We Convinced Her This Was Real w/ Spencer Agnew | Smosh Mouth 20

Shayne and Spencer prank Amanda, talk about video games, and do Chosen things.

0:00-0:42 Intro
0:43-16:17 Real gamers only
16:18-30:20 Addictive games
30:21-31:47 Sponsors!
31:48-32:11 Prank explanation
32:12-39:29 FNAF prank
39:30-47:31 Game education
47:32-49:44 The Chosens appear
49:45-54:59 Were you judgemental when you were younger?
55:00-1:03:25 Games video ideas
1:03:26-1:08:39 FNAF reveal

AUDIO VERSIONS:

WHO YOU SEE

NEW SMOSH VIDEOS:

OTHER SMOSHES:

FOLLOW US:

[GameTheory]

Thank you guys for supporting my true crime series on The Mysterious Case of Freddy Fazbears Pizza

[barrettdowell]

I can't believe shayne managed to drop "its all just a theory" with a straight face

[TheHolderOfTheStory]

I don’t know how Shayne and Spencer kept a straight face during the FNAF part. As soon as Spencer said “Mathew Patrick” and Shayne said “its just a theory” I lost it

[OGEdger]

I love Matthew Patrick's sign off at the end of every episode: "But that's just a crime--a TRUE crime. Thanks for watching."

[saulitix]

I almost died when Shayne said "that's just a theory". I don't know how in the world they didn't laugh

[thatonespoon_]

"HIS NAME IS MATTHEW PATRICK"
the poker faces are next level

[monkebrainiac]

amanda being chronically offline is one of the best things in smosh

[RlVlN]

Matthew Patrick is my favorite true crime channel on YouTube. It always amazes me how he’s able solve cold cases with his theories.

[malkam.]

Please do another episode where you present real plotlines from games and fake ones and have Amanda try to tell whats real

[tylerlzr]

You could see how hard Shayne had to steel his resolve when he said “it’s just a theory” HE COULDNT MAKE EYE CONTACT

[amiritiichia]

The level of self control from Spencer and Shayne on this episode is absolutely unreal. I legit screamed when Spencer dropped "Matthew Patrick", and I have absolutely no idea how Shayne did not lose his shit after sliding in the "its just a theory line." These kids are wild, pranking Mom like that

[Overlordofthelollipopguild]

Shayne and Spencer deserve an Oscar for delivering the FNAF prank completely seriously without corpsing. Bravo boys!

[kathrynguy]

Calling MatPat a true crime youtuber was the best part of this podcast 😂

[emory]

The FNAF prank has the same energy as Shayne convincing Courtney and Olivia that the Care Bears killed people

[monstrousmind]

I just LOST it when Amanda said “You know I’m gonna search up the bite of ‘83” 😭😭😭😭

[sorenallen]

“There’s this guy, his name’s Matthew Patrick. He’s a true crime YouTuber”

I laughed out loud and almost woke up my wife.

[sir-dame-sander]

major props to spencer, I would’ve cracked at that “it’s just a theory”. shane slipped that line in so casually, it really caught me off guard lmao

[fernandajordan]

How did spencer and shayne keep a straight face when telling Amanda about FNAF 😂

[livdawg]

idk why but during the entire FNAF bit, I kept replaying Markiplier saying, "Was that the bite of '87?!?" over and over in my head 😂

[stevenboelke]

The fact that they were able to pull off "Matthew Patrick" and "it's all just a theory" with a straight face is great.