The Best Pepperoni Pizza In NYC | Best In Town | Food Insider

Best in Town (formerly known as Best of the Best) is BACK for a limited-run season 3. In this episode, Herrine Ro and Erin Kommor search New York City to find the best pepperoni pizza. They visit Prince Street Pizza to try the Spicy Spring, Rubirosa to eat the Tie Dye Roni Pie, and Emily to try two different versions of their pepperoni pizza, The Colony. In the end, they declare which place is the best in town.

Editor’s Note: Insider visited these restaurants in December 2019. The restaurants are all currently closed to dine-in service due to the ongoing pandemic, but have various takeout and delivery options.

Additionally, the owners of Prince Street Pizza have stepped down from the restaurant's day-to-day operations after offensive and racist social media interactions were uncovered.

For more information, visit:
Prince St. Pizza:
Rubirosa:
Emily:

MORE BEST IN TOWN:
The Best Fast-Food Fried Chicken Sandwich | Best Of The Best
The Best Po’boy In New Orleans | Best Of The Best
The Best Hot Chocolate In London | Best Of The Best

------------------------------------------------------

#Pizza #NYC #FoodInsider

Insider is great journalism about what passionate people actually want to know. That’s everything from news to food, celebrity to science, politics to sports and all the rest. It’s smart. It’s fearless. It’s fun. We push the boundaries of digital storytelling. Our mission is to inform and inspire.

The Best Pepperoni Pizza In NYC | Best In Town | Food Insider

[UncleRico]

I love how 3/4 of the comments are just telling them not to call it “peps” or “roni”

[Zlurpa]

"it has been a difficult journey"
You just had to eat pizza and tell which one you liked more

[noho_hank]

"we had a hard time finding a place to shoot so Dominic hooked us up with a spot in the basement" sounds like the beginning of a murder mystery.

[SupremeLeaderKimJong-un]

The best pepperoni pizza is in Pyongyang, where else would it be

[weisd]

the chemistry between them is like mixing Beef with Vanilla Ice cream

[apollstar]

The owner of Prince Street Pizza is really cool. You can tell he has a lot of passion and cares about what his customers think and want.

[tristan]

The blonde girl sounded like my sister trying to make a fake food review in our kitchen.

[appal]

As soon as I heard “peps” it instantly killed the vibe.

[nattobaby]

i never knew hearing people call pepperoni "peps" or "roni" would trigger me so much. i hate it

[erickavila]

Tell me I’m not the only one find it annoying when they say peps instead of pepperoni

[kazijannatara]

Who else already knew the pizza with pepperoni doused would be the best.

[DM-pmyd]

I thought about this for a while now and I don’t like pepperonis to be referred to as “peps” or “ronis”

[docstanley]

I love the Robert de Niro reference and explanation on how all their pizza's have the same amount of pepperoni

[hv]

White girl: it looks spicy...I feel overwhelmed with all these toppings

Asian girl: let’s just eat it

[Plutoniumcontrolrod]

Please just say pepperoni, it’s not hard. You don’t have to say “peps” or “roni”

[Frassic]

Being from Italy, prince's pizza looks amazing!

[dvoob]

incredible. they went to all three pizza restaurants in NYC. Insane that they made it to every one of them!

[squidMB]

Whoever says “peps” or “roni” doesn’t deserve to step foot in New York again

[noho_hank]

"and the grease pools in the middle like a warm little hot tub that you just want to swim in"
"No."
"Okay cool"
😬🤣

[coolhandluke]

“Don’t do drugs kids” is the vibe of this video