Understanding Lambda Functions and Closure in Python: Why Do They Return the Last Value?

Explore the intriguing behavior of `lambda` functions and `closures` in Python, particularly why they return the last value. Learn how to manipulate closures effectively in your own code!
---

Visit these links for original content and any more details, such as alternate solutions, latest updates/developments on topic, comments, revision history etc. For example, the original title of the Question was: python: about lambda and closure

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---
Understanding Lambda Functions and Closure in Python: Why Do They Return the Last Value?

When diving into the world of Python, you might run into the concepts of lambda functions and closures. These powerful features can often trip beginners up, leaving them puzzled about how they work. In this post, we will discuss a specific scenario involving these concepts to clarify why lambda functions behave the way they do, especially regarding variable scoping and closures. Our primary concern will be understanding why certain expressions in Python yield unexpected results.

The Initial Confusion

Consider the following code snippet:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

When you run this code, the result is [3, 3, 3]. At first glance, it seems strange—why does every function in the list return 3? Additionally, if you later execute:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

You still get [3, 3, 3]. So, you might ask, why do these functions not reflect the updated value of k? Let’s break this down to uncover the mystery behind these behaviors.

What Are Lambda Functions and Closures?

Lambda Functions

Lambda functions are small, anonymous functions defined with the lambda keyword.

They can take any number of arguments but return a single expression.

Closures

A closure is a function that captures the lexical scope in which it was declared. This means it retains access to the variables from the outer function’s scope, even if the outer function has finished running.

In the example provided, the lambda functions are created inside a list comprehension, and they all reference the variable k. But what does this mean in terms of scope?

Why Do They Return the Last Value?

The Closure Mechanism

Within the list comprehension, k is not just a number. It is treated as a variable that is scoped to the comprehension itself. Let's examine the sequence of events:

List Comprehension Execution: When the list comprehension executes, three lambda functions get created, all of which reference the variable k.

Variable Capture: These functions capture the variable k in their closure; however, they do not capture its value at the time of function creation. Instead, they store a reference to the variable itself.

Final Value: After the list comprehension completes, the last value assigned to k (which is 3) is what all three lambda functions will return when invoked.

Why Modifying k Doesn't Affect the Output

The line

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

attempts to change the variable k, but it only changes k in a different scope (the global scope). The lambda functions created earlier still refer to their own scope—meaning they continue to reference the original k from the list comprehension, which remains 3.

Adjusting the Behavior

If you want each lambda function to return the value of k at the time of creation, consider modifying the lambda function to take k as an argument:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

In this case, each lambda captures its own instance of k, resulting in the output [1, 2, 3]. This is a common pattern when working with closures in Python and ensures that each function retains the value of k as intended.

Conclusion

Understanding lambda functions and closures in Python is essential for writing effective code. They offer powerful ways to manage scope and variables but can also lead to confusion if not fully understood. Remember, closures capture variables, not their values. By grasping this concept, you can avoid common pitfalls and utilize Python’s features to their fullest potential.

If you enjoyed this explanation and want to explore more about Python features, stay tuned for our upcoming p