clubhousecancer.com

[tommclarty]

Gary never had the makings of a varsity athlete.

[basketballplayer]

Funniest part was jimmy throwing it back perfectly

[djduejdbt]

Haven't seen this in a while. It was hilarious the first time I saw and and have to say it holds up. Still hilarious.

[kennyvega]

The smile Jimmy gives to the camera when he sees Gary walking back to pitch is so telling 😂
He knew he was gonna fuck it up😂gary is such a tool

[kemowasabi]

Even better, Robin went on Kimmel soon after, and nailed a perfect throw 😂

[Frankybroadcast]

As soon as that glove came out, you can see BaBaBooey's face drop. Lol

[erics]

“No I can throw just not that day!” One minute later hits a guest in the head with a baseball

[CoCoBaunz]

he just be smacking those choppers. he's nervous lol

[hinkhall]

He fails the exact same way every time. It deviates to the right.

[JakeBaker]

Jimmy hits him in the chest every time! Nice arm

[thielees]

Gary is like the Zapruder Film: Back and to the right. Back and to the right.

[pugjab]

I love how Gary never looks at The crowd. Just eye contact with jimmy.

[tastethejace]

2:19 HAHA I love Kimmel's shit-eating grin into the camera. He just knows this will end up terrible (which means hilarious).

[carlmarston]

“Nohhh I can throw I can throw. Just not that day” idk Gary

[Bigmike-yqfr]

Wow I actually feel bad for Gary holy shit

[dessertlocust]

hard too see video with the studio lights reflecting off his teeth

[reddwood]

RIP to Susan the woman in the audience. Most people don’t know that she died not long after this from a brain hemorrhage. Although never proven her family believes this incident may have been the cause. I think they hold Jimmy accountable more than Gary from what I’ve heard

[kennyryan]

Love the way he wants the ground to swallow him up at 0:52 😂 Gary must be the most overpaid and overrated person in Showbusiness

[stuckinthepastproductions]

2:55
He's loosing his mind lmao!

[DrHUGEshow]

A life long baseball fan and little league coach horrified when Jimmy pulled the glove out HAHAHA