Understanding Why minBy() Returns Optional in Java Streams

Explore the differences between Java Stream methods `minBy()`, `summingInt()`, and `averagingInt()`, and understand why `minBy()` returns an `Optional` while the others do not.
---

Visit these links for original content and any more details, such as alternate solutions, latest updates/developments on topic, comments, revision history etc. For example, the original title of the Question was: why does the minBy() returns Optional but others dont?

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---
Why Does minBy() Return Optional in Java Streams?

In the world of Java Streams, developers often encounter various methods built into the Stream API for data operations. One common area of confusion is the behavior of the minBy() method compared to other methods such as summingInt() or averagingInt(). This guide aims to clarify the reasons behind this difference in return types and help you understand when and why an Optional is necessary.

What is minBy() and Why Does it Return Optional?

The minBy() method is part of the Collectors utility class that allows you to retrieve the minimum element from a stream based on a provided comparator. However, if you attempt to call this method on an empty stream, there's no legitimate value to provide.

Key Point: Logically, there cannot be a minimum or maximum value if there are no elements in the collection.

Return Type: Therefore, minBy() must return an Optional. An Optional is a container object which may or may not contain a value. When it doesn't, it can represent the absence of a value clearly and safely.

What About summingInt() and averagingInt()?

On the other hand, methods like summingInt() and averagingInt() do not return an Optional. Instead, these methods return a primitive value (int for summation and double for averaging), which can be zero in the case of an empty stream.

Sum of Elements: When summing numbers, if the collection is empty, the sum is defined to be zero. Think of it this way:

If I have no apples and combine that with an empty bag of apples, how many apples do I have? Zero.

Average of Elements: Similarly, with averages, if you have several empty bags:

If you average the count of apples per bag, the result will simply be zero.

Different Perspectives

It’s important to note that while the standard behavior is as outlined above, some might argue about this treatment based on specific contexts or mathematical views.

Business Perspective: In a typical business environment, it is often expected that sums and averages of empty datasets yield zero. Most people interpret zero as “nothing,” making it a sensible return value.

Javadoc Reference: Notably, Java provides explicit documentation stating: “If no elements are present, the result is 0.” This means that if your application relies on these methods, you can expect a consistent and logical behavior from them.

Conclusion

The behavior of Java's Stream methods is not arbitrary. The decision to have minBy() return an Optional while summingInt() and averagingInt() return zero aligns with logical reasoning about the data being processed.

If the behavior of these methods does not meet your expectations in a particular context, consider adapting your approach. You can either modify how you use these methods or implement your own custom logic to handle edge cases.

Takeaway: It’s essential to understand the return types and behaviors of various Java Stream methods. The clarity on these distinctions not only helps in writing efficient code but also in creating a more robust Java application.