Prom Night Murders | The Unsettling Case of Jeff Pelley

On Sunday April 30th of 1989, the police arrived at the Pelley families parsonage to a scene that was utterly disturbing.
The Prom Night Murders are going to really make you question if the person behind bars is really responsible. That person's name is Jeff Pelley.

SUBSCRIBE TO MY SECOND YOUTUBE FOR MORE CREEPY CONTENT WITH MY TWIN BROTHER

Also, a HUGE shout out to "CounterClockPodcast" for most of the information used in this video. Go checkout their entire series on the Jeff Pelley Case.

High Time Crime is a true crime account that's dedicated to bringing you some of the most unsettling and creepy cases. We are not responsible for any information that is inaccurate as we are only using the sources we have given.

Now, I'm not saying that Jeff Pelley is innocent, but there certainly are some interesting discrepancies in the police investigation and the entire case itself that make you wonder.

Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.

Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.

#truecrime #crime #solved #jcs #jcsinspired

[j.sargent]

Him and his grandparents didn't even realize the police were already blaming him during that interrogation... crazy. I feel bad for him, losing his family then being blamed for it...

[joshuajones]

These cops' incompetence or blatant tampering is crazy

[barrykennethdaniel]

If cops had to do prison time and pay compensation personally for the cases they get wrong I'm sure they wouldn't rush to judgement so fast.

[ANDREA-kkgx]

So innocent with her thinking the caution tape had to do with their dog.. heartbreaking man..

[Timmeh_The_tyrant]

How any jury could convict the dude on such nothingness is insane I do not understand the thought processes of our fellow human beings

[hightimecrime]

Hello friend! This is a bit longer video then I normally do and so it took me a while, but it's here, The Jeff Pelley Case. This is a very interesting video and has many twists and turns that make you wonder if the true culprit really is Jeff. Let me know your thoughts and opinions below and what case do you want me to do next? I also plan on being much more active now on and hope you all are too!

[mayorofmischief]

“Guilty beyond a reasonable doubt” really does only apply when we feel like it lmao

[TheTaurean]

Keep doing longer videos. I was captivated the entire video. Waiting for more and more info. Your storytelling skills are even better on longer video. In short. KEEP DOING THEM! 🗣👏🏾

[kellig.]

I always felt this young man was not guilty of this crime. ❤

[MsMeece-gkem]

The Counter Clock podcast was incredible. I was hooked right away, and ended up binge listening all the seasons over a 3-4 day span. Highly recommend.

[danniitheaussie]

Loved the longer video, thank you!
I think Jeff is innocent, even just going by his initial interview with his Grandparents present. I've watched a lot of interrogations, I just can't see him remaining so calm and well spoken if he was guilty, he would have had to be a very good actor!

[genesisv]

asking kids who you didn’t even invite to the wedding after the death of their mother to ask you mom is actually so beyond messed up… not that they deserved this death but so much of this is messed up :(

[traceymarrero]

I'm really happy I stumbled into your channel, you really do a great job! I know it takes a lot of time and effort to get these stories out and it shows that you're putting the time in, so thank you!! As for this case....I don't understand how they're comfortable convicting a man with such horrible "evidence". I really hope this poor guy gets out, he doesn't deserve to be there. It's a heartbreaking story and the true killer needs to pay for what they've done.

[brianallison]

There was a film on this by the "Evil Lives Here" series I believe. The stepsister was the one reciting life with him growing up and claimed he was crazy the whole time and did abusive things to her. It didn't mention many of the inconsistencies this does. Strange indeed

[fuzzyfotch]

Interesting story I have been following - I love your take on cases - you tell the story in a superb fashion .. keep up the good work, friend.

[kitsamariahansen]

I really like the way you tell the “story” - you’re a GREAT narrator my friend 👍🏼😃 I’m now OFFICIALLY a HTC GEEK… Appreciate all your efforts and all the work you put in your videos!
“Thank you!” all the way from here in Denmark 🇩🇰😃🤜💥🤛

[laurenellingwood]

First things first, I’m in LOVE with your editing!! Your videos are always SO entertaining to watch, I also didn’t know you played guitar 😉 but also???? What the heck people?!? Jeff OBVIOUSLY didn’t do it!!! I think all signs point to Phil and HIS family!!!! I hope Jeff’s new lawyer will bring justice!! Anywho, I can’t wait for the next video!!!!

[dawnbreak]

An entire congregation in a small town and not one could suggest the children being fostered with them? Or even more so they couldn't adopt these children. What a great community filled with " God" 🙄

[momsbaloney]

How do you only have 11k subscribers? I’m sure that’ll change soon lol. You’re a good narrator. I like your 80/90s style goin on. Not many people can pull off a stash like that. Pls keep it

Edit; just realized you started released videos not long ago 😂

[tkdb]

I'm loving the way you say parsonage. In Australia we pronounce it 'parsonidge'
I keep waiting for someone in the story to go back there 😀.