DEBATE: Jay Dyer vs. Jake the Muslim Metaphysician (Trinity vs. Tawhid)

Consider supporting The Muslim Metaphysician
Kindly donate to contribute to ongoing expenses:

[CoachZahabi]

Dear Jay, if something is “self-evident” then by definition it doesn’t need “justification”.

Moreover if you insist everything needs justification then we have the problem of infinite regress.

[BroRizwan]

Woke up for fajr.Alhamdulillah brother Jake defending Islam

[libanali]

I don’t think the average Christian understands the trinity. They just simply believe it because they were told to

[sh-engy]

He knows and does not know at the same time, very Trinitarian lol

[TheProofLady]

Jay went from defending Justin Martyr as a trinitarian with his CC video, to calling him a heretic here lol 😂😂😂

[homtanks]

Masterclass performance brother Jake 🤝🏻, may Allah make you even more knowledgeable 🤲🏻

[tuanmohdarfantuankhusairry]

Jay when he realized he cannot use "circular Argument" : 😮

[mukhtar]

No one can defend better than Islam.
Its simple.
Rest they are like roller coasters.

[shadmankhan]

May Allah SWT bless you brother Jake, ur work is much appreciated

[crespo]

Wait, why did he mention Ibn Taymiyyah’s concept of Christian theology😂 that has nothing to do with the debate. We could just as easily do the same on a larger scale by proving his “saints” had zero clue about Islām and made zero compelling arguments.

[lukezdraw]

I love the clear difference of the comments between this video on this channel and jay's/other channels. Us muslims gives cheers to jake and appreciate him for defending islam, we mostly focus on our side. Yet everywhere i see a christian comment, most of them only throw out insults to our side as if our mere presence is a threat lol, it shows the standard emotional reaction between both sides. Makes me proud.

[Nobody-yqfk]

Jay duet is a psuedo intellectual. He’s studied secular philosophy enough to the point that whenever he is put into a hole in a debate he claims that the person he’s talking with is “contradicting themselves” or “a logical fallacy”. He uses philosophical standard to substantiate his belief, yet if he was so fundamentally logical, he’d realize that 3 in 1 is a logical fallacy for a creator, who created everything, and was not created.

[muhammadgwarzo]

Jay' s questions have nothing to do with Tauhid or Trinity

[helsharidy]

Jay thinks his worldview is the best but is too shy to put it up there and express it, in his opening. All he does is sit back and say Jake doesn't understand the position but there's no position he even posited, a big failure in his presentation.

[RoyalBlue]

Alhamdulilah.. I wakeup about to pray suddenly realised Jake is here defending Islam. May Allah bless this brother. These reverts invest i inestimable amount of Time spreading the Message than those born into Muslim families, (specifically myself) their commitment embarrassed me and i envy people like Jake Sub'han-Allah.

[Sheragust]

This is one of the weakest debate performance I've seen from Jay

[MOnir]

Well smashed him Jake. Baraka allahu fik from Lombok Indonesia!

[quranchannel]

So proud of Jake. May ALLAH reward you. Ameen ya RABB

[sweetcell]

Isn’t Dyer getting a bit ad hominem when he inflects into a sort of pseudo homeboy down in the hood voice? I think the moderator needs to pull him up on that stuff. Dyer is a decent dude, but he might be getting too gangster since his discussion with Sammy. He’s not made yet, but he’s already talking like he’s a skipper.

[Yugo]

Crazy to see in the channel of modern day debate all the comments of the cricisboys thinking jay won something here