of the time but just tried the It Cosmetics new gel liner and it is great, waterproof and didn't skip as I applied. This will be my new go-to liner for more of a defined line. I found it easy enough to apply that I think I will use this instead of my Mac pencil liner.

[hhjjhh]

For low-end pencils, you can't beat Rimmel's Scandal Eyes. For high end, I still love UD  w/o glitter, Tarte Smolder Eyes, and recently have enjoyed Clinique's Quick Liner in Intense Chocolate.  I only use liner under my lash line, my old eyes look even smaller with liner above the lash :) Often, I just bring down the shadow I'm using that day as liner too. Thanks for the reviews!