Who Was The Holiday Killer? | The Long Halloween Part Two

- For 59% OFF NordVPN + 3 extra months!!!
Who Was The Holiday Killer? scene in The Long Halloween Part Two

[mattinato]

- For 59% OFF NordVPN + 3 extra months!!!

[deadpoolrockz]

Compared to the change in the Hush movie, the change for the Long Halloween actually works. In Hush, by changing the identity of Hush to the Riddler, the intrigue given to Thomas Elliot was lost, while in the Long Halloween, changing Gilda's motivations gives more to her character compared just a woman who wanted to spend more time with a husband and start a family.

[Artisan]

What made this mystery work so brilliantly is that when you saw holiday and looked at the killer's eyes, you couldn't tell if it was male or female at times. That subtle trick made you wonder how much of this was done by Harvey and how much was done by Gilda. There were two holiday killers. I also like how they elevated her character to being a fully licensed attorney as opposed to just a wife that wanted to make her husband's life more easier with more time for starting a family. That made Gilda more of a force to be reckoned with and more of a competent mastermind. Someone who knew what she was doing.

[BitestheStuff]

You know the ending is extra sad when Batman lets the criminal go.

[joshuahermanson]

As a lifelong Batman fan, I must say stories like these are where Batman works best. The quiet intimacy of a moment like this speaks far more to who Batman is and the world he operates in than any Justice League or global crisis drama.

[RockLegendA]

Just watched the movie, and, while I take serious umbrage with how incompetent Batman is shown to be, this scene in particular is great. The realization that the baby bottle silencers are not only silencers, but her trademark - since Falcone killed her unborn baby and made her infertile - is damn chilling.

[ranadheerarakshith]

Moral of the story : remove a pebble the whole thing comes down .

[zubairhanif]

1:12 when Gilda said, she loved harvey but not completely it symbolizes the two face persona of Harvey. How his one half is intact because of love and the other is messed up. Such a great narrative.

[Godofawesome]

I like this version of the Long Halloween more than the comic. even the ending showing Batman figured out who the killer was and confronted her in the end. though, I feel bad for Alberto. didnt even want anything to do with his family and was forced away from her. and she kills him too despite he too was a victim of his father

[gorrow]

I like how so many of the mystery villains in these animated movies are tragic characters. Andrea. Jason. Gilda.

[FoxsDumbSeriesMaker]

I figured Gilda was the cause of the killings with how much they were focusing on her and how she was the personification of depression, but I'm not a fan of how Holiday on screen looked completely different from her. They cheated a little there, making Holiday look more like a man like Harvey Dent. They should have completely shaded the face or make the image blurry around Holiday instead of straight up drawing completely different eyes.

I originally assumed she hired an assassin to do the killings, still technically making her the killer, but they didn't say that. Not even a mask or wireframe was used for a disguise was implied, which is kind of ehh... A great reveal and twist. Just a little confusing and sloppy. I really liked these movies, though.

[roguelionproductions]

The Boys fans watching the pistol get thrown into the fire:

“NO, YOU IDIOT, YOU’LL BLOW IT UP-“

[jdjacobo]

I genuinely want to feel bad for Gilda. However, her actions led DIRECTLY to the creation of Two-Face, so I can't.

[IHunterk]

When the guy with the glasses told Selina that he couldn't get with the girl she wanted and terrible things happened to her, the most depressed person comes to mind. I couldn't figure out because why would she shoot him.

[deathstarstallion]

The animation for this new universe is really starting to grow on me

[CelicAWD]

I hope they keep Jensen on for this new continuity. Always liked him.

[bankansh]

Batman's 2 biggest regrets in his life, what he considers to be 2 of the biggest mistakes of his life:

1. Not being able to save Jason.
2. Not being able to save Harvey Dent.

[sriharsha_]

She has a role familiar to that of Andrea aka Phantasm. Instead of Andrea being strangled btw her Father and Bruce, Gilda was strangled with Alberto and Harvey. Phantasm kills everyone in mafia surrounding her father, Gilda kills people surrounding Alberto.

[jeffreytan]

Why Gilda did not tell Bruce Wayne, commissioner Gordon, and her husband Harvey dent that she was the holiday killer?

[Angyali]

Gilda has to be the most tragic female character from any DC animated film ever.
Her whole broken life was a never ending cursed cycle of misery and lone despair.