How does TDS always win? (Roblox)

Thank you for watching! Please consider subscribing & leaving a like on the video if you enjoyed it :)

----LINKS----

Discord Server:

Twitter/X:

BUY THE OFFICIAL ROBLOX 5OULS SHOULDER BUDDY!!

🏷️tower defense, tower defense simulator, tds, roblox, tds update

[NotOofLegacy]

I mean no offense to you, but i feel like you said a bunch of words without actually addressing what appears to be the core thesis of your video based on the title (That being TDX being a "failure") The reality is that success is always dependent on the mindset you have. Tdx doesn't have the player count that TDS has, but that doesn't mean it's a failure, when it still has an active community and videos on it still get thousands of views. It's player count is no different from Tower blitz's which also wasn't a failure in its prime. I dislike your points about ttd, because by that logic TDS is a complete failure eclipsed by 10x when comparing player counts, when this is definitely not the case.

Tdx isn't a failure because John hasn't given up on it. That's just how it is. The reason why TDS has more players is just common sense lol, its a simple, easy to get into game that updates weekly and is high quality. Tdx appeals to an older audience of Tower Battles Veterans, and his own fanbase. It may not be bringing in the numbers you would consider successful, but i would say it's doing just fine for itself, just like how tds is perfectly fine despite having less players than the toilet or anime games.

[Squidboi]

Hating on TTD is the one thing TDS and TDX players can agree on

[RonElias-rdqz]

The bigger reason is that it's because many players already got 10s of hours of gameplay on TDS and wouldn't want to grind new TD games, in short; the game won't die unless they release really shitty updates or no updates at all

[juiceboxbs]

It's simple, tds had an insane headstart compared to tdx

But it's also due to tds reling more on a constant player flow, while tdx relies on keeping its initial player base active, hence the difference in traction

Tds is more well-done in terms of a roblox game, while tdx is more well done in terms of a game in general, both are good, just below knows how to get his numbers big

[laisksjjsjs]

I'll state the actual reason. The reason why tds wins is because of Roblox itself. Tds won the best trailer that carried it, and it was in all classic, hunt, and haunt events. If tds weren't so popular, it would have been surprising.

[CantFindGudUsername]

3:47 tdx is not getting "discontinued, shut down"... its only really been around one year since release and the team will continue to make updates. i hope tdx stays successful and i hope we get tds and tdx collab event sometime..

[PenumbrasTheGatekeeper]

Youtubers trying not to say tdx died (impossible challenge):

[PressurePlayerfr]

Honestly TTD is the worst TD game

Edit:its my opinion bruh

[KobraArab]

It's not even fair to compare a game that had lived for 5 years to a game that's still in beta

[RedNinjaKoopa-ut]

TDX isn’t dead or dying. John
Roblox was a very popular tds YouTuber and generated a lot of hype for his own tower defense game so it makes sense that the player count would dive, or rather, stabilize over the first month. It’s been at a nice 2-3k players for months now.

[Finnn]

Yall are forgetting that 80% of TDX community is from TDS since John announced the development of TDX while playing TDS.

[Atmxx]

There was this one tower defense game, that’s now dead called Universal Guardians. Pre overhaul update it was really unique as you placed towers on the path and enemies could attack them, making it feel more like plants vs zombies. Then they overhauled the game and completely changed it, from its original gameplay style to that of a generic td game. It’s sad it never reached a decent player count but the game itself had a lot of flaws that probably were factors in preventing it from securing a decent player base as the game is now dead.

[MadCat]

as a person who studies content creation, I can say that TDX is very pleasant to play, but there is little content, and TDS has more content, that's why it has more online, the whole trick is how to keep players, TTD noticed this feature, TDX just make the game with less the number of lags, which makes the game more enjoyable.

[ScribbleSoda-pk]

Its so funny how people are still debating this

How to be annoying as shit

A. Say a game is fighting another game even tho it isn’t

B. A
C. B

[A-Amused]

I don’t really care how valid some points may be, comparing minor tower defense games on a lego game is just.. unproductive. (Seriously, if you play TDX or TDS, in the grand scheme of things, it’s not relevant on the internet).

I feel like this video is incredibly biased to TDS no matter what, and the thumbnail is putting another game, TDX, to absolute shame, not to mention how he puts up a massive ‘TDX’ logo and mentions how other tower defense games are being “shut down or discontinued” which just implies that he thinks TDX is just completely dead.

This video feels more like ‘Why TDS is better than TDX’ and I think we’re tired of hearing it.

[NoNameReal]

TTD destroyed stuff about your average tower defense games, nearly every new tower defense game makes you gamble for your towers, all because of TTD.

[lucasgalizadasilva]

I don't even remember the last time I logged into TDX.

[Sighlar]

TDX is anything but a failure. Not being able to overtake a game that has had 5 years to develop itself, find its direction, and has one of the hardest working team on roblox, and has proved itself to be the most polished, high quality game on entire platform with a passion project that has only been out for a year is completely normal. John never expected to overtake tds, he wanted to make his own td game with his own direction and theme that he liked, as apparent by the heavy DOOM influence in his game. He loves working on the game, and not to mention TDX still has around 4.8k players on weekends, long after the newest update. TLDR: TDX isn’t a failure just because it can’t overtake the best in its genre

[Synchronocy]

Honestly not sure how to feel about this video but ill say this to two points

Tower blitz was NOT the first td game to have to paths, Im not entirely sure which game is but there's a much older game called "Mecha Cubes" that has two upgrade paths for each tower.

Also putting my hat here, I feel like a game losing players after some time from a major update is normal. Heck even TDS loses players after a lil bit, feels kinda unfair to only point that out for TDX.

Note I am biased to TDX, as it can actually run on my computer but i say this with my most respects (Even IF im biased)

[Ralse_]

“Nah, we’d win”
-Tds Halloween event night 1, 2024.