Top 5 Greatest “Goats” in Survivor

"The Greatest of Allllll Tiiiiime!!!" Until they lost.

If you'd like to support me, check out these links:

SUBSCRIBE FOR ALL THE SURVIVOR GOODNESS! :D

[Peridiam]

Guys, PLEASE READ:
GOAT = an acronym for “Greatest Of All Time”
Goat = not an acronym, but instead a player who very likely won’t win

Write this 100 times tonight for homework and I’ll see you in the morning.

[Cometstarlight]

Whenever Phillip gets brought up, I always laugh when I remember the first time I realized they put a question mark at the end of "Former Federal Agent". Shows that even the people working on Survivor had their doubts.

[lorivaughn-gvfo]

My top 5 would be close to this but not exactly the same.

1.Natalie T- moved up
2. Phillip
3. Troyzan
4. Sugar
5. Russell Heroes vs Villians- moved down

[strategicgameplayer]

Jeff can I vote for none of the above?

[itsjoesantos]

I would've included Will from World's Apart, the classic "Dead Fish"

[aaronw]

Troyzan from game changers is one of the biggest imo as well. Especially considering no one on the jury wanted to ask him any questions and he even acknowledged at FTC that he wasn't going to win. Also called it with Sugar being on the list. ;)

[spencerclark]

My controversial Gabon hot take is that Sugar (entirely by accident and without realizing it whatsoever) played the best game of the season - and if she wasn't such an unstable force and so terrible at FTC, she probably could've come in second or maybe even first. But her lack of awareness of how well she (again, accidentally) played as well as her emotions and rudeness definitely tanked it for her.

I actually think Phillip played decently in Caramoan! He did more by coming in tenth place than John did, and John won unanimously because all three of the final three that season were goats just John was more likeable than the other two.

[JSDSandiego]

I have a lot of respect for Sugar and her gameplay. I think she stood up to Randy and Corinne, even though it cost her votes. She played with her heart and often called the shots.

[feeney]

I agree Phillip is the Greatest Of All Time

[brycerichardson]

Sugar; "I don't think you necessarily have to vote for me"
Some people; "I think she was trying to win"
uhhh

[lerdog]

I think "biggest goats" would be a better title. I was under the impression the list was gonna be about the goats who played the greatest games etc. Awesome list regardless, I love you channel \o

[shinyhydreigon]

8:02 Ruffle, ruffle feathers. You said rustle feathers.

[officialsurvivorfan]

Matt in Amazon, Twila in Vanuatu, Katie in Palau, Becky in CI, Cassandra and Dreamz in Fiji, Sherri in Caramoan, Gervase in BvW, Will in WA

[jennifersmith]

Russell Hantz played the same type of game in Samoa which is the reason he didn't win. He has horrible jury management skills. These were on much fuller display on H v. V but it was essentially the same game. All Russell had to do was show some humility and respect for the other players and he might've won.

[quiddity]

Good video. I think your top 3 perfectly encapsulates the 3 ultimate goat games; be the rudest, most annoying person possible (Phillip), go scorched earth, grinding people underneath your foot as you vote them out (Russell) and be the biggest do-nothing imaginable who can make no decisions of her own (Natalie). They'd be my top 3 as well.

[jackspiegel]

I love that the top three were all in Redemption Island

[noelmelnick]

I think that will from red collar vs white collar vs blue collar

[masonlopez]

Too bad kass doesn’t count for this video because I was waiting for that “ the next goat, or should I say llama, ”

[dianeross]

Peridiam, you underrank Natalie T. She is clearly the #1 goat, not #3. Philip atleast got a vote and the cast say maybe he beats Rob if he had said it was all an act to get to the end as his brilliant plan at FTC. Not likely he does that but still a chance. Russell probably beats Danielle and Candice, or maybe if he doesn't betray Danielle which is the top thing that really made the jury hate him, he even has a shot vs Danielle and Parvati since a lot of the jury hated or had personal grudges with Parvati. There is no way those 2 are biggest goats than Natalie T.

[ngelgotchi]

you putting Russell at second again is SENDING me