Stephen's A-List: The Top 5️⃣ QBs of ALL TIME 👀 | First Take

Stephen's A-List: The Top 5️⃣ QBs of ALL TIME 👀 | First Take
Stephen A. Smith breaks down his list of the top five NFL QBs of all time.
#ESPN #NFL #FirstTake

[theatricalityanddeception]

Mahomes has had arguably the best start to a career for a QB but it’s way too premature putting him in the top 5 all time. Gotta see how his entire career plays out first

[lavishtalks]

It's so disrespectful to the likes of Drew Brees & John Elway to have Patrick Mahomes (after only 5 years in the NFL) ahead of them

[justkhalil]

People don’t appreciate drew Bree’s as much because he didn’t have a defense most of his career and threw the ball to 0 hall of famers

[julianbernal]

Mahomes over Brees, Marino, Elway, Moon, Young and even the controversial Rothlisberger is beyond blasphemous.

[mattislinx]

Putting Mahomes #4 is so ridiculous at this point. It's crazy how much they have hyped this guy up. I think he's arguably the best QB in the league, and he'll have an amazing career, but it's way too early to put him in the top 5. Rodgers isn't in the top 5 either. He's probably 6-8. One championship is cool, but he's known for falling short in the biggest moments. I agree with 1-3 though.

[davepeterz]

Stephen A is living in the moment clearly.

[pedrodias]

Rodgers clearly did something to Molly. "Is this a regular season thing?" And then procedes to ask about Dan Marino who never won a chip. 😂😂😂

[iam-audio-kidcps]

1. Brady 2. Manning 3. Montana 4. Marino 5. Rodgers 6. Mahomes 7. Brees 8. Elway 9. Favre 10. Steve Young

[MandeepSingh-kive]

Isn't Stephen A the one always talking about "you gotta show me consistency for a long time, not just a few years"? And then he puts P. Mahomes in an all time great list 😂

[qmac]

Mahomes is probably on his way to being one of the best QBs of all time, but when you talk about all time, longevity has to matter, and Mahomes doesn't have that. I wouldn't have Mahomes as a top 10 QB of all time yet, because he has no longevity built up.

[henrywu]

Tom Brady has reached Superbowl the same number of times Montana, Manning, Mahomes and Rodgers combined.

[raymondgagne]

How is drew Brees not even mentioned in this segment?! Dude is criminally underrated

[justinpelletier]

It’s way too early to put Patrick Mahomes in the top 5 of all time right now

[Kenandgrat]

Brady, Montana, Peyton, Elway, Rodgers, Marino

[And_Guess_What]

Stephen A’s 1-3 spots are no-brainers, but his 4 & 5 spots are highly questionable. If he’s going off of not just superbowl wins alone, but complete resumes, I don’t know how he catapulted Rodgers & Mahomes over dudes like Brett Favre, Steve Young or Ben Roethlisberger, just to name a few

[JuiceMahoney]

Top 5 in my opinion:
1.Tom Brady
2.Peyton Manning
3. Joe Montana
4. Drew Brees
5. Dan Marino

[-.TS.-]

The moment they excluded Tebow and Jay Cutler this list lost all credibility for me in my humble opinion.

[PeanutButterAndJellyBros]

Top 5 QB of all time
1. Brady
2. Montana
3. Elway
4. Peyton
5. Marino

[TheJuiceAlert]

Putting Patrick Mahomes 4th all time causes this list to have ZERO credibility

[SuperPackerBOY]

Statistically, Rodgers is the goat. You can talk all you want, but Rodgers has all the records that prove he's the goat, highest passer rating of all time, lowest interception rate, Best TD to INT ratio. All of that while throwing in Green bay. I'm obviously a fan, but stats don't lie. If we're looking at entire body of work, then its Brady, Manning, Montana, Rodgers (4x MVP), Favre (3x MVP)