IVE’s New MV “HEYA” Criticized by Chinese netizens for “Stealing Chinese Culture”

IVE’s New MV “HEYA” Criticized by Chinese netizens for “Stealing Chinese Culture”
.
.
.
► SUBSCRIBE our channel
► Hit the LIKE button and ring the BELL to get informed of our new videos!
If any owners have an issue with any of the uploads, please get in contact and we will handle it immediately. Thank you for your cooperation!
.
#wonyoung #ive #yujin #jungkook #kimtaehyung #newjeans #danielle #jennie #blackpink #kpop #kpopnews #kpopnewsarticle #lisa #enhypen #aespa #gidle #exo #got7 #txt #twice #ive #wonyoung #bts #straykids #nmixx #jimin #exokai #nct127 #skz #fiftyfifty #cupid #aespa #karina #aespaningning #giselle #aespawinter #nct #nct127 #lucas #nctlucas #jennie #IU #babymonster #lesserafim #zerobaseon

[rachaelruan]

Everyone can tell this is Chinese culture

[Lainelainehere]

As a Malaysian, I can see why Chinese netizens are angry.

If people look back at traditional movies filmed before 2000, they can see super obvious differences between Korea, Japan, and China in terms of their traditional techniques, knots, styles and accessories.

Japanese is influenced by China but they made themselves unique in a way that Japanese and Chinese cultures are obviously different.

I saw many Chinese traditional culture is portrayed in anime and they are confident to say that it’s based on ancient China (like colour cloud palace). And the Chinese do not mind at all.

[lululue-tj]

This illustrator has studied in China. Her previous works were tag "chinese panting" "chinese ink" but now she has changed the tag.Theycompletely denied the facts.

[Haoareyousohandsome]

Y’all are forgetting the whole argument is because the Koreans claim these culture as their own, ofc it’s normal for transitional customs to lok. similar due to China and koreas geography and Chinas influence on East Asian cultures and there’s nothing wrong with including themes of it AS LONG AS YOU GIVE CREDIT. However no credit was given and people keep denying the fact that was was in the mv is Chinese culture

[Euphoria]

So South Korea suddenly have Karst Landforms 🥴🥴

[jasmineRafayel]

Because most of the elements in the MV, the Korean don’t have it . For example, the Karst Mountain Landform . It’s only Chinese culture! Secondary, Korean don’t admit that some of their culture were learned from China. After they learned, they blamed Chinese is the one who stole their culture. For example, a famous Chinese YouTuber Liziqi, made a video of making salty spicy vegetables. Then Korean blamed her and said she stole Korean Kimchi. But the truth is Chinese made spicy and salty vegetables since Qin Dynasty, it was from thousands years ago. At that time, ancient Korean dynasty wasn’t even exist.

If you don’t believe this K-pop group stole Chinese culture, go to search their new interview video. When the host asked about the group members some cultural questions. They don’t even know the names of the art patterns that were used in the video! If it was Korean culture, how come this K-pop group members have no idea about the names of the patterns??? It’s their song rights???

[noahdraper]

The fact that china left a historic mark on korea makes their argument pointless

[bBenzopyrrole]

Every person who was aknowledged themselves with some traditional chinese culture would have realised that this is mostly Chinese culture. I was at the beginning happy to se a kpop group who is promoting culture from other countries but every changed since Starship said that all the characteristics are from Korea, tbh do think this is kinda serious and indeed is cultural appropriation, or worse, stealing culture (because they dont like their own culture or whatever). Its very funny when they consider a Chinese knot "korean".

[lululue-tj]

This illustrator has studied in China. Her previous works were tag "chinese panting" "chinese ink" but now she has changed the tag.They completely denied the facts.😂

[xiaoxiao]

Korean in the old times have always just used Chinese culture due to the great influence of ancient China. However they are so used to changing the name of Chinese culture that they took from China to Korean names. Like Chinese calendar, they directly took the calendar and used it with only changing the year name. The dates and maths are the same as Chinese calendar, now they call this Korean calendar and claim Korean invented it. Same as this MV, Koreans were like "Oh this fan shape of Chinese fan looks so cool, it is different from Korean fan but let's use the Chinese shape instead." The mountains, cloud shapes are all what they learned from ancient Chinese culture. Now they call this Korean beauty. What a shame for Korean.

[foreverblink]

It’s Chinese culture, the MV uses Chinese knots, auspicious clouds, ink art, Chinese style clothing, Chinese myths and many more. (More Chinese elements are used in the Mv than Korean ones) Many elements used in the MV only existed in China, NEVER in Korea. There are in fact many big differences between Chinese and Korean cultures, this MV blurred it all. When more and more people do that, it’s literally cultural appropriation.

[monyetcerdik]

better explain we promote traditional East Asia to the Western fans everyone is happy no war

[lilyis]

And there is someone who start it. I think Korean are copycat in a lot of things … why did he said korean elements that are unknown… unfamiliar like even Korean themselves cannot attest

[Krakk-hjre]

But it is korean folklore what they are showing in the mv, tigers and magic flutes are a part of their stories, also Korea was flooded with tigers until last century when japanese exterminated all of them

[KANA]

We are angry not because we do not accept Chinese cultural elements in the MV, but because Starship does not admit that there is Chinese culture in the MV. This is cultural appropriation because some elements in the MV are obviously not Korean but Chinese😡

[najyannna]

There is an organization called VANK in South Korea, which specializes in cultural appropriation.

[ninesunstars]

Thanks to ive and Starship for helping China promote traditional Chinese art culture, I didn't realize that the whole MV is full of Chinese culture at a glance, which pays homage to Chinese art movies such as Huluwa and other landscapes and auspicious clouds are more outstanding!

[btsismyoxyjin]

Did any member or starship claim or starship claim it as korean?? I'm genuinely asking because if they didn't claim then I don't think Chinese should be upset because I thought it was obvious that the mv had lots of Chinese culture influence. I'm not Chinese but everything gave so much chinese vibe I thought it was obvious.

[Chifuyaaaa]

The problem here is chinese and korean people hate each other ... they have political history for tht ... and koreans always criticize chinese idols for no reason and this time it's like chinese getting revenge cos if u are promoting korean culture u have to say tht clearly ...it may be not problem for us but not for them

[RUITANG-cybx]

In ancient Korea, China was a subsidiary country. At that time, the dependent country was only called to China to attend the funeral when there was a national-level funeral. Chinese funeral was marked by white and wreath. The ancestors of Koreans used white when they thought it was a major festival, so they now hold activities to send wreaths and white decorations representing funerals in China. Even the national flag of South Korea is also a gossip map of China. It was originally a good omen. They did not understand feng shui to remove the four hexagrams and turned the national flag into fierce gossip. This has always been very funny for Chinese people. Recently, many ancient costume dramas in South Korea will plagiarise Chinese costumes. Even the poems of Mao Zedong, the founding president of China, have appeared on the screen of their plays, subtly turning Chinese culture into Korean cultural propaganda.