Idle Comparison: Idle Gel Foam vs. Gel Plush

Full Indepth review →Coming Soon

Memory foam has been around for decades. The material type gained popularity due to its unique ability to conform to the curves of any body type. However, there were problems. It retained heat and caused sleepers to feel like they were stuck in their mattresses.

Over the years, clever mattress companies have taken initiatives to reduce these negative side effects while maintaining the desired contour and pressure point relief. Idle has recently produced two mattresses using their take on memory foam, and we had the chance to take a side-by-side look at each to help you decide if either could be a good solution for you.

In an effort to help you make an informed decision, we’re always hard at work here at mattress central seeking out all the tools and resources you need. Here are all the links referenced in our review. I highly suggest checking them out before you buy!

Something many consumers get, well, consumed with when they shop is the cost. When you compare the Gel Foam and Gel Plush mattresses, it’s clear the Gel Foam is cheaper. Don’t get me wrong, here. It could be a better option for you than the Gel Plush, but not just because it’s easier on the wallet. At a glance, the Gel Foam is a good fit for:
People looking for a plusher feel
People with a BMI of between 18-22
Although the Gel Plush is more expensive, the added investment will pay off in the long run if:
You’re looking for a firmer feel.
You have a BMI higher than 22.
You want the option with a higher durability expectation.
Here at The Sleep Judge, we’re not here to sell you a particular mattress. We’re here to guide you to the one that’ll work best in a sea of products that grows larger just about every day. And we don’t stop at mattresses. Our review team looks at everything from bedding and pillows to snore devices, hammocks, camping gear and more. Don’t miss out on new innovations designed to give you a restful night’s sleep. Subscribe to our channel!

The Sleep Judge is the top source for sleep product reviews including mattresses, toppers, outdoor sleep gear and more. Want to know which mattress outperforms the rest in terms of comfort and durability? Looking for other sleep product reviews on pillows, sheets, toppers, protectors etc? The Sleep Judge has the answers.

Disclosure: We receive free products from brands so that we can test the product; however, we are under no obligation to provide a favorable review or endorsement of this product. The Sleep Judge retains full editorial control over the content in this video and has not accepted any monetary compensation from the respective brands.

This video and description contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links and purchase a product, I’ll receive a small commission. This helps support the channel and allows us to continue to make videos like this. Thank you for the support!

[lonniechamberlain]

I’m amazed how underrated this channel is! The thoroughness and data collected is very impressive!

[JoeJock]

Honestly hard to believe this only has one comment and so few views. I've just started looking into some mattress options and watched a few of the other reviews out there. This review is incredibly thorough with solid data to actually measure the different characteristics of the daunting number of options out there. Great job and thanks!

[philipbaldwin]

I am a little confused. You’re saying the Gel Plush is firmer than the Gel Foam?

[stevenwhirls]

This mattress sounds like what I need for a good night's sleep. This would be great to win.

[JohnSmith-mlyh]

I own this mattress and I’m 5’10” 275 and this baby is so freaking comfortable! Plus it’s insanely temperature neutral and you don’t get hot on it! I’m buying another Eastern King and doubling them up for a double king! Best Mattress we’ve ever slept on!

[scottwmoxham]

Wonderfully detailed video! Thank you.

[arnie]

Thank you, this was an amazing review. Made my mind up based on what you said.

[kristinekerr]

Great review!! Please review the WinkBed Gravity Lux...specifically the soft version. As a person w/ RA and chronic pain so therefore mobility issues I need a pressure relieving mattress that won’t give me a stuck feeling. I thought memory foam would make it harder to move around. For reference I’m 120# and am a back and side sleeper. I do like a softer feel. I bought the WinkBed Softer mattress (hybrid model) and it is not soft enough. I do like to sink in a little. The bed is beautiful and luxurious just not as soft as I thought. It’s more of a 6 out of 10. I was hoping for more of a 4.5 - 5. Any suggestions welcome. Thx so much!

[lonniechamberlain]

I’m curious to why this mattress doesn’t make the top 10 list of memory foam mattresses. Makes me wonder how much these companies are paying to get included in those lists.

[hectordelrosario]

If you are planning to purchase from Idle Sleep, do yourself a favor and take 5 minutes first to check their reviews on BBB

[austincool]

The plush sinks in like crazy and I think it's too intense 275 lbs

[philipbaldwin]

I’ve read several bad reviews on Idle Sleep’s customer service and their honoring their warranties and sleep trials. I’m so on the verge of ordering from them but every time I’m about to do so, I find a terrible review of this company.