Total Drama All Stars: Most Fair To Unfair Eliminations

Check my animation made with #FlipaClip

[ezekiel]

I agree with Lightning being the most fair elimination, because he's so annoying in both Revenge of the Island and All Stars

[MadMan-xwwp]

alejandro was actully a good person in all stars, he tried to save cameron, stood up to his brother, and tried to warn people about mal

[Frockst]

If Fresh Tv didn’t take away Heather’s brain maybe she could’ve been a better character

[Mthefoxx]

I don't remember pretty much anything that happened in season 4+5, mostly because I didn't really like them. But I can recite over half of 1, 2, and 3 because I loved them

[miav]

I totally agree that Courtney had the most unfair elimination. I mean I pretty sure I recall her being lactose intolerant. And also Gwen was stupid in that episode because why who you want to befriend Courtney if she was planning the get you kicked off? Idk I feel like Courtney should’ve made it to the finally cause the Mike and Zoey finally was so expecting (I didn’t hate them in TDROTI but in All stars I did) and because Courtney always comes so close to the finally and then just gets booted off..

[Disneylover]

Chris is a Narcissistic egomaniac who loves himself so when he so himself in art form destroyed he basically got all pissy and kicked Gwen off

[CrystalClearWithBE]

Correction:
12: fair *SHA WHAT!?!*
11: fair
10: fair like an ejection due to injuries like in Survivor
9: unfair (I guess) just because he destroyed Chris's mansion I mean cottage
8: unfair and why can't the heroes vote but instead the villains eliminate a hero of choice?
7: fair because of cheating
6: fair and why did you hide the Immunity Idol? Alejandro took it and used it and Heather have the next highest number of votes
5: *most unfair (fans: Actually it's fair.)* because she doesn't belong to All Stars without a reason
4: unfair
3: unfair
2: unfair with an art reference
1: _unfair and cursed_ Courtney isn't friends with Gwen anymore and I'm glad Scott broke up with Courtney all because of that chart and why is there a bonus challenge (eat your own sundae) and why can't Chris feed his interns?

[warriorofdramaclan]

*sees number 1* OH MY GOD

Ed McDonald is SO gonna be dead meat when I come around! (too far?)

[pizza]

Most fair to unfair elimination All Stars :
14.Lightning-he cost his team the challenge
13.Duncan-he committed a crime, fair enough.
12.Jo- I never liked Jo, but she made it furthest for her team.
11.Lindsay-she didn't know how to drive.
10.Cameron-he couldn't win after he won in Season 4(for most people).
9.Sam-was caught cheating(but very little).
8.Sierra-It kind of makes sense, her teammates were probably freaked out because she imagined them as Cody(especially Cameron).
7.Scott-He would have been eliminated anyways unless he wins the challenge and eliminates Mike/Mal.
6.Gwen-She got a painting and Mike/Mal and Scott didn't and she got eliminated, just for making Chris barf.
5.Zoey(Mike's Ending)-Zoey was complimenting Chef for enough time for Mike to get the sword.
4.Mike(Zoey's Ending)-Mike's was higher because Chef shot him down when he was talking.
3.Courtney-She's my least favorite character on the show, but this was partially unfair because this was a heartbroken and most cursed episode in the season for the three(Courtney, Gwen, and Scott).
2.Alejandro-He wasn't a threat in this season unlike in Season 3, and the others would not heed his warning that he gave about Mike/Mal.
1.Heather-This was the MOST unfair elimination in this season, where Heather was the least mean in this season. Alejandro stole her idol, I blame her a bit because she hid it in a terrible spot.

[juniorsmalls]

Actually, If The Heroes Would've Been Able To Vote In Episode 7, They Would've Voted Mal

[RainbowDjDash]

I think the final should had been Courtney vs zoey

[MarcoSuperNova]

My personal thoughts & opinions about these TDAS fair to unfair eliminations due to bad writting wise:
12: Fair
11: Fair
10: Fair
9: Mixed feelings (Fair since he commited a crime)
8: Mixed feelings (Unfair, but no via voting)
7: Unfair
6: Unfair (same as #5)
5: Unfair (bad writting)
4: Fair (he was voted out fair and square)
3: Unfair
2: Unfair
1: Totally Unfair: Fuck Ed MacDonald (3 words)

[kammitp]

The finale we got SUCKED, and courtney probably woulda made it if ed macdonald KNEW about chinese fake out, it should've been courtney vs scott

[averytheebaddie]

I so agree with you on the courtney elimination like she literally said she wanted her and scott to be the final 2, but scott got offended bcuz she drew a tail 😟 like

[RainbowDjDash]

Why did duncan had to commit a crime I was so mad when he got arassred

[bfdixiifan]

12: Fair
11: Fair
10: Fair(injured)
9: Unfair
8: Fair
7: Unfair
6: Fair
5: Unfair
4: Unfair
3: Unfair
2: Unfair
1: Unfair

[ethanalgicosathlonchannel]

Sierras was way too low. She was eliminated by the winners instead of being voted off by her team(kinda like Mike in ROTI) but it’s more unfair because it was announced after the challenge was over.

[overlyfixated]

Honestly would've liked a Duncan and Zoey final would've been cool

[bfdixiifan]

My Opinion:
12: Lightning
11: Jo
10: Alejandro
9: Sierra
8: Heather
7: Lindsay
6: Cameron
5: Gwen
4: Scott
3: Sam
1: Duncan/Courtney

[mnkash]

honestly i find duncan a 7 -- 5
he just complained about being good more then actually trying to win same with gwen but she kinda got over being evil and complained more about her and courtney
duncan helped DJ find a new bunny in TDI
he actually manged a sort of freindship with harold in TDA which was ruined by owen...
in TDWT i now he was just hated for cheating on courtney but as sierra says "LOVE IS LOVE"
and the fact that he did the crime on the merge and not during the time he was on the heros team i mean come on its the merge teams dont even matter