Who wins the Cars.com 3-Row SUV Challenge? | MotorWeek Comparison Test

If you’re in the market for a 3-row family SUV, you’ve probably realized by now that the number of good choices is almost overwhelming. Well, we’re here to help, with a look at 7 of the best-selling big crossover utes. So off we go to find out which one offers the best value for today’s families.

[Mgoblagulkablong]

Nice test. My only complaint: Mazda CX-9 is missing. I know it wouldn't have won because of less space, but otherwise it's a good model.

[andybub]

The Telluride is the best in the segment. Provides a value like no other!

[swanblake]

Kia Telluride and Hyundai Palisade are game changers. Easily better than all the competition and even the XT6. Very impressive. Just gorgeous inside and out

[farmallD]

The Honda Pilot should have one 1st. It is so much more reliable then any of the other vehicles. What is the point of buying an expensive 3 row if it doesn't last?

[cmac]

Highlander isn't on here because it's the #1 selling.

[sw]

HOW THE 3rd ROW OF THESE CARS COMPARE TO EACH OTHER?!? WHICH CARA HAVE 2nd ROW THAT CAN MOVE W/ CAR SEAR INSTALLED?!?
Astounding how nearly NONE of these reviews provide the info that really matters for the families looking to buy them… 🙄🙄🙄

[parsley]

Toyota just had their press launch event for the 2020 Highlander. I don’t think they wanted the 2019 to be in the comparison as it’ll soon be old news. Why waste the time when the new model will be out late next month? Makes total sense to omit having it in the comparison.

[bvsuber]

These reviews are too gadget oriented. All these vehicles can be purchased, nicely equipped for less than 40, 000.00. Personally, I prefer handling. performance and safety over gadgets. More expensive to fix when it breaks.

[jaydibernardo]

Hyundai & Kia have come a long way. That's awesome as competition is great for us consumers.

[mushroom]

2:32 Wait, the engine is transverse in the Explorer?!?

[DMETS]

They bought a $54, 000 4 cylinder Ford Explorer and then complained how high the price was. I just bought an Explorer XLT, same power and drivetrain, well equipped for under 38K.

[seagrass]

I agree to agree, great comparo:) The Hyundai and Kia really are super nice, they all are. Lets see how the competition reacts.

[TJBellamy]

Not really a fan of Toyota, but the fact that the Toyota Highlander was excluded made this review pointless to me...it is literally one of the best selling vehicles!!

[SSDracerSD]

Now base model comparison. Kia/Hyundai still win hehe

[kennethwalton]

I purchased my Palisade Limited in June, 2021, and I’m enjoying it. I upgraded my tires to the Michelin CrossClimate 2’s and they have truly improved the handling in all conditions, making it an even better purchase.

[tungol]

My top 4, 4th Subaru Ascent, 3rd Honda Pilot, 2nd Hyundai Pallisade, 1st Kia Telluride

[amelsfr]

why no mazda cx-9 ? it would have been very interesting

[gzyang]

No highlander? That's the real winner.

[matthewbowen]

Oof. That Exploder costs $7k more than the Palisade?! The Hyundai looks and feels like a $70k vehicle for $40s and the Explorer looks and feels like a product from 2010 for insane prices. Ford either phoned it in or is suffering from 1980s-level hubris.

[NissanAltimaGuy]

The traverse is better than them all...Just needs better infotainment screen, as well as instrument panel cluster.