Who Makes 'Elite QB' Status According to NFL Network's Gerald McCoy?

Showcasing insightful sports expertise with an offbeat mix of humor and pop culture, The Rich Eisen Show attracts the most recognizable names in sports and entertainment.

FOLLOW US HERE:

#richeisenshow #nfl #patrickmahomes

[bucsfan]

I'm still not over losing Gerald. Much love!

[_The_Journey]

He was spot on about everyone 💯 expect Purdy deserves more respect fs, he’s proven to be a better quarterback then Dak, Kirk and arguably Tua based off of film and numbers alone, especially when you bring in clutch factor which Purdy has proven time and time again he has

[Yellow_Flannel]

I don’t agree fully but his concept is consistent and that is worth hearing him out.

[randy]

The reason for herbert should apply to Lamar, we havent seen lamar be elite in the playoffs.

[chrism]

I haven't seem Lamar do it more than once. Hes on a milk carton by January every year

[TJAvant]

2 time MVP, and he said “why?” 😂😂 hating for no reason 😂

[charleslathrop]

Herbert playing better than the elite Burrow

[piercegormley]

“What has he done in the playoffs?….Yeah Lamar is elite”

[floresgt]

Purdy year two with all those stats to back it up. Uhhh

[irishroc]

Elite Montana, Elway, Brady, P.Manning, And My 2 Favorites of All Time Randall Cunningham, Big Ben Roethlisberger

[joeywestfall]

Discredited immediately with Lamar being elite 😂😂😂

[Burkhardt_]

“Is Dak elite”

“No, we question how much Dak turns the ball over”

IN THE VERY NEXT SENTENCE

“But you consider Josh Allen to be elite right”

“Yes”

ALLEN TURNS THE BALL OVER MORE THEN DAK, I MEAN WHAT ARE WE EVEN TALKING ABOUT HERE

[catf]

Any person who has Lamar as elite immediately loses all my attention. The kids fun to watch but he will never win in the playoffs. Period.

[bsgoat]

Gerald seems like such a bright football mind

[TheRealDarthVadar]

Best thing Tampa did was replace Gerald with Suh Tampa needed a enforcer on the D line not a nice guy who helps up opponents after they tackle them 😂

[guyinthecomments]

Bro moves the goalpost constantly on what it takes to be "elite"

[gomasonpatriot]

Elite is 2 guys (won superbowl AND MVP). Elite active qbs:
Mahomes, Rodgers
That's it. If you think someone is better then they would go in and bump the guy he is replacing down to very good

The very good list is like 4 deep (MVP or substantial statistical AND playoff success).
Hurts, Allen, Lamar, Burrow

Above avg is 10 deep (statistical success and regular season success)
Herbert, Trevor, Purdy, and a ton of others

That's exactly 16 players. Mathematically, everyone else would be below avg.

[JoshSlinkard]

Every year? He had one season with a lot of INT

[bengaltiger]

Burrow? Lamar? Uh, no. And I like Lamar, and I understand he's been hurt. Elite should be a VERY small group. He's right about Purdy - if Purdy proves himself over the next few years, then yeah, but let's not break out the anointing oil out just yet.

[itskelvinn]

Lamar Jackson scoring 10 points today = elite

Brock purdy scoring 30+ points in every game = not elite