Barstool Pizza Review - Nonna's Pizza & Sandwiches (Chicago, IL)

After trying Nonna's delivery last week, Dave stopped by the pizzeria to try the real thing but was befuddled when it was not the same pizza.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[rufioswitch]

Dave often doesn’t know what city he’s in, what state, how to pronounce the name of the restaurant, what corner streets the place is on… but he knows this isn’t the pizza they had last time.

[Headlikeanorange]

Dave has this hilarious ability to become more confused with every question he asks.

[YusefulChronicles]

Exciting. The channel has shifted from Comedy to a Mystery Thriller now

[californian]

How could he not at least do a side review on that Sicilian!?! Looked good

[paulnash]

The guy describing the basil as green leaves! 😂

[dgrock]

Dave doesn't know what year it is, everyone knows the rules

[anotherrabbithole]

Pizzerias around the country changing their pizza recipe the moment Dave walks in.... you know what that means!

[Unsolicited-Info]

Prez went inside and left the extra pizza outside 😂

[IzzoSkizzy]

I wonder if Dave knows there are multiple Nonna's in Chicago. I wonder the one he had in the office was on the Southside (Nonna's Good Life)

[ronyeahright]

Steve pondering the differences between a cheese pizza and a margherita pizza like a nobel physicist contemplates the expanding universe.

[lemongavine]

I mean, Dave is always confused, but this was next-level and it was great

[szymonbrzozowski]

Basil on pizza makes it artisan, everybody knows the rules

[donnierion]

I'm so glad that Dave is calling out the pricing. As a Chicago native, the pizza pricing is out of control these last few years. $50 for a margherita pizza and a small sicilian with no toppings. It used to just be the pizza places in the west loop/river north up-charging because "west loop/river north = posh" now, but recently everyone is doing it and it's ridiculous. It's mediocre pizza and it's not worth these asinine prices. Ironically, the best deal is on the deep dish now, because although it's a $25-30 pie, it will easily feed 4+ people. When I was in NYC last year I ordered some of the best pizza I've ever had at half the price. Serving NYC style pizza in Chicago doesn't give you a carte blanche to double prices.

[apierrakeas]

This is legitimately the scariest thing I've ever witnessed, and the most scared I've ever been. To purchase a pizza and it not be the same as last time is heartwrenching, immoral, and unjust.

[nnnickkk]

We need to start a drinking game. Every time Prez tries to guess an address and/or when he pronounces the name of the restaurant wrong. One shot, everyone drools.

[TheWrightVibes]

He should order the cheese pizza off the kids’ menu, everybody rules the know.

[aliwantizu]

Interesting in that it was in the box for quite some time, and yet was not floppy. Looked really good, 7.3 seems low!

[jaykay]

This is the "Stonehenge" of pizza mysteries!

[LUGNUTHOSS]

This truly is one of the greatest pizza mysteries in my existence. Please keep us abreast on any new developments.

[BrandonthGen]

Dave is right, if you look at the places photos on Google you can see they make a normal cheese pizza.