The Book of Shadows Is Missing! I CHARMED

[mitche]

"to vanquish your sister....I think I'll sit this one out" :) I miss Cole :)

[steevenhyde]

Holly is such a great actress, she can cry in cue, she has such good comedy timing.

[skynetprime]

It was beyond hilarious how Cole just sat down and left Phoebe to chase after Piper alone 😆

[KasaiWolf]

lmao that subtle "Oh no" from Phoebe is just perfect.

[sandiego]

I like how Piper's hair, top and bottom all have matching color. Looks nice on her. Especially with that silk hair.

[jessedellross]

Piper is so funny here. So is Cole. So is pheobe.

God I love them and Leo together. The real power of 3

[sifilore]

Cole's funny but right to sit this one out. All of Paige's spells were selfless, consequence free. Only with that dirtbag wasn't. But can't really blame her for doing so, even if it did get out of control.

[LeniiNero]

It was really their fault for not explaining the consequences sooner to her.

[aaliyahlovato]

Don’t get me wrong now, I love the show as a whole! It’s just something about “The Paige era” that speaks more to me. She came into the show at a dark time & provided a sense of comfort. She was a breath of fresh air! It was cool seeing Piper becoming the eldest living sister, Phoebe the middle, Paige the youngest. The dynamic change & I love seeing them adjust to that. Ughh so good. “Hell Hath No Fury” one of the best episodes in the entire series.

[Gor]

So cute :) Piper is so funny here. And Cole

[DoubleHeader]

Piper’s face and response at the beginning😂.

[juju-zrdp]

S4 is so interesting. It has almost as many excellent episodes as s3. Alot of good episodes the first half even if most were filler until "Charmed And Dangerous". It was the beg of Phoebme the later half . Maybe I saw the season too many times. I also really like "Bite Me". Supposedly alot of Paiges lines of distrusting cole were intended for Prue . Imagine if they didn't have the sam/ patty storyline fall back on? I don't think the season would have worked with anyone BUT Rose Mcgowan. She was perfect .

[CosimasNiehaus]

The way Phoebe stops Cole from shimmering away always tickled me as a kid and rewatching as an adult it still makes me snort - no idea why

[ca.um]

I love season four. And I LOVE Paige. Rose is / was THE perfect addition to Charmed, following Prue’s exit of course. I said what I said 😭🤭👑👏🏻

[CamCam-mqji]

I liked Paige's job. I didn't like when she quit

[theessexriddler]

I wish prue stayed and that Paige was one of their daughter’s from the future. Would have been even better!

[ryanappleton]

Though Paige was wrong for taking the Book of Shadows out of the house after Phoebe told her it doesn't leave, her heart was in the right.

Yet the controversy lies in what is considered personal gain. Since she used magic to help her colleagues (Billy's acne, Lila's car loan and the extension for the O'Brien application) and improve their lives.

[ChrisWolff]

0:00-0:01 This face needs to be framed and sent to both the TV Hall of Fame and to Holly's house. The second greatest facial expression she ever made on this show.

[Asmodeus]

I don’t remember the whole episode - did the writers ignore Personal Gain and let all these spells slide lol?

[ShielaM-pw]

I hate that they got rid of prudence, but the paige episodes were just as great.